It has been a long road, but the Republican Party’s embrace of the idea of privatizing Medicare via a voucher system is now complete. The GOP will add Paul Ryan’s plan to turn Medicare into a voucher program to their official party platform, based on a draft version likely to be ratified. From Bloomberg:
“While retaining the option of Medicare in competition with private plans” the platform called for “transition to a premium-support model for Medicare,” which would give recipients an income-adjusted subsidy to buy insurance.
Medicare should “change from an unsustainable defined- benefit entitlement model” to the “defined contribution model,” the platform draft said. And a “more realistic” eligibility age than the current standard of 65 should be set to reflect “today’s longer life span,” the document said.
The Republican embrace of this very unpopular idea began in earnest in 2011 when House Republicans voted for it as part of the Paul Ryan budget. Even after this event, though, there was still a good chance the Party would back away from the idea after witnessing the political blow back it caused. There was real concern among many top Republicans that the idea went too far and could damage the GOP brand. Even Newt Gingrich, while running for the Party’s nomination and trying to appeal to Republican primary voters, first worked to distanced himself from it by calling it “radical.”
The presidential election created an opening that could have allowed Republicans to back away from this plan. The acceptance of a new leader who was trying to reach out to swing voters was a real opportunity to abandon an unpopular proposal. Their presidential nominee could easily have created his own plan for Medicare that would have supplanted the Ryan budget’s ideas as the “official Republican plan.” Instead of doing this though, the Republican nominee has apparently decided to double down on privatizing and voucherizing Medicare. Mitt Romney didn’t just endorse the basic idea by selecting the idea’s architect, Paul Ryan, to be his running mate. Adding the idea to the party platform is now the cherry on top, officially stating this is what the Republican Party now stands for.
This is more than a proposal from simply a top Republican leader or an idea popular with some Republicans in Congress. This is now what the Republican Party is about. Republican candidates at all levels are now inescapably tied to it.
This is a rather remarkable move by a party given that only a year ago this Medicare issue was seen as costing Republicans a solidly red congressional district in New York.




22 Comments

Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About FDL Action
And GOP/Tea Party voters are all now clapping, cheering & doing the happy-happy dance because of Ryan’s privatizing Medicare. Not snark.
Believe me, the Tea Party has been *heavily* brainwashed to sniff Ayn Rand’s panties (just like Poodle Ryan does) and drink the ersatz “Libertarian” Kool Aid. My rightwing family members have been dissing and poo-pooing Medicare for quite a few years now because they “believe” that they should be “self-reliant” and not expect “hand outs.”
No appeals to factual reality – such as that we’ve all PAID INTO Medicare, so it’s not a “hand out” – have any effect.
Sad to say, I do NOT see this as a negative for the GOP. I think the party faithful are blissfully delighted by this move.
Translation: it means it’ll be harder for poor people & minorities to get “free” medical care. w00t! WIN!!! Yay.
I think this is a signal that the Party establishment believe that through vote suppression they have the election in hand. The proposal will cost votes where they don’t need them, and they seem to think they will be able to hold the T-baggers. Since a significant portion of Democratic House members will support some version of the proposal as part of a ‘Grand Compromise’ (in which they get nothing), a Romney victory could ensure its passage in the first year of his Presidency.
I think Vouchers are in our future, no matter who “wins” the
Kabuki Show gameelection.Tea Partiers have been brought to heel on this issue by and large, mainly through the auspices of Glenn Beck.
Obviously the party faithful (aka the universally misinformed ignorant morons) are indeed dancing on the country clubs. BUt the more the GOP moves to the extreme right wing of the party the more regular people they alientate. Their “big tent” concept is working in reverse. Not that that is a bad thing.
The GOP is doing on a national level what Rick Perry did. Slowly but persistently shoot off one toe at a time until you can’t balance yourself anymore.
I’d like to think you’re wrong, but unfortunately I think you’re on the money.
Good pointsd all. I DO think the GOP believes they will win this election and do as you say with the help of the gutless democratic party. IMO, theymay have trouble with the senate, esp since harry Reid apparently has found himself a pair as of late.
But, there is one thing they are not counting on. Romney is gonna lose. Every week either he, Ryan or some other dimwit in the party sticks their size 12 foot in their mounth and the proverbial mouth of the party. Right now, regardless of the popular vote, Romney has NO way to get teo 270 electoral votes.
just wait till the white folk dont have the excuse of the black guy giving away all the money to his brothers.
then you will see the realizations set in.
beside that these tea bags who are obviously the far right in this country have no qualms about voting against their own interests or the interests of their children.
in fact its as if they invite it!
and THAT is why you see these type of things from the republican party.
just watch them cheer (if you are a masochist) romney at the convention when he tells them how he intends to lower taxes on the rich and raise theirs.
and btw…..people who are against this needed worry because it requires 60 votes in the senate the democrats told us to get anything done even when you hold 59 and the other 2 branches of government.
so no chance this could actually happen.
lol…wanna bet?
ACA was just the first nail in the Medicare coffin. By the time I retire (not that much further down the road), Medicare will be a thing of the past, at least in its present format.
No appeals to logic, facts or reasoning will make any difference. It’s all about funding BigIns, etc. Definitely NOT about providing decent reliable health care services to the 99%. Of course, the 1% could give a shit cuz they’re so rich off of our tax dollars that they can buy whatever they need and want.
Medicare & the Veterans Health Care programs have been proven endlessly to be cost-effective and efficient at providing good health care to seniors and Vets. There is absolutely NO reason to privatize either program. Rather they should be expanded to become a Nat’l Health care system.
Not gonna happen. Never. Privatization, here we come! And with it: ever shittier and costlier and less effective & efficient health care. Team USA, Fuck Yeah!
Drive a stake through these zombies worshipers of MAMMON.
Who the fuck wants to profit off of suffering and death ?
Must be those Hypnotoad eyes of Ryan
You should hope so, in it’s present format the Trust Fund will be depleted and there will be major shortfalls.
This is a win-win. Whatever happens to the Romney candidacy, the Republicans can demonstrate enough voter support to allow Obama to do what he wants to do with SS and Medicare.
And these guys criticize Obamacare and disown romeycare? Gimme a break with the illogic of this bullshit.
Ok so now its up to the American voters who I have no faith in at all. The fact that the Republicans have no fear in even promoting this voucher system tells me that they are very much in tune to how stupid the people are that we live next door to. We constantly pick apart the elected officials when the real culprits are the voters. Put the blame where it should be.
Newcarguy I have been a member of FDL for a few years and I read your comments and others daily and I think you are very bright and well informed but this time I think your wrong. With all of the f—ups the Repubs have been making lately Obama can’t keep more than a few points ahead of Romney. Its clear that the voters do not want to vote for him. I think many are going to stay home and Obama is going to lose.
The Rs are playing fast and loose with Medicare. They make a lot of noise about the 716b cuts and they lie about what it is and say doctors will be cut. Not that I can see. When they repeal Obamacare they plan to restore those 716b of savings and then they want to use it for tax cuts. Pay attention to these guys.
DD’s previous post states:
Not sure what you mean by doctors will be cut, but their pay will be, and if they get fed up with that, they’ll stop seeing Medicare patients which is the same thing as cutting doctors.
Every year for years they threaten to cut Dr’s reimbursement by about 8% and then there is a vote to restore it. Usually happens around end of June. Other times money is restored retroactively. You are correct that an good percentage of Drs. would quit, which would cause their patients to wake up a bit re: the issues at hand, instead of the commonly seen “I’ve got mine, Jack.” attitude. The other cut that is also unlikely to be cut is Bush plan “Medicare Advantage”, a for profit, gov’t subsidiized giveawy to the insurance banks. This is a managed care plan that works great for oldtimers until they get sick.
They need to get rid of the bulk of the B-bommers and the only way to do it is cap their care somehow. Soon the new Reptile/ Dinocrat plan called
MediIdon’tcare will only allow treatment for really important stuff like hang nails and bad breath, not so much for heart disease and cancer anymore though.
I agree, but the amount increases every year. This from the Medicare Trustees Report:
The financial outlook for Medicare is also uncertain because some provisions of current law that are designed to reduce costs may not be sustained. The clearest example of this issue is the sustainable growth rate (SGR) formula for physician fee schedule payment levels. The projections in this report assume that, as required by current law, CMS will implement a reduction in Medicare payment rates for physician services of more than 30 percent at the start of 2013. However, it is a virtual certainty that lawmakers, cognizant of the disruptive consequences of such a sudden, sharp reduction in payments, will override this reduction just as they have every year since 2003.
The Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act, as amended by the Health Care and Education Reconciliation Act of 2010, is another, and even larger, source of policy-related uncertainty.
MEdicare and SS…. Dems platform is death by a thousand cuts or GOP platform. death by a sledge hammer,,the vast number of Americans do not want this to happen and neither party will listen. Great times we live in. Money talks and the American people can go take a hike. I am voting 3rd party,,,
It’s amazing that Obama is even still in the race. The employment numbers are awful, many people believe he raised taxes, the economy is in terrible shape, Citizens United put billions from unknown and unknowable sources into the election (fully 90% going to Mittens et al) and yet .. . Obama is running neck in neck.
He should, by all accounts, be out of it by now, and still people believe in hope and change, want him to win, and know that he has made very few mistakes in his first four years. If we’ve learned anything at all, we’ve learned that the Rs are willing to put the country “on the table” when it comes to elections.
I hope no one expects much when Obama IS reelected. It seems that the most he will be able to do is slow the trend toward feudalism.