If you look at President Obama’s State of the Union address as primarily a political speech to kick off his re-election effort, you get a strong sense of what the Obama campaign thinks are his strengths and weaknesses.
The auto rescue and several foreign policy successes made up a huge part of the speech. But if you weren’t paying extremely close attention, you may have missed Obama’s few passing references to his signature health insurance law.
As best as I can tell, these are the only references to the Affordable Care Act in the entire speech:
I will not back down from protecting our kids from mercury pollution, or making sure that our food is safe and our water is clean. I will not go back to the days when health insurance companies had unchecked power to cancel your policy, deny you coverage, or charge women differently from men. And I will not go back to the days when Wall Street was allowed to play by its own set of rules.
[...]
That’s why my education reform offers more competition, and more control for schools and States. That’s why we’re getting rid of regulations that don’t work. That’s why our health care law relies on a reformed private market, not a Government program.
On the other hand, even my Republican friends who complain the most about government spending have supported federally financed roads, and clean energy projects, and federal offices for the folks back home.
That’s it: in the entire 7,000 word speech, there are only two lines, one of which ignores the proposed large expansion of government Medicaid, sandwiched between other unrelated talking points.
I take this as a strong sign that the Obama campaign is basically admitting they simply can’t win the politics on Obamacare. It’s a sign they believe their best political approach is just to ignore the issue as much as possible in the campaign. The law was unpopular when it passed and is still unpopular to this day. There is no reason to believe it will get any more popular by November.
In the auto rescue case, the policy was actually implemented right away, and now we are seeing results. In contrast, most all of the health care law and its promised benefits won’t even start to be implemented for another two years. Obama simply can’t campaign successfully on health insurance reform when there are few tangible benefits from his signature law, and the health insurance coverage situation is now worse than when the law was passed.
This strategy of mostly ignoring health care may even work politically for Obama if Mitt Romney wins the Republican nomination. Given the incredible similarity in their health care laws, Romney is going to have a tough time successfully hitting Obama on the issue without leaving himself vulnerable.




29 Comments

Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About FDL Action
Nader on democracynow this morning: There was no mention of Occupy in SOTU.
The crux of SOTU was about the dog that didn’t bark.
POTUS Obama signaled was very important to him: the ongoing fellating of the 1%.
Obviously, if the SOTU speech is just Obama positioning himself for this year’s re-election campaign, and the Obama team believes strongly that Mitt Romney is going to be Obama’s competitor, then Obama will not make a strong focus on health insurance. This is because he has implemented Mitt Romney’s health insurance plan.
Throw in the reality that aspects of the “Affordable Care Act” that are all about guaranteeing health insurance and pharmaceutical corporation profits above guaranteeing anyone affordable health care are probably not very popular, and no, Obama doesn’t want to talk health care.
Plus, the publicly visible polling shows that the only real concern to the bulk of likely voters is the aspect of the economy that concerns most people: jobs and wages.
You don’t start talking about health care when you and the other guy are effectively identical and everyone wants to hear about jobs and wages.
Without Occupy, that would have been a totally different speech. It would have been debt reduction, debt reduction, debt reduction. Hats off to everybody that helped change the subject.
Why would you expect the protesters to be mentioned in this speech? They are persona non grata in political circles, to judge by all public reports.
Didn’t expect it.
Agree totally! Major change in discourse about America since OWS. It will continue because nothing has changed at the top. Also agree with previous comment this is preview of stump speech we will hear until November. Hope=Nope 2008-2012 America Built to Last = Americans will be last. 2012-2016
Yes, that’s probably true, and always: KUDOS to Occupy.
But still too much sucking up to the 1% for my liking.
Only slightly OT. If you’re sick of the lying and corruption of what passes for democratic government, find time to spend with your local Occupy contigent. It will provide many intangible rewards.
After watching what the man does over the course of the last three years, why would anybody care what he says?
Planning to take some more donations to OWS when I figure out whether they are going to be raided again & stolen by cops like my prior donations.
Health Care. Obama’s original signature issue. Now being tactically ignored because he didn’t do anything close to what he promised.
Obama is SOOOO lucky that the GOPer clown car is full of, well, clowns. If Obama wins this one, he’ll owe the win to the tea party.
Boxturtle (though the $1B he’s expecting from Wall St won’t hurt)
NYC is spending millions on police overtime. I think Berkley’s total expense is under $1K, mostly spent on the first two days.
Boxturtle (But the millions were covered directly by WallSt donations to the general fund)
Exactly….It’s not like folks aren’t aware,he is lying again it’s election time folks.
Why mention healthcare? It’s bad enough with America in servitude to, financial institution, energy corporations and the laws the “monied interests” buy preserving their business models, without mentioning the third leg of the trifecta; servitude to health insurance industry? The health insurance bailout act? Hostage taking….
Government which protects waste and inefficiencies in both the market place and its institutions cannot meet the needs of the governed. Advancement is stifled to protect cash cows, limiting choice.
Same bullshit on a different day. Couldn’t help but notice how he wants to staff the cops and fire departments with ex-military. Military on the border and military controlling future alternative energy. Can you say military take over of the government?
HCR will be billed as big accomplishment in his campaign speeches not covered by corp media.
Gotta give those storm trooper something to do.
Please tell me the cops aren’t stealing people’s coats and hats now.
In first OWS raid, anything that was not on peoples’ bodies was dumped into garbage trucks. As my donations were about $500 worth of sleeping bags, I assume they are now in landfill. Most of what I have left to donate is camping gear, not clothing, so if there’s another raid, to the dump again.
Once upon a time Obama told us he actually preferred a single payer system but we had to be pragmatic. Here is what he said May 14, 2009.
Now his tune had changed. I think it’s because now he thinks telling the full truth is more politically advantageous for him. Now he’s clear it’s not just pragmatism but his theoretical base. From the State of the Union on January 24, 2012:
The man wouldn’t want a ‘government program’ even if he could build it from scratch because he’s a Reagan Democrat who likes the idea of limiting government as much as possible and giving power instead to the for profit corporations.
Sorry to hear that.
I guess the proper opposing strategy to that is to make sure the sleeping bags are extremely inexpensive ones so the cost of paying the cops and clean up crews hurts the municipalities more than it does us to replace them.
I know that’s a silly notion, because there always seems to be money enough to push people around but never enough to help them, but still, maybe that’s the right tack.
Those are ones I’d had in my attic for 30 years since I stopped backpacking. They were like new, thus I gave the replacement value, in the sense that I used them only a couple of weeks/year, washed them and stored them properly when I came home. Cheap sleeping bags will not work in cold locations. Mine were good to temps down to at least zero, maybe lower, I can’t remember. When you are sleeping you are not moving, so generate no additional body heat. Thus need good insulation to keep body heat inside.
The remaining camping equipment I have in my attic is also from the way-back machine. Have an expensive small tent, but the rest is small stuff. But no point in having any of it end up in the dump.
In response to LibWingofLibwing @ 21
He made that speech just over the hill from where I live, LibWing, and it happened at a Town Hall Meeting on the economy in which the first questioner was asking him directly about his healthcare program, in light of Congress’s terrible treatment of singlepayer advocates at the hearings supposedly convened to fix the huge problems in the system.
Bravo to you for pointing out the shift in his rhetoric from a supposedly sympathetic argument to outright change of course. I would add that he has to do that because, as many of us knew then, the ‘huge disruption’ of which he spoke had already occurred.
“We don’t want a huge disruption…”
That huge disruption, it is now clear to everyone, was that big money had taken over politics and was running the country. Everything occurring now is a function of that disruption.
It is no small thing that Obama began the State of the Union address by wishing we were all behaving like the military. I would call that his significant, dangerous, (though oblique), attack upon OWS. Could not be plainer that he’d rather be Commander in Chief than President of the people, and if we don’t act like the military, be the military, the military is going to get us.
That’s his electoral promise.
I agree, sympathize and would do exactly the same thing. I’m just exploring the asymetric aspects of this occupation. Hitting where it hurts is what counts (the pocket book). “When you ain’t got nuthin, ya got nothing to lose.”
Don’t forget that last time, O told the SCOTUS he was disappointed with their Citizens United decision. I didn’t see some of those Supremes there this time. In a few months the SCOTUS will be reviewing Obamacare. They could embarrass him enough to defeat his re-election. If you don’t understand the semiotics of political texts, don’t try to deconstruct them.
I won’t get tired of writing anywhere that Obamacare is Unaffordable for
a lot of people,check only prices,copayments,deductibles and premiums,appaling! and a mandate!! and no single payer,po or universal..
Obama’s shooting down single payer by saying that we don’t want large government running health care while evoking Abraham Lincoln’s name made me ill. That phony lying sack of crap got elected by saying he was a single payer advocate. It was so central to his message during his campaign that after he was elected the country segwayed right into the health care debate without missing a beat. At which time we were repeated stabbed in the back by the audacious lying sack of crap, Obama, while he stayed creepily behind the scenes, of course. Hiding behind two smiling money drunk sociopaths, Lieberman and Baucus and let’s not forget the phony wooden grinning princess of death, impeachment is off the table, Pelosi.
Obama said Government should do what people can’t do for themselves. “That’s why our health care law relies on a reformed private market, not a Government program. ” A nice little public BJ for Wall street controlled death care and cancer industry that doesn’t work and rakes in Trillions annually breaking the backs of Americans by the millions.
Drones, Guantanamo, elite controlled health care, Isrealification of our Police force, Indefinite detention. Obama is a nightmare. The well dressed, soft spoken, walking death. Maybe he is the antichrist. He sure as hell fits the definition.
Obama Swipes at Single Payer in State of the Union
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CyNrrMjmf7g&feature=g-u-u&context=G292e681FUAAAAAAAIAA
Hey! We did that 2 years ago. All over and done with. Look ahead. Turn the page, (I hear that one more time , I’ll wretch!). Historic legislation. If you just disregard the fact that while doing a few good things, ( kids ’til 26, pre existing conditions, yada, yada, yada), we’re still hostages to health insurance companies, big pharma, etc., are going broke for even lousier coverage and STILL don’t have universal coverage, we did what no other administration since Teddy Roosevelt has been able to do, (whatever that is).