The new, expensive backscatter x-ray scanners installed at airports have already been shown to be fairly worthless because they can’t stop a determined individual from smuggling contraband onto an airplane in a body cavity. But that’s not all; it appears the scanners can easily be defeated by a kitchen rolling pin and a roll of tape.
According to a new paper (PDF) in the Journal of Transportation Security by Leon Kaufman and Joseph W. Carlson (via Slashdot):
It is very likely that a large (15–20 cm in diameter), irregularly-shaped, cm-thick pancake with beveled edges, taped to the abdomen, would be invisible to this technology, ironically, because of its large volume, since it is easily confused with normal anatomy. Thus, a third of a kilo of PETN, easily picked up in a competent pat down, would be missed by backscatter “high technology”. Forty grams of PETN, a purportedly dangerous amount, would fit in a 1.25 mm-thick pancake of the dimensions simulated here and be virtually invisible. Packed in a compact mode, say, a 1 cm×4 cm×5 cm brick, it would be detected.
It appears the only thing needed to defeat the new porno scanners is to mold the plastic explosives into a thin irregular shape next to the body so the scanner reads the mass as additional stomach fat. While not specifically addressed in the paper, one might assume other thin objects could also be easily hidden under an irregular pancake masked as part of the human body.
In other words, the porno-scanners appear to “work” only if we assume potential terrorists will be nice enough to hide explosives as easily recognized bricks. That is why it is called “security theater.”



18 Comments








Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About FDL Action
I’ve said before this exercise is meant to accustom us to being radiated by the government. Eventually the technology will improve and they’ll be able to see clearly inside your butt. By then you’ll be so pacified you won’t even care.
“Thus, a third of a kilo of PETN, easily picked up in a competent pat down, would be missed by backscatter “high technology…”
and this is OLD SCHOOL smuggling tech. Ive read thats how a lot of playdough-like raw Heroin has been coming into the country for decades, rolled up in thin sheets.. they dont actually want to stop the Heroin trade though, it keeps a few million poor people out of action and its extremely proffitable
Should be able to put this to the test by seeing how chicken cutlets show up (I don’t mean this offensively, but these devices for women are the same kind of flesh-like body-hugging irregular shapes as described). Of course, airport security theater is all super-secret with no oversight so who knows if they even bothered to test such obvious things.
Holy Shit! Is this for real? But, but, but, Judge Chertoff would never try to fool us, would he? He was a Judge for chrissake! Can we get our hands on this PDF directly from the cited journal?
ewwww
PDF is downloadable there.
Since they’re only a few Million apiece, do you expect them to like, actually detect weapons technologies? That will require a lengthy (and extremely costly) upgrade, which will likely inconvenience the hapless air traveler at some airports which are located in the most
terror resistanthigh threat areas forweeksmonthsquite some time.Carrying PETN onto a plane is not the same as getting an explosive device onto a plane. PETN does not explode when it is lit afire, as the so-called “Christmas Bomber” allegedly tried. The “C.B.” had no bomb. He had PETN taped to his body, which doesn’t explode when lit. It would require a detonator to make PETN dangerous.
This is exactly the type of thing that you hear in the news that just makes you wish you didnt have to live in such an absurd period of history. I mean…how do you even acknowledge stuff like this? Everything has gotten so ridiculous that anything, in reality, is exactly the complete opposite of what it appears. There could not be less of a point to these “security measures” besides corporate profit (Chertoff) and O trying to show he can be an authoritarian, too. My head just hurts.
Great post, Jon. Recommended.
I like Teddy’s Terror Theater™ myself.
OT– Discussions with Canadian Nicole “Stoneleigh” Foss on the status of the Canadian real estate bubble. More here and here regarding the risks to Canadian pensions (hint: it’s the banksters).
What about putting it in the microwave?
Who approved this tech and said it was necessary foe Homeland Security? I smell a bribe.
Your assumption about objects hidden in the pancake are incorrect. Depending on the composition of the object, they might still be detectable. The paper was actually very careful not to make such claims, because they are not supported, and, in the face of it, not necessary, given the severity of the original claim.
There are worse things than something hidden in there, though– instead of reading the Slashdot analysis, take a look at the Ars Technica one (http://arstechnica.com/science/news/2010/12/imaging-specialists-tsa-scanners-can-miss-underwear-bombs.ars). In general, their science reporting will be far superior to Slashdot’s, and to anyone else’s that I’ve found. The comments can be very illustrative as well, as there can be multiple domain experts commenting on the article. For instance, this article: http://arstechnica.com/science/news/2010/12/a-tale-of-an-ingenious-experiment-with-a-dubious-interpretation.ars was followed by several comments explaining how a particular antibiotic worked and why E. Coli resistance wasn’t as big of a deal as it sounds.
I don’t see why detonation would be a problem. The majority of recreational and automotive push-button ignition switches produce the necessary energy to detonate PETN.
If you had PETN and a BBQ ignition switch from any hardware store you’d be set to go.
True.
Also, a custom detonator could be easily disguised and hidden in any number of consumer items that contain batteries.
My reply was meant for Nathan @ 13.
Funny what having javascript turned off does to a post :-)
Chertof is in on it. Lieberman is so hot for it, he is likely in on it too. Probably dozens of Congressman bought the IPO through shell corporations before it was foisted on the taxpayers. Such is the state of affairs.
Public Servants like Dick Cheney and lessers have made millions off the war and MIC stocks.
PETN is not set off by an electrical charge, it is set off by a shock wave produced by an explosive charge called a detonator. The detonator is set off by the electrical charge.
You can get surface detonation of PETN from between 10-60mJ of electrical discharge.