Sometimes the often irresponsible behavior of the United States Senate rises to a new, more disgusting level that still manages to physically make me ill. Today, a bill that would provide help finding health care for the 9/11 rescue workers sickened as a result of their selfless actions failed in the Senate because it managed to only get 57 votes in favor (compared to 42 opposed). From the New York Times:
Republican senators blocked Democratic legislation on Thursday that sought to provide medical care to rescue workers and residents of New York City who became ill as a result of breathing in toxic fumes, dust and smoke from ground zero. [...]
In a vote largely along party lines, the Senate rejected a procedural move by Democrats to end debate on the 9/11 health bill and bring it to an up-or-down vote; 60 yes votes were needed, but the move received only 57, with 42 votes against.
Republicans have been raising concerns about how to pay for the $7.4 billion measure, while Democrats, led by Senator Kirsten E. Gillibrand of New York, have argued that the nation had a moral obligation to assist those who put their lives at risk during rescue operations at ground zero.
This is truly revolting action taken by Senate Republicans. Their decision to reward these heroes by dooming many of them to medical bankruptcy is made even more repulsive by the claim of concern over the $7.4 billion price tag while at the same time, their demand for a reduction in the estate tax will cost $68 billion. I frankly don’t know how they can live with themselves after taking this vote.
My anger is not just for the obstructionist Senate Republicans, but also falls on the spineless Senate Democrats.
In almost any other sane legislative chamber, a mere 57% majority would be enough to pass a bill. There is absolutely nothing stopping Harry Reid, Joe Biden, and 49 other Senate Democrats from taking 10 minutes to use a ruling from the chair to kill the filibuster and pass this bill. Senate Democrats–if they really wanted to–could pass this bill right now, regardless of how Republicans vote. Reid could take to the floor and declare “I will not allow Senate Republicans to crucify these American heroes on this cross of broken Senate procedure.”
Once again, Senate Democrats actually had the choice of protecting the ridiculous, broken rules of their chamber, or helping people in serious need. Sadly, like with every other fight this year, they showed what they most care about is the silly rules of their clubhouse.




47 Comments

Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About FDL Action
No one has done a good job of explaining to me why 9/11 recovery workers deserve a federal compensation package worth $740,000 per worker, in addition to a city settlement of $62,500, in addition to disability, workman’s comp and various other legal actions.
The U.S. pays $2500 to families of foreign civilians killed by U.S. troops. There is no standard policy for compensating the injured, and many receive nothing.
Every GOPer who voted against this should get commercials reminding voters of this when they run for reelection.
Every Dem who would not end the filibuster deserves to face a Primary.
Lets see Obama criticize the Left for standing up for 9/11 workers. Lets see the MSM keep silent again mourning their loss of independence.
This is the Christmas Season this is the real war on christmas. No healthcare for people made sick by 9/11. No unemployment extensions will mean how many kids won’t get presents this year?
When did Biden hand in his sack is Harry contagious?
Care for the Sick, Help the Unemployed thats Christmas thats the Left. Bill O’Reily whining about keeping government and church separate, whining about conspiracy theories that seem inspired by rum and Meth thats the Right’s idea of Christmas.
They are Form first we are Function.
Biden is sure building a resume of Spinelessness that I’m sure will ruin his dreams of being President heck Joe your killing your son’s hope for a political career too.
Let’s see, US: 57 THEM: 42. WE ….LOSE???
Batshit insane.
Which tells me more than anything else that this is just a fucking dance. Kabuki to fool the masses. They have to save that money to throw it at the rich people you see….
This illustrates just how criminal the Republicans are – they’re holding our “911 patriots” hostage until they get their way on tax cuts for their overlords, the corporatists in this country.
If anyone ever had a doubt about how disgusting and heartless the GOP is, there should be no further doubt.
Sadly, our government has become one huge chessboard. We, the people, are the Kingmakers as these congressmen line their pockets with bribery money thanks to Citizens United and our SCOTUS….while we sit back and watch the chicanery and shenanigans ad nauseum.
Do Republicans read the Bible and do the Opposite? I could have sworn Jesus said give up all of your goods to the poor if you would follow me.
Is Obama, Biden, Harry Reid and the entire Senate playing the role of Pontus Pilate this Christmas by not working to end the filibuster washing their hands of the whole matter?
Any rich person who collects the estate tax this year when 9/11 workers don’t get healthcare and the unemployed don’t get checks to buy their kids Christmas presents GOES TO HELL!
The prophet has spoken:)/s
My respect for Joe Biden disintegrated today. I can see his comment (take it or leave it) coming after copious amounts of blood, sweat and tears of ALL concerned parties coming to a compromise on something this critical.
But since they purposely eliminated all Dems from even being present at the table, how dare Biden have the audacity to come to those who were excluded from the process and insist that they take it or leave it.
This man doesn’t have a brain in his head.
Biden’s political days are now over.
Nah. Give Satan some credit for having standards.
Chess? More like Monopoly when they hold all the money and property.
The beginning of the end of our democracy (at least for me) came long ago. When this admin. took office on promises to clean things up and bring people to justice (meaning Bush and his criminal cabal) for torture, illegal spying, etc., etc. and this president uttered the words “we will not look backwards, but instead will only look forward”, it was immediately apparent that he either was denying spiritual law completely or had no intention EVER of doing anything he promised to do.
Anyone who has even the slightest notion of real spiritual law knows that in order to proceed forward, you must reflect back on injustices, wrongdoing, etc, in order to authentically move ‘foward’ and not repeat those mistakes but, instead, to right them and learn from them.
For me and my sense that this administration might be anything different than it’s predecessor, those hopes were dashed when I heard Obama utter those very ignorant (and telling) words.
I’m not sure if he is senile or drinking the cool aid but we need to make sure he is not the Dem front runner we need to make sure he knows it too no more free pass its time to take him down and this issue is more than enough to do it.
No Dem can win the Presidency without New York and Biden just lost that state today if he stays on the ticket next election.
7.4 billion is paltry in the scheme of things lately. They’re taking the piss out of it, really. 7.4 billion? I think Bill Gates SNEEZES 7.4 billion. WTF?!?!?!
GOP holds first reponders “hostage” to their tantrum to give their oligarch overlords more tax money! This should be headline news.
I know that they’ve marginalized Biden because of his honesty (which they affectionately dub ‘gaffs’) so I’m presuming that the genesis and willingness to sell his soul for this president is his own doing.
If so, his political aspirations are swirling the commode, too.
Ok they get to reincarnated as poor African Americans and poor rural Whites living during the Bush/Obama years. Funny how the GOP loves rural America but the kids in rural America leave the farms for the cities, the burbs and even the ghettoes.
Can you just imagine ANY Democrat running in 2012 against the OBAMA TAX BREAKS FOR THE RICH??
This is precisely why the GOP criminals are so willing to cut a deal before they take over the House in January.
If the progressives know what’s good for them and their democratic colleagues, they will trash this bill completely and let the BUSH TAX CUTS run out. This would force the GOP to do something about it or deal with the wrath of all americans.
If Obama is not astute enough to recognize this, surely Democrats in blue states running for re-election are.
Let’s fast-forward a bit…..to these $900 billion tax cuts now adding to our national debt. The Repukes will come in with a bang and justify neutering Obama’s health care plan, social security, medicare, and medicaid and have every justification now to do so.
Imagine how angry voters will be at Obama for permitting this to occur?
Mark my words – it will occur and the twisted republicans are salivating at the very thought of it all.
And if the Dems cave now and permit this to be dubbed “OBAMA’S TAX CUTS TO THE RICH” (making him a hypocrite as well), no Dem will be safe from being voted out of congress. This is why the Dems, particularly in blue states, need to hold firm and permit this bill to become a Republican problem in January.
I think they’ve neutered Biden, to tell you the truth. Frankly, I thought the man had more conscience than to be used as such an obvious pawn.
“I believe that the moment is near when by a procedure of active paranoiac thought, it will be possible to systematize confusion and contribute to the total discrediting of the world of reality.” Salvador Dali
Time for a change. We need to bring back the ~~~Edited by Moderator. Violence is not discussed nor condoned at FDL~~~
Has anyone actually gone back to look up Reid’s wrestling record? Did he, like O, conspire with his opponents to lose before the match began?
It was boxing, wasn’t it? Maybe Reid’s conscience took too many blows to the head.
I’m in total agreement with Jon and all the other commenters.
The Senate Democrats should stop cravenly surrendering to the increasingly batshit crazy Repugs and bring out the “Nuclear Option”.
Make it the simple majority of 51 votes to end any cloture, any lack of Unanimous Consent, and carry the day on any legislature up for voting.
And the Senate Democrats should use the “Nuclear Option” in just this way.
Bring up every single thing they want to pass, and pass the fookin’ things. Over and over again, nonstop, day and night until the Repugs surrender or this lame-duck session is over.
Cram it down the Repugs throat just like they had themselves threatened to use the “Nuclear Option”. Make ‘em squeal for mercy.
It’s been awhile since I’ve typed “Ds are too dumb ~~~Edited by Moderator~~~,” but now seems like a good time to repeat it.
~~~Mod Note: Not even as a rhetorical device~~~
Bravo! [standing and clapping]
And exactly right word, CHOICE. They CHOSE this outcome. And all politicians should be held liable for their choices.
Remember, watch what they DO, not what they say. And part of what they say is the theatre acts like these votes. Watch the RESULT. And judge them on that.
In fact, if I understand it correctly, it doesn’t have to be Harry Reid to start the process. It can be any Senator that objects, and therefore requests a ruling that gets rid of the filibuster. So ALL 57 DEMOCRATS that “said” they support this by “voting” for cloture, DID NOT support it with the act of starting the so-called nuclear option rolling.
Watch what they Do. Not what they “say.”
Could be Reid, Obama, Biden all seem to like to bend over and grab their ankles.
I’m not sure if they’re too dumb~~~Edited by Moderator. No advocating violence~~~
Assholes.
Scyphozoa are brainless, spineless and apparently heartless.
Yes, I just re-read the wiki on the “nuclear option” and ANY SENATOR can start the process by requesting a point of order. At that point it is in the hands of the President of the Senate to rule on the point of order.
So ANY ONE of the 57 D Senators who “said” they supported the bill by voting for cloture, could’ve ACTUALLY supported the bill by making a point of order. And all 57 CHOSE NOT to.
Sorry mods.
But when real human beings are suffering and real human beings are dieing because of the intentional acts of others, I get upset.
My bad.
The MOTU wants everyone who around and/or near Ground Zero on 9/11 dead. There’s literally hundreds of firefighters and rescue personnel on video tape that reported hearing explosions prior to the Twin Towers coming down and during the collapses.
The MOTU don’t want anyone contradicting their conspiracy theory.
All Senators are Leaky Weaks, OFG.
However, you’ve just shined a light on the truth … watch the roaches scurry away …
DW
Fine they all deserve a primary even Al Franken this is a stand and be counted moment not a minor point of concern for the Left for anyone who was hurt by 9/11 and cares for the unemployed at least on Christmas.
I don’t recall the Senate waffling like this when the Banks needed a bailout.
Don’t listen to me.
Listen to the dust covered firefighters themselves on 9/11.
http://911blogger.com/news/2010-10-06/new-video-911-firefighters-reveal-huge-explosions-towers-collapsed
Why not include in the bill that the revenues gained by letting the Tax Cuts for those making more than 250,000 and the return of the estate tax will pay for the care.
Thanks for editing my post. Did you actually think that in this day and age I want to bring back guillotines. It’s a metaphor for taking heads. Like voting them out. Like holding them accountable. I hate the death penalty!!!!! Please don’t become another HuffPo!
Uhh Jon, this doesn’t actually have to be voted on. Remember Baucus’s Montana Medicare deal? There was this corollary–
‘(B) OPTIONAL PILOT PROGRAMS.— The
Secretary may establish a separate pilot pro-
gram, in accordance with this subsection, with
respect to each geographic area subject to an
emergency declaration (other than the declara-
tion of June 17, 2009), in order to furnish such
comprehensive, coordinated and cost-effective
care to individuals described in subparagraph
(2)(B) who reside in each such area…
http://www.scribd.com/doc/33726977/Env-Emerg-Medicare-Cov
So Sebelius can expand Medicare to cover 9/11 rescue workers (actually she could make it broader than that depending on how big a geographic area she sets). How would we pay for it, what about the deficit?
That’s covered too, the HHS Secretary funds the pilot (Montana) and optional (say, New York) out of the Medicare trust funds, no furthercongressional votes or appropriations are required. The paygo (“budget neutrality”) rules specifically don’t apply; its impressive what Max Baucus is capable of when he applies himself.
The phrase that pays: the Secretary makes a “declaration of a public health emergency under section 104(a) of the Comprehensive Environmental Response, Compensation, and Liability Act of 1980“. I bet it would take a lot fewer of 57 senators being obstinate for that declaration to be issued.
A more accurate headline would be “Senate Screws 911 Rescue Workers Because They Don’t Give A Fuck About Them”.
Yeah, and most of us can’t even afford a house on Baltic Avenue!
You are simply asking the impossible, Democrats don’t have a backbone. I would say this is a failure of Democracy, but I get the impression that most people don’t care. The general attitude of “Greed is good” seems to belong elsewhere, not in the US. Maybe in ancient Rome.
This could have been part of Obama’s capitulation package, but he obviously didn’t care either.
I just don’t understand, really, how we slid downhill so fast. All we needed was one person to actually draw that line in the sand. Maybe it happened when all the WWII Democrats died.