Power in politics comes from the ability to destroy. The ability to take out an incumbent or end politicians’ careers if they cross you is how a group gains the power to influence policy in America. The Anti-Saloon League understood this concept well and used it to become one of the most powerful pressure groups in American history.
The league started in 1893 and by 1920, had led the fight to accomplish the difficult task of passing the 18th Amendment, mandating the prohibition of alcohol’s manufacture and sale. ASL founder Howard Russell understood the importance of retribution.
“The Anti-Saloon League,” Russell said, “is formed for the purpose of administering political retribution.”
This is from an excellent “Smithsonian” magazine article, “Wayne B. Wheeler: The Man Who Turned Off the Taps,” which examined how the Anti-Saloon League managed to become so politically powerful and achieve the impressive feat of pushing through the 18th Amendment. Wheeler was a member of the ASL executive council and its head Washington, DC lobbyist.
It is important not to underestimate how politically powerful the Prohibition movement was for a time and what a monumental achievement it is to pass a Constitutional amendment. It was able to get three-quarters of state legislatures to pass the 18th Amendment in 394 days. The ASL also went directly against and effectively killed what was the fifth-largest industry in the nation. Wheeler was the man Senators feared to cross.
The Anti-Saloon League understood that the carrot is important but the stick is critical. That, to quote Machiavelli, it is “safer to be feared than loved.” If you want to affect policy, you need to make those with the power–legislatures and governors in both parties–fear for their political careers if they cross you.
In 1905, the popular Ohio Republican Gov. Myron T. Herrick worked to make some changes to a local prohibition bill. The ASL organized more than 300 anti-Herrick rallies and mobilized supporters against him. Herrick was defeated, in a good year for Republicans.
Anyone running for office can promise interest groups to support their cause. Campaign promises are easy and cheap because politicians running for office don’t pass bills, only those already in office do. If you want your goals to be realized, sitting politicians must fear, more than anything else, retribution from failing to deliver to your group. This inherent understanding was part of Wheeler’s political genius. As he once told a friend:
“We are teaching these crooks that breaking their promises to us is surer of punishment than going back on their bosses, and some day they will learn that all over the United States—and we’ll have national Prohibition.”
If you want to be part of a successful political movement, you should study past, successful movements to understand how they gained power and achieved their goals. The Anti-Saloon League was for a time one of the most successful American interest groups ever. Studying it provides modern political movements with several lessons. The most important is that real power comes from the ability to administer political retribution. It is not just the ability to help people get elected but the cunning to take out those who have crossed you.
Take a moment to picture the big political groups that have been effective at advancing legislation, like the NRA. That’s an organization politicians fear.




22 Comments

Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About FDL Action
That Smithsonian article is good stuff. Interesting read for sure.
yeah as a person that loves the interplay between politics, policy, and outside interest groups it is great.
Excellent segue into helping Bill Halter unseat Blanche Lincoln. I have no axe in this, I’m in CA. But, Obama & team and the Washingtonian Dems we elected have done their darnedest to stack the deck for Lincoln. They will be hard pressed to write off this loss as easily as they did Martha Coakley’s!
PLEASE, let’s send our message loud & clear to Obama, Reid, Pelosi et al: Without OUR votes – they can NOT and will NOT win reelection.
http://www.actblue.com/entity/fundraisers/23963
Quote from Jane: “None of us can win the battle against a heavily armed corporate world by ourselves. We’re going to have to extricate ourselves, and our political dialogue, from the tribalism and demagoguery that facilitates corporate hegemony.”
Here’s a GREAT way to start! Do whatever you can to help Bell Halter beat Blanche Lincoln in tomorrow’s Ark. primary. If Obama & team can’t carry (dead weight) Blanche Lincoln to a win in this race they will have no one to blame but themselves for prioritizing a corporate agenda over the needs & wants of Democrats who elected them.
The choice is ours: Do something today, or whine about it on Weds.
https://secure.actblue.com/contribute/page/halter?refcode=header
My grandmother was an avid suffragette and also zealously worked for Prohibition. She saw to it that my older brother was a “blue-ribbon baby” meaning that he was going to abstain from using alcohol. He never was a heavy drinker but he had a beer every once in awhile.
I guess his case just goes to show that you can’t legislate against “vice.” You simply drive it underground. Would that we had learned that lesson and applied it to the disastrous war on drugs.
Dayam, Rachel Maddow just highlighted Jane’s dare for Blanche’s filibuster on the PO in drawing a primary opponent… Bill Halter…! ;-)
Nice. Fits very well with my subject matter right here, although the post was written well in advance of today.
As I’ve pointed out before, there are examples going back to the Middle Ages of what motivates politicians. Being nice to people isn’t one of them. Any who want to get re-elected will do what it takes to get re-elected. If you can’t prevent that from happening, or can’t limit their power in other ways, you don’t matter, and you will get no consideration.
There is one important difference between the example of Gov. Herrick and our current situation. It’s easier to keep pressure like that up if most politicians either don’t care or are scared already. That’s not the case today, clearly. At least, they’re not scared of us, and that’s even after having lost two Senate races – three if Halter wins tomorrow – in which progressives played some role.
Clearly, in this situation it’s going to take more than a couple of examples.
Part II? How to use the ASL model to pass a Constitutional Amendment designed to put “corporations in their place?” Retribution?
*heh* Jane certainly wields a hefty stick, eh…? ;-)
wasn’t LBJ one of those ball-busters (sorry if that is not the best phrase) who people feared to cross? He must have really been shocked when he had to exit from politics over the war.
LBJ never took no for an answer…! Moyers’ tale of LBJ’s words upon signing the Civil Rights Act is a very poignant tale of his deeds and actions…!
Given the chance that they might be the one Jane tries to find a primary opponent for next election cycle, I think most congresspeople would risk it. The odds are pretty low – one in, how many, eighteen, among Senate Democrats? There are some very dangerous people in DC who have plenty of money at their disposal – the sorts of people who can end careers. Just ask Elliot Spitzer or Eric Massa what happens when you stand up to them.
That’s why bailey’s quote @4 about getting over our differences is important. We’re competing with a lot of other folks, and they’re in a great position to push their agendas at our expense.
The same thinking that passed prohibition is alive and well today.
Pohabition was simply some wanting to make what they thought of as wrong, outlawed to suit their will.
Today it is Abortion, gay marriage, and a host of other things people wish to impose their beliefs on others, and make them do as they wish.
It goes much beyond those things, and we see conservatives wanting to make the Country do as they see fit. This is everything from doing away with Social Programs, and them getting everything they want.
They use Politics today the same way they got prohabition passed, by making people feared of not going along with them.
Most indubitably, Cujo…! You do mention the three D senate races, if Halter wins tomorrow… But, isn’t that still a wake up call, ironically, for both the Reichwingers, with the havoc the Tea Baggers have wrought, and, the Rahmbo DLC’ers…! ;-)
Case in point…! Ed Case is lost luggage…! ;-)
Jon, you’re point is very well made BUT for the life of me why the female population hasn’t come together like the ASL did is the devil’s advocate’ against the point.
38 years after being passed by Congress the ERA has STILL NOT been ratified(which does go to our point of how hard it is to get a Constitutional amendment passed).
Which 15 states have not ratified the ERA?
The 15 states whose legislatures have not ratified the Equal Rights Amendment are Alabama, Arizona, Arkansas, Florida, Georgia, Illinois, Louisiana, Mississippi, Missouri, Nevada, North Carolina, Oklahoma, South Carolina, Utah, and Virginia.
(Someone want to overlay the States where the Tea Party is strongest and see the matches? Or where violent racism is most often reported on? In fact ,the only States that were part of the Confederacy that have approved the ERA are Texas and Tennessee)
Maybe it’s the ‘exception to the rule’ BUT it’s ratification would affect so many things(like, is there a law against a man getting a vasectomy, with the concomittant arguments that doing so kills ‘life’?; silly I know but so are there arguments put forth against abortion based on the idea of a life being taken).
watertiger is upstairs!
Late Night: Because California Isn’t Already Up the Creek? and Other Tales of “Teh Crazy”
From the article:
What else do you need to know about Prohibition and how bad an idea it was. Would that have happened without the self-righteous busybodies? Maybe, but maybe not and certainly the idea of Prohibition made it far easier for politicians to fall for the rhetoric of the “War on Drugs”… just because Prohibition failed did not mean that finding another “enemy” in another vice wasn’t a bad or politically inexpedient idea.
What Wheeler accomplished has been mimicked by the NRA, not to pass an Amendment (they have the 2nd after all) but to ensure that politicians live in fear of losing their perks, privileges and power. Maybe it’s time for a Constitutional Amendment to federally finance campaigns and take those away from them for the good of us all.
It should be a wakeup call, but they don’t seem to be awake yet. The action on the “
climate/energy” bill is a case in point. They just continue to follow the pattern of promising half measures, and then delivering something we’d just as soon they hadn’t bothered doing.If folks are doing too much pot or booze or whatever to act upright in their lives, they need compassion and rehab, not prison or getting shot up or killed.
Seems to me it’s far more constructive making art, not war.
Intermission: Bill Narum on the Armadillo World Headquarters.
But of course we need more than art and the absence of war to re-balance human society …
Shouldn’t we be adding in Bennett, Specter, and Case in this wake up call? All of these are races where progressives have challenged the administration’s anointed. True, the jury is is still out Bennett, but even so, most everywhere the administration has stood up to protect someone from the “fucking retarded”, the retards have extracted a pound of flesh.
I honestly don’t think Rham has the skills or desire to do anything but triangulate and advance the goals of whoever promises to fill his campaign coffers the fullest. With him in the pivotal role he holds, we will never see anything different … Isn’t that 18 months almost up? Maybe *this* is that nth dimensional chess we’ve been hearing about; get all the really important changes we hoped for through congress and “accomplished” in name only, add some not-so-liberal SC justices and generally screw us all. Then have Rham leave and blame everything on him. Pass DADT and pretend like this is the most progressive/liberal administration since the founding or our great nation. Taaaaadaaaaaa!
[*sigh*] This last year has made me even more cynical than I was previously.