Not a surprise really that upon passage of the health care bill, Max Baucus would openly thank Liz Fowler, the former Wellpoint VP, for writing it:
Mr. BAUCUS. Mr. President, there are a flood of emotions going through all of us today as we pass this reconciliation bill which improves upon the bill the President signed 2 days ago. I would like to focus only on one part–a very important part but only one part–and that is to thank the people who have worked so hard, especially in this body, to help accomplish this result.
[...]
We all want to thank so many people. Once we start mentioning a couple or three names, we run the danger of offending people whose names are not mentioned. We all know that. There will be an appropriate time for us to make all the thanks, and I will make mine so sincerely because I am so grateful for all the hard work my staff has put into this.
I wish to single out one person, and that one person is sitting next to me. Her name is Liz Fowler. Liz Fowler is my chief health counsel. Liz Fowler has put my health care team together. Liz Fowler worked for me many years ago, left for the private sector, and then came back when she realized she could be there at the creation of health care reform because she wanted that to be, in a certain sense, her profession lifetime goal. She put together the White Paper last November–2008–the 87-page document which became the basis, the foundation, the blueprint from which almost all health care measures in all bills on both sides of the aisle came. She is an amazing person. She is a lawyer; she is a Ph.D. She is just so decent. She is always smiling, she is always working, always available to help any Senator, any staff. I thank Liz from the bottom of my heart. In many ways, she typifies, she represents all of the people who have worked so hard to make this bill such a great accomplishment.
I will have printed in the Record the names of all my professional staff. There are more than I realized, so I can’t name them all. I ask unanimous consent to have that list printed in the Record and just regret that I cannot thank everybody personally.
It’s right up there with Tom Carper’s insistence that the Senate had to respect the White House deal with PhRMA because after all they paid for it with $150 million in political advertising as “most telling moments of the health care debate.”
Nancy Pelosi says the foundations of the health care bill were written by the Heritage Foundation. Probably true, Heritage is awash in corporate money. And really, the plan is no different from the one that AHIP (then HIAA) wrote in 1992:
- Every American was required to buy ‘an essential package’ of benefits
- The government would help define the essential package and private insurers would provide the standard package “regardless of a person’s medical history”
- Only the essential package would be protected from taxation. If employers bought more than the basic benefits, the premiums pad for the extra coverage “would be treated as income to the employees, and they would have to pay income tax on it.”
- The government would work with private insures to “stabilize health-care prices” and make sure private insures and government programs pay similar amounts for the same services in the same geographic area.
All of the underpinnings of the insurance “reform” package were already there, waiting for someone to sweep in and make AHIP’s champagne dreams come true. And now that the Chamber of Commerce is not funding the mandate repeal effort any more, those legislative efforts are stalling out across the country. Republicans in Alaska, Kansas, Georgia and Michigan have all voted down anti-mandate bills since the Chamber pulled the plug (failing by one vote in Kansas after Republican Dwayne Upmeyer “accidentally” voted against it. “Oops” was his response.) Sarah Palin didn’t mention the mandate in her speech before cheering Tea Partiers at Searchlight, no doubt conscious of the $2.5 million in donations the health care sector contributed to McCain/Palin in 2008.
The insurance industry has spent their money well, spreading it across both parties. They got what they paid for with this neoliberal health care bill. Ken Silverstein’s prescient 2006 article in Harpers on Obama’s early vetting by corporate interests still stands up. They sized up the situation accurately years ago.
Thanks indeed, Liz Fowler. The country really does owe you one.
(transcript powwow)



53 Comments







Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About FDL Action
Hmm, that praise for his staffer was so effusive, I was worried he was going to nominate her for US Attorney. :o)
http://www.mainjustice.com/2009/12/04/baucus-girlfriend-withdrew-as-u-s-attorney-candidate/
Welcome to the bizarro world where it’s considered good manners and good ethics to let corporate kings run the country, rather than something to be ashamed of.
Shame, wear it proudly.
Baucus Health Insurance Reform Plan
1. Let Lobby write bill
2. ?
3. Reform!
And Liz Fowler should probably thank the entire range of womens’ rights organizations, OFA, HCAN, the liberal “blogosphere”, “Daily Krust”, The Nation, etc etc etc, for seeing to it that her legislation became law.
We can all hope that the video of Baucus thanking a high-ranking corporate lobbyist and operator for assembling his health care team against him and writing his legislation for him is used against the Democrats to the n-th degree in the elections this year!
Thank you, thank you, thank you,
Liz Fowler for being so assiduous with your Law Degree, PhD, and lifelong goal to provide Heath Care Reform.
You have done well, as Max Baucus stated in the record on the Senate Floor.
Do you think perhaps, that he outed you, deliberately, to deflect the blame? Perhaps you should publish your 87 page white paper, which according to Max, is the root of what we have.
You have secured your place in History. How do you believe history will judge you?
Just like the thief she and Baucus are… At least I hope so!!
Just another day in Class Warfare where the Rich WON…. again…
Got that part right. The rest, not so much.
Here’s another predictable outcome of the HCR bill.
The Democrats are no better than the Rebublicans, this fiasco proves that.
No more Kool-Aid drinking for me, I am done with the Dems.
‘Most progressive legislation in 40 years’ brought to you by Wellpoint.
I will be interested to see Ms Fowler’s next move. How long will she stay on Baucus’ staff? Will she be so crass and obvious as to return to WellPoint at a higher position than she left? Or will she move to a lobbying firm? Here’s my guess and I would love to know what Jane thinks: Within 6 months she will resign from Baucus’ staff and then let the conflict-of-interest period pass ( is there one for Congressional staff?) working at a low-profile job somewhere, and then return to DC as a lobbyist for whatever firm represents WellPoint.
This could be a job for Eric Holder (aka Sheriff Droopy).
Shorter Max:
Crush on you
Makes one feel all warm and fuzzy then does it not?
The American healthcare industry–as then with the Pentagon/M-I-C and CIA/National Security sub regimes– is a powerful sub regime that has defined post WW2 America’s social,economic and political boundary lines.
Certainly was a show of candor for Senator Baucus to shine the spotlight on Liz Fowler so honestly at this point. Wonder why he chose to not do so last summer? Perhaps Liz Fowler can answer this question? She seems quite central to what Obama and Baucus were up to last summer.
Would one be out of line to suggest Barack Obama come clean on his having been the point man for what AHIP wanted out of this “American healthcare industry reform”?
Thanks Jane for all the energy and attention you have brought to this HCR story over the past year. Your integrity should shame some so called D Party headliner talent deeply. The D Party seems to have become what the R Party used to be regarding how Barack Obama and his D Party “leadership” made sure AHIP and PhRMA got most of the chairs at this “reform” table.
Heart warming to then see Barack Obama thinks he has credibility to go to Kabul and lecture President Karzai about clean,open government and governance. He failed to display much integrity or credibility with this AHIP/PhRMA approved American healthcare industry “reform”.
So much for practicing what you are preaching President Obama.
As the aftermath of this “HCR” unfolds we already are seeing,hearing and surely will be experiencing that what was bought and sold here will be riddled with fine print and work arounds that Nancy,Barack and Harry conveniently “overlooked”. But it is a victory. A triumph. Well — for AHIP and PhRMA anyway. Find your crumbs if and when you can. It’s all good.
This is sooo disturbing on soooo many levels. It’s like being forced to live with your rapist. This is like a sadistic dom/submissive humiliation act. Thank you sir can I have another.
After folks do their homework, seems that they would be stampeding to credit unions with their remaining pennies and dollars to de-leverage Baucus et al. More at “The Growing Movement for Publicly Owned Banks” (http://www.alternet.org/economy/146123/the_growing_movement_for_publicly_owned_banks?page=entire) and “The US-China-Australia love triangle” (http://www.zerohedge.com/article/us-china-australia-love-triangle).
according to the Public Sector Health care Roundtable website, Liz was also very influential in another piece of healthcare legislation…
What a resume…
Max “Bucks” Baucus, who probably has a nice, comfy post-retirement “desk by a window” in the WellPoint office tower, top floor of course with little but nothing to do but Lunch with Liz and collect a fat seven (maybe eight figure) check every year. Once in a while a quick trip to DC to make sure that WellPoint’s Point of View is well considered by his former colleagues and then a quick jaunt to some nice destination in the Corporate Jet to relax after all that work.
he must enjoy her “assets” to the legislative process
You are right to suggest that that premiums will go through the roof but I would not call that an “outcome”, rather a process which will require further reform in the form of a public option. But how that can be done with the Clinton DLC democrats is another issue.
How long before VP Fowler pens a diary over at DKos thanking Progressives for their hard work?
Yet another example of our one party system. Remember this day when our next Pres is Sarah Palin. Beyond the fact that her voice, to me, is like nails on a chalkboard, what’s the effen difference? There. is. no. difference.
Permanent Republican Majority – achieved!
Seymour Friendly @5: what you said! No $h**! Ugh.
Remember when Cheney went behind closed doors with the oil CEO’s and wrote the energy bill. People were suing to find out about that meeting behind closed doors. The democrats have gotten so blatant about it, Baucas goes on the senate floor and brags that it was the insurance industry that wrote the bill. The democrats are far more dangerous then the republicans because normally the veal pen crowd would not allow this. Bush could never have pulled this off. Hopefully someone will follow up on the pay off that Fowler gets from the industry. I would imagine she can just retire and live off her payments.
Meanwhile, Mr. Baucus is the same guy that said quite boldly as the Single Payer Advocates were being arrested in his hearing room: “I think we need more police.”
Who would use it. The republicans love this bill. Most people who see this on cpan will not know she is from Wellpoint and besides this was democrats that did this, it must be OK. I had someone tell me, since the tea party hates it, it must be a great bill and can’t be written by republicans.
I was at a democratic convention this week-end and an OFA was there with hand outs propagandizing this bill. nothing about the mandate, nothing about the 7 year law against states getting health care for their citizens, nothing negative. Actually, nothing said OFA. By the time I got done with him, at least he will no longer be comfortable doing what he is doing. I told him he should educate himself before spewing these lies. I also found out OFA, is DNC. Maybe that was common knowledge, but I didn’t know. He now knows this was written by the insurance industry and why do they have to hire people to sell this bill? If it is a good bill, it will sell itself. By the time I got done convincing him of what he was selling, I had to feel sorry for him. He really did not know.
Another good one Jane.
Keep it up. MAKE ALL WHO SUPPORTED IT OWN IT!
That’s right DKos, when the public figures out they’ve been fucked again, they’ll know you were in on it. Same to you, you supposed “women’s rights” organizations that folded up like a cheap, well, progressive. Let me know how those donations are working out about 5 years from now when real women see the real damage done here, and realize you were in on it.
It’s not going to be hard for folks to realize this one was a royal fucking, it’s just going to take time (which is why they waited SO LONG for everything to kick in). But the folks out here juggling health care, mortgages, gas, education, and food prices are going to figure this one right quick when they see just what little good it does for them and what great good it does for those insurance company CEO’s and their continued 50 million dollar salaries.
And it’s important that those folks know who to turn to as far trust in coming up with real solutions.
This is NOT a progressive, liberal, of left bill. It is a corporate, neoliberal, right wing bill. Just because it was the Democrats that wrote it, voted for it, and signed it into law doesn’t mean it’s any less right wing. The Republican Party of 10 or 20 years ago would’ve gladly written this, passed this, and signed it into law.
Assholes.
Revisiting this seems apropos:
“Was I hired to stand in the way of health care reform?“
Thanks Jane!
David Frum said something that was very true, the Republicans work for Fox, Fox does not work for Republicans.
The same applies to the Dems, they work for the Corporate Elite, not the people who vote for them.
The american people think their enemies are Bin Laden, Iran, Afghan, North Korea etc. the real enemies of americans live in Washington and call themselves Dems and Reps.
Again thanks Jane
the true AXIS EVIL is
Current Democrats
Current Republicans
Supreme Court
Thank you Jane for the link to Silverstein’s article; I hope others bothered to read it.
““My argument,” he says, “is that a polarized electorate plays to the advantage of those who want to dismantle government. Karl Rove can afford to win with 51 percent of the vote. They’re not trying to reform health care. They are content with an electorate that is cynical about government. Progressives have a harder job. They need a big enough majority to initiate bold proposals.” ; and as we now see. just because there is a significant Dem majority, it doesn’t mean the Dems are ‘progressive’.
“I recall a remark made by Studs Terkel in 1980, about the liberal Republican John Anderson, who was running as an independent against Ronald Reagan and Jimmy Carter: “People are so tired of dealing with two-foot midgets, you give them someone two foot four and they start proclaiming him a giant.” In the unstinting and unanimous adulation of Barack Obama today, one wonders if a similar dynamic might be at work. If so, his is less a midgetry of character than one dictated by changing context. Gone are the days when, as in the 1970s, the U.S. Senate could comfortably house such men as Fred Harris (from Oklahoma, of all places), who called for the breakup of the oil, steel, and auto industries; as Wisconsin’s William Proxmire, who replaced Joe McCarthy in 1957 and survived into the 1980s, a crusader against big banks who neither spent nor raised campaign money; as South Dakota’s George McGovern, who favored huge cuts in defense spending and a guaranteed income for all Americans; as Frank Church of Idaho, who led important investigations into CIA and FBI abuses.
Today, money has all but wrung such dissent from the Senate. Campaigns have grown increasingly costly; in 2004 it took an average of more than $7 million to run for a Senate seat. As Carl Wagner, a Democratic political strategist who first came to Washington in 1970, remarked to me, the Senate today is a fundamentally different institution than it was then. “Senators were creatures of their states and reflected the cultures of their states,” he said. “Today they are creatures of the people who pay for their multimillion-dollar advertising campaigns. Representative democracy has largely been taken off the table. It’s reminiscent of the 1880s and 1890s, when senators were chosen by state legislatures who were owned by the railroads and the banks.”
Perhaps it’s time to reverse the ‘direct election’ of Senators; still am figuring out how “In the early 1900s, one state initiated changes on its own. Oregon pioneered direct election and experimented with different measures over several years until it succeeded in 1907.” given that the Constitutional amendment for direct election hadn’t passed at that time.
And since Durbin -Obama’s good buddy- has introduced the Fair elections Now Act AND Obama was an original co-sponsor back in 2007 , why is he not speaking out about it?
AFAIC, Obama is what I have called him before, a corporate whore.
“All of this has forged a political culture that is intrinsically hostile to reform. On condition of anonymity, one Washington lobbyist I spoke with was willing to point out the obvious: that big donors would not be helping out Obama if they didn’t see him as a “player.” The lobbyist added: “What’s the dollar value of a starry-eyed idealist?””
Yeah, we can’t let the good be the victim of the perfect and lets look ahead, not backward. /s
Thank you, Jane. Please don’t let go of this. It’s going to be important in the future that people remember why–why they don’t have money to send their children to college or help fund their retirement, why they need every penny they can scrape together just to pay their family’s health insurance premium.
Rather bold of Senator Baucus to go out of his way to single out this one person, his chief health counsel, who happens also to be a former Wellpoint VP, in order to thank her for writing this pos legislation.
If our political system worked, Baucus and all the sellouts and enablers calling themselves Democrats would have a huge political price to pay for this bullshit.
Fortunately for them, our political system doesn’t work and they’ll get away with screwing over the American people.
Shameless assholes.
Max Baucus should be in prison.
I blame Baucus, too, for the Tea Party’s existence, or at least its “significance” in the news cycle and the politicians’ consciousness.
Baucus and his six people (IIRC, there were 6) who worked alone on the “health care reform bill” took so long, kept things so secret, kept out anyone who had slightly more liberal ideas, etc., etc., that it wasn’t close to done by the time of the summer recesses, thus allowing the Tea Partiers to blow up Town Halls and get Scott Brown elected, etc., etc.
Just look at how public reaction to the bill is flipping now that it’s done. (not making any personal comment, just the polls and interviews).
Dems couldn’t really defend a bill that wasn’t written, that no one knew what it would end up being, when attacked last summer.
Had there been a bill – let alone had there been a better bill, with real reform, Congresspeople would have had a chance to shut down the hysteria at Town Hall meetings, and there might even not have been a Tea Party.
Baucus and his little group of Blue Dogs have a lot to answer for.
Harper’s pointed this out a few months ago. I guess it didn’t hold much interest to some people. I think the article was titled “Understanding Obamacare”.
heh
Wait till we all see financial reform legislation. Apparently, same scenario as healthcare. I know, hard to believe, but it seems industry insiders wrote this bill as well. Call me shocked. So don’t be surprised if you are mandated to open bank accounts.
Your so right, I was just thinking that exact thought today. How am I going to be able to pay for my health Ins. policy after my wife loses her job? Without, it I’m a dead man after having a serious heart attack last summer. For many of us what Bauchus and Fowler and Obama have wrought is an utter disaster. Yet, they’re proud of this thing for some reason?
The whole thing is not workable and will blow up in the face of the Dems.
You’re right it will blow up, but not in the faces of the Dems in now in office. That’s why it doesn’t really kick in until 2014. The bill was written not to BE reform, but to hold off reform for aleast 4 more years. What I’m still trying to figure out is how can the American people be so blind? Even so-called proggresives.
Wow.
Twice even!!
You are upset at Baucus.
Believe or not, I’m actually more upset at the so called “progressives” or “liberals” that are supporting this POS and those that wrote it. Because of that, we have little chance of fixing the problem of corporate whores writing legislation.
If only we could all agree that these corporate whores MUST be held accountable for this atrocity, I think we would be able to work for real change.
*sigh*
The Strongest argument I have seen for Term Limits. People should be screened prior to becoming candidates, then perhaps we could weed out the sociopaths and/or the criminally insane.
There is a special place in Hell reserved for the K-Street parasites and their minions — our fearless leaders, [we humbly pray]
Never have so few, fucked up so much for so many!
Baucus smaucus,
I’m still pissed that Dennis caved without getting anything for his vote
from the commander in thief.
Unless you read her bill, I wouldn’t pass judgement on her. You know all those good things that were supposedly in the bills at one point, perhaps PO? Maybe those were in her draft…
Obama had some sort of vision for HCR.
Someone wrote it.
Then the House and Senate mangled it.
Um, you know what’s coming, right?
And then there’s this headline currently on display at HuffPo:
I wonder if Sebelius has any clue.
In case she doesn’t know, yes, we all saw the wink.
I do not think any progressive went along with this bill. It was popular only as long as PO was present and Jane tried hard to get it in the final bill if you saw her posts and requests. Progressives just had a limited budget and you know the result. In other category which really matters of votes we will soon get our chance in November.
Sister Jane, thanks for bringing this up and fighting for whats right for the long term future of the country instead of taking the easy path of going with the flow and being in good graces which is always short-lived since the reality hits sooner than later.
Now American Industries are asked to compete in a free-for-all global economy with no intellectual property protections, at the receiving end of currency manipulations with no similar retaliation from our side, keeping quiet when our children are exposed to all sorts of harmful imports, with our future work-force hampered with ever-lasting long-term effects of these imports, and finally every body hampered with individual and industry mandate laden sky-rocketing insurance premiums which runs counter to spirit of our constitution and declaration of independence principles. It shocks me to even think at the absurdity that these broken futures and careers is only because one party wants to raise more campaign contribution than other party in a two party majority system and this race by itself is illogical in this setup.
I simply do not trust any more reform packages from the senate, congress and executive branch since they seem to look to these bills as a corporate donation raising event.
Things will get better only when we have third party members in Senate and Congress. Request to all. Please do not skip 2010 elections in disgust but vote hopefully third party like Green Party if you want to be counted and if you want to avoid more mandates in future and make our country and world better.
I’ve never bothered to go through the comments at HuffPo before; until now My God, if you have any desire to hang onto the last bitter shreds of any faith in humanity; do. not. go. there.
What is the average age of commenter there? Thirteen?
We are a poor befuddled nation
We don’t know the truth from falsehood
Each light ahead becomes a rushing train
Every sound a voice of discord and distortion
Where are you truth do you exist?
Are all our saints not
Social unrest is percolating
So, Obama’s buddy Ron Williams is set to screw the pooch. Wow! Thanks for the link. I don’t think this little piece of info has gotten to the front pages of HuffPo yet for the O-bots to digest yet.