Over a hundred call reports were logged in the past hour by people calling Michael Bennet’s office, asking why he’s now refusing to offer up an amendment on the public option after saying he wanted such a vote only a month ago.
This call report from Lora P. is typical of what people report he’s saying, and it’s clear that Bennet’s office is outright lying about Senate procedure:
They said that someone out on the Internet doesn’t understand the legislative process and that if he does introduce the amendment right now it will require a full vote by both the senate and the house and that it would thus in essence kill what’s already been passed, whereas later this year they can and will introduce the public option and many other fixes which can then be passed via reconciliation instead and that it makes much more sense to do it that way – which is similar to what I’ve heard in other quarters. No wonder he made that snarky comment about the blogosphere.
Michael Bennet and his staff are just lying. Plain and simple. There is no other way to say it. From Jon Walker’s Frosh Sen. Michael Bennet Won’t Offer Public Option Amendment, Still Seems Not To Understand How Legislative Process Works:
Oh, poor, poor Michael Bennet (D-CO). He just doesn’t seem to understand how the legislative process works. He took to the Senate floor to praise what the “Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act”–which was signed yesterday by President Obama–will do. That bill is now law. Today they are working on a completely different bill, a budget reconciliation bill, which mostly contains some tax changes that will not go into effect for years.
Bennet falsely equates what the already-passed health insurance law will do with what this reconciliation bill will accomplish. He claims that trying to make improvements to this minor “sidecar” would be to “play games with the lives of thousands of Coloradans and millions of Americans, and I won’t do it.”
That is absurd. The bill that expands insurance coverage was already signed into law. This reconciliation bill, with its minor changes for the employer mandate, and changes to the excise tax, is not playing games with the lives of millions of Americans. Whether this new bill passes or not it will have little impact on our health care system.
Bennet also claims that merely offering some popular amendments to improve the reconciliation bill would kill it. This is completely nonsense. Changing the bill will only send it back to the House for another vote, where it would likely pass. Because of Byrd rule points of order, the bill will almost certainly need to go back to the House for another vote, anyway. Of course, if there are not enough votes for the amended reconciliation bill in the House, they can always amended the bill again to their liking and send it back to the Senate for a final vote. This is how the legislative process works.
And in fact this morning the Senate parlementarian has ruled that the bill will have to go back to the House regardless. Yet another one of his bullshit excuses evaporates. Bennet’s primary challenger Andrew Romanoff is looking awfully good for calling him out on this.
Bennet said yesterday that he “doesn’t confuse the blogosphere with real people and real voters.”
If you’re in Colorado, please call Senator Bennet and tell him that you are in fact a real person and a real voter, and that you simply want Bennet to do what he said he’d do: save the public option.
If you’re not in Colorado, we’re blanketing the state in online ads ahead of the vote in the Senate later today. We want to engage Coloradans to pressure Bennet in these final hours. Please donate to help us run these ads now.




61 Comments

Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About FDL Action
am thinking I should start a FB Group – Hey Senator Bennet, We Are Not Your Chumps !
somewhere Craig Hughes is reaching for his Jane Hamsher voodoo doll :D
I just kicked in $15, sorry it can’t be more. Keep up the great work!
Shorter Michael Bennet: Go away, you people. I don’t need you.
Thank you so much BooRadley. Every penny counts.
I hear they’re a hot item.
;)
Grrr. Jerk. As if I wasn’t opposed to him before, I’m doubling down now!
Jane you guys ought to clip out the am760 & my footage of “real voters” crowding his office and signing the petition.
I shoulda gone all Pollack and locked down the concession when I had the chance
OT newsflash on the Cult of Money:
“Workers fired for credit scores hit close to home for White House”
“Employees at a government agency in Cleveland which processes President Barack Obama’s paycheck risk losing their jobs because they have failed credit report checks, according to Troy Marshall, a union leader at the Cleveland office of Defense Finance and Accounting Service (DFAS).
He says tighter security clearance rules introduced by the Pentagon five years ago have cost 25 DFAS Cleveland workers their jobs and threaten another 42. The rules are unfair, he says, because these employees don’t handle classified information and are struggling to dig out of debt due to the economic crisis.
“We’ve had people who have tried to get their debt consolidated […] but in this economy you can’t get loans,” says Marshall, who also works as a management assistant at DFAS and who claims he was suspended after 17 years because of $6,000 he owes on credit card and hospital bills.”
Tips on how to de-leverage the banksters at ANewWayForward.Org.
cynical me: I think dems want to run on the promise of the PO, not on actually having acted on it while in office.
Hi Kelly, good work!!
I haven’t checked youtube. is it on there? did I miss it. I can’t find my car keys either. :)
ETA: never mind. found it! the video, not the car keys…
This used to work.
People would call their Senators and Representatives, get these bullshit lies, and say, “My what an arcane set of rules you all have!” and let it go.
But no more.
Now we recognize lies like Bennet’s for what they are.
We badly need to defeat this tool and his lying office crew.
Yes, but it seems only someone as old as McGrampy would still think they could get away with that tactic.
Bennet’s staffer:
Am I incorrect in my understanding that this was the only shot at reconciliation for this year?
How many Dem. Senators are there? And, not one of them will ask for a reconcilliation vote on a public option?
Obama, Senate Dems. and House Dems. are amoral, self-serving low-lifes, but at least they’re getting paid for their hypocrisies. What about all the voters here who will rationalize returning their Dem. Representatives to Wash. D.C. to do it to us again. Shameful, simply shameful!
It’s time to vote every Democrat in Wash. D.C. out of office, every stinking one of them! If there’s no other choice I will vote for the WORST Republican running rather than vote for a Democrat who had a single chance to do something great but didn’t.
If its not already apparent, the Senate Democrats have no intention whatsoever of putting any actual reform amendments of a meaningful sort into the reconciliation. The Democrats in general never wanted real reform, just a giveaway to big business interests. Otherwise we would have had actual reform legislation passed last year, and we wouldn’t be worrying about trying to inject some sort of real reform into a regressive law already signed via budgetary reconciliation.
The “reform” enacted is a sham, deliberately so, there was never any other intention …
We need to find some form of stick we can use with these people. Until we do there’s just not going to be any action.
[Mod Note: Just so long as we keep it metaphorical of course]
AND THE KILLIN’ GOEZ ON AND ON AND…
Citizen Hamsher and the Firepup Freedom Fighters:
Keep the pressure on, Sister Hamsher, Bennet is toast and so is Blanched Lincoln, One Hung Harry Reid, Stupak, Scott Brown, every Blue Dog in blue or “purple” districts and maybe even poor old Ben Nelson ‘cuz the Tea Baggers are out ta lynch the poor bastard. Politically, this entire process and the the boondoggle that came out of it is gunna cost both the fascist Republicans AND the corporatist Democrats includin’ those in the White House a lot goin’ forward, startin’ in November.
Please don’t quit now, Citizen, because we are in the center of the triangle with real, jack booted thugs and murderers on one side and the slimy corporatist Democrats on the other. Keep the pressure on within the system, cut the corporatist numbers down until they realize that fascists don’t kill only “liberals”.
In for a penny in for a pound, your efforts and those of all your allies are all that stand between the people of this country and a neo-Nazism that that will make this country look like Germany in 1940.
And to those arm chair radicals, psuedo revolutionaries and frustrated Guns and Roses fans who hurl epithets at Democrats and other progressives who disagree with them and call for roits in the streets: be careful what you wish for because you aren’t ready and those of us who are don’t want you anywhere near us when the shit hits the fan.
KEEP THE FAITH AND PASS THE AMMUNITION, YOU CAN’T QUIT NOW EVEN IF YOU WANTED TO!!
Anyone know where Russ Feingold is? Hasn’t he made a career of being a “Courageous Progressive”? Feingold’s up for reelection in 2010, does he deserve to be returned to Wash. D.C.? This is not just another day in Washington D.C., folks. This is the death of the Democratic Party.
Of course the Dems don’t want a public option.
Obama cut a deal last summer in which he promised there would be NO public option. That’s been well documented and confirmed.
This has turned into legitimizing the president and giving him a ‘win’ (cover) on his signature issue, even if it’s nothing like what he ran on, or the democratic platform.
It hasn’t worked since the Republicans found out they could stiff their constituents and still get elected. I remember in the 1970s writing Strom Thurmond and getting a response that politely informed me how wrong I was. And I remember in the 1980s writing Jesse Helms about torture in Chile and getting a response accusing me of being brainwashed.
It isn’t surprising that the attitudes crept into the Democratic part of the Congress.
Maybe because they know that there are not enough House votes nor the will of the House leadership to go through another battle royale with the House Republicans. Winning by three votes and four votes shows major disunity in the House Democratic caucus.
The Senate health care bill has been signed by President Obama. It is the law of the land. The baseline bill is in place, period…but Senate Democrats could have improved it immensely by adding a public option amendment.
Bennet could have proposed the amendment he promised to propose…and offered Senators the opportunity (I doubt that most of the Democrats in the Senate would have welcomed that opportunity, but I digress…) to vote, up or down, for the public option.
Jane is absolutely correct. Bennet is either a complete idiot regarding the crafting of legislation in the Senate…or, he’s a liar.
Maybe both descriptions apply…
Where’s Sanders?
F’ing lol.
Woolsey, Kusinch, Donna Edwards and on down the line, but this time we’ll have a real Progressive in Romanoff, not like the faux Progressives we now have.
Sure, I’ll get behind that.
We should be expecting a fundraising letter anytime now from Sen. Benedict asking for our help in getting the public option passed.
” Winning by three votes and four votes shows major disunity in the House Democratic caucus.”
No, half votes one way and half the other would be “major disunity”.
They all own this pos.
Lmao, no kidding. As in Benedict Arnold?
Bennet is useless, unless you’re an insurance company.
When I called Senator Merkley’s office awhile ago, I was told that Merkley and Bennet made a deal with Senator Reid not to introduce any amendments. That’s the situation, but Bennet won’t be honest about it. It sucks, but at least Merkley’s office was upfront.
I’ll bet the lines into the WH are burning up with the Democratic Senators demanding cover from Orahma. Not a pee about the lack of PO in reconciliation at the orange satan. Not a whisper, except to say they “fixed” it. I “fixed” my cat too. It’s called “spaying”
Will do Kelly, thank you so much for doing that.
Why not? It would be an appropriate response.
They won’t get it, it’ll be much easier for Obama to gut social security and medicare with a bunch more reps to be ‘bi-partisan’ with. The little shit.
That’s the cycle!
Make things worse, whip people up about how bad things are, raise their hopes when nothing can happen, then back out when you can actually do something.
And it will repeat once again.
Where is Sanders, Franken & Feingold, some much for guts. What a phony charade this whole thing has been. From the start it was always obvious these crooks and liars had no intention of passing anything that wasn’t just another Corp. bail-out wrapped in Orwellian Newspeak.
Of course there is no way Bennett can save the public option whatever that is supposed to be at this point.
Citizen bailey:
Ease up on Feingold, he’s teeterin’ on the edge of possibly a very tough November if the poll numbers are correct and Tommy Thompson gets in the race. I live in the state and work in the Democratic Party in one of the “purple” districts…if you look at his electoral history, Finegold has cut it pretty thin in keepin himself from sellin out for corporate bucks. Don’t go after Finegold or any other Democratic Senator up for re-election who isn’t a full blown Nazi sympathizer like Blanched Lincoln.
Kabuki. Produced and directed by the health insurance industry and promoted by the Orahma administration.
In a way, I’m sympathetic to that position because Democrats may be bought and corrupt but they aren’t full on, batshit crazy for the most part. Still, there is no real difference anymore and I am as sick as it’s possible to be of having to decide between two REALLY crappy candidates. I’m voting third party. I have to vote my conscience this time. I gave the Democrats a chance, they have done nothing except undermine my faith and negate my efforts on their behalf.
And now O goes all alpha male with “Go for it.”
Which sounds an awful lot like “Bring it on.”
He’ll be buying a fake ranch next in order to “clear brush”. Watch.
But does he have better personal hygiene habits than W?
As reported at TPM the Clintons are reported to be even happier than Obama with the HRL which passed.
I got a different answer: the kid said “to be honest, it didn’t have the votes,”–so naturally I asked him, “if it didn’t have the votes, why did you promise with Sanders to introduce it?” he said he had no answer. I left a vm for the LA on hcr to call
me; her name is Lucy and you should do the same.
Note to Kelly, the classics master:
This is our modern day greek tragedy. Gods cavorting above, pulling the strings of poor humans below as the hoi polloi is forced through the gauntlet between a Scylla of corporate interests and Charybdis of campaign contribution captured government.
Demos + crazy = Welcome to America, the ungovernable
One big problem with the public option (medicare for all) is fraud. Just the system we now have in place suffers fraud at the rate of at least $60 billion a year. Of course no one knows how much for sure because a lot of crooks are ahead of the government. As far as we know it could be $600 billion. You’ve got to admit private insurance companies don’t get cheated like the government.
Medicare fraud is just one sub category of welfare fraud (which is huge–probably one in three) and one of the biggest arguments against the welfare state.
I’m sure you people are in complete agreement.
In a recent poll asking who they would like to see as president if they could pick anyone some 74% picked Bill Clinton. They didn’t ask me but if they had I would have been in that 74%.
“America, the ungovernable”
I like that because I think it is very true.
Mind providing a source for that figure?
Well, I don’t rightly know anymore where I fit in on the Norske Scale Of Progressive, or maybe even the FDL Scale Of Prog.
1) The Dem’s in both chambers and in the WH scewed us. They lied to us to get elected and now they have lied and have proven they will NOT vote progressive, demand progressive change in their chambers or in the legislation they craft and pass and only represent the special interests of the corporate machine that pays for their bidding. So as a progressive, I am against them, one and all, Sanders, Kuch, Grayson, Weiner, ALL of them who failed to do as they said they would do.
2) As to FDL Pups who profess the legislation Obama signed is a beginning, has value and merit, and will help millions, I say you have been badly misled and time will tell the difference, but I respect COMPLETELY your rights to support and rally for your beliefs and the causes important to you.
3) The progressives, be they FDL Pups or otherwise, who continue to stand for a line in the sand, and demand REAL change, and refuse to support the Dem Party in any further efforts to move the nation further rightward under Obama, is where I align myself with.
Sadly, we were ALL outnumbered post election (when all libs/dems/progs were SOMEWHAT united) when it came time for our political corporate operatives that we elected to begin to go about their business.
And lo, what a shock to learn that all we had championed in ’06, and ’08 for change was stripped from reality, rewritten into some neoliberal revisionist messaging to prop up a corporate sponsored ‘vision of change sweeping the nation’ that will save the dem’s political chances in ’10 and ’12.
So, I draw a line. I say, better we shun and dun the dems and let fate take the nation into a pit of hell worse than it is now, which in the end, will FORCE some kind of changes on the system as it falls, fails and the masses finally decide they will have no more of it.
Because, to sit longer and play the replacement game political hack by political hack just to see them turned, forced, and enrolled into the corporatist machine over and over again is just not a productive use of my time on the planet, not is it IMHO, of value to the ideals of the fundamentals and tenets this nation was founded upon.
And without those values, and tenets, it’s pretty clear we the people, the masses, the 90% of this nation, will not be served in our better interests.
It’s pretty clear our better interests are being stripped from us, at such a rapid rate during 8 years of BushCo and now only ONE year of a Dem Obama, so as to make the past 50 years of slippage of our gains (SS, Civil Rights, Women’s Rights, Social Services, etc>) seem minute.
It’s ‘all in’ time to use the poker analogy, and if that’s not clear to others, well, our visions differ greatly.
Now, my ONLY problem, as a ‘line in the sand’ progressive, as a general member in the club of so called liberals, progs, and dems, is that not only are we the people with good intent FRACTURED amongst ourselves (irrepairably, I’d add) but our numbers are so minute as to be inconsequential.
So, to what, now?
I don’t know, I’ll let you know if I figure something out.
But I’m over the line, I just can’t support the dems anymore, not for ’10, not for ’12.
They lied, and they have delivered naught IMHO, for the masses. They have only exponentially speeded up the pace of the diminishing of our body of citizens, and the diminishing of our quality of life.
Can’t. Support. Them.
I can’t wait for tomorrow, for each other rising sun left in my time . . . for each day now is filled with tension, excitement . . . and the smell of SOME kind of inevitable change is in the air thicker than I’ve ever had it waft thru my senses.
The system as is, cannot sustain itself, it’s doomed to fail.
When? I don’t know, likely EASILY within the next 20 years.
I’ve got about 20-30 years left on this rock, I was hoping to get out before it all crashed.
Sigh. The excitement I speak of, the daily sense of things? I would much prefer calm, serenity and peace among the people for my final years. Alas, the naivete of my youth is finally and utterly shattered with the reality of the moment.
But damn, we had some good and noble intentions, then and now, didn’t we folks. Sad to them all kicked to the curb this way.
Hmmm, any other Pup just lose the edit buttons on the comments?
Well put.
Go for it
Rush Boilbutt Hillbillyheroin Limpdick said it (welfare fraud), so it must be true.
Very interesting. Did you call the Portland or Washington DC number?
and be sure that government domestic spending is at Ronald Regan levels as it was during the Clinton “era”. No public option there and Hillarycare if yu recall was all based on enhancing the private insurance industry.
Yeah, winning really sucks.
1. Fraud can be fought if desired
2. Fraud is easier when there are 100′s/1000′s of differnt HIP’s
3. Fraud against private or fraud against government is the same – either we end up paying higher taxes or premiums…
cuz the government aint paying (they don’t have any money – people and the fed do), and private companies sure ain’t going to eat the cost.
Wee Willy Winkie.
- and what does one do if s/he has 10-20 years left, tops?