Oh, poor, poor Michael Bennet (D-CO). He just doesn’t seem to understand how the legislative process works. He took to the Senate floor to praise what the “Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act”–which was signed yesterday by President Obama–will do. That bill is now law. Today they are working on a completely different bill, a budget reconciliation bill, which mostly contains some tax changes that will not go into effect for years.
Bennet falsely equates what the already-passed health insurance law will do with what this reconciliation bill will accomplish. He claims that trying to make improvements to this minor “sidecar” would be to “play games with the lives of thousands of Coloradans and millions of Americans, and I won’t do it.”
That is absurd. The bill that expands insurance coverage was already signed into law. This reconciliation bill, with its minor changes for the employer mandate, and changes to the excise tax, is not playing games with the lives of millions of Americans. Whether this new bill passes or not it will have little impact on our health care system.
Bennet also claims that merely offering some popular amendments to improve the reconciliation bill would kill it. This is completely nonsense. Changing the bill will only send it back to the House for another vote, where it would likely pass. Because of Byrd rule points of order, the bill will almost certainly need to go back to the House for another vote, anyway. Of course, if there are not enough votes for the amended reconciliation bill in the House, they can always amended the bill again to their liking and send it back to the Senate for a final vote. This is how the legislative process works.
In a moment of pure comedy, Bennet states that he “will continue to fight for the [public option] until we get a vote.” Clearly Bennet doesn’t have the vaguest understanding of what the word “fight” means–because he doesn’t even need to fight to get a vote on the public option. All he needs to do is exercise his right as a senator, and politely ask for a vote on the public option by offering an amendment.
It is completely within his power to get a vote on the public option at this very moment because of the rules of reconciliation. All he needs to do is offer an amendment, and it will get an up-or-down vote in the Senate. In fact, a reconciliation that deals with health care is basically the only time Bennet can be assured to get an up-or-down vote on the public option.
I guess taking one very simple step to ensure that you get a vote on the public option, at the time when you most easily can, is just too hard a fight for Michael Bennet.




47 Comments

Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About FDL Action
sorry about the technical error
Commenter: ADC14
Submitted on 2010/03/24 at 3:59pm
Vote him out. If you have to vote Republican/3rd party, then do it. If the Dems never pay a price for lying, they will never change.
======
Commenter: OldFatGuy
Submitted on 2010/03/24 at 3:58pm
The sad thing is all the folks buying the shitty excuses are likely to buy the ones they hear when the bill goes back to the house anyway.
Oh yea, WITHOUT a public option.
Wonder what excuse they’re working on for explaining that day???
“Gee, Senator, you said the public option couldn’t be added because it mean it would have to go back to the house and we didn’t want any more votes there. Well, since it’s going to go back to the House anyway, why not put the public option?”
And then we’ll hear the excuse they have for that day. And likely lots of folks will drink it up.
It’s like they’re too stupid to think ahead, or we’re too stupid to remember.
Or both.
======
Commenter: leliorisen
Submitted on 2010/03/24 at 3:56pm
The reason that NO Senator will not briong up the public option for a vote is very clear…they have been instructed by the White House not to.
And why is that? Because Obama and Emanuel made a deal months ago, in exchange for insurance industry dollars.
Since these meetings have been confirmed by a New York Times reporter, why has there been no follow-up?
And why the Hell are we acting like there is even the possibility that Obama wants one?
It is one thing for the mainstream media to cover it up, but we should be putting this out there front-and-center.
======
Commenter: alank
Submitted on 2010/03/24 at 3:50pm
Well, we didn’t see that coming, did we?
======
Commenter: rmwarnick
Submitted on 2010/03/24 at 3:50pm
I wonder if the Republicans thought about offering the public option as an amendment, just to make the Dems squirm.
======
A few comments went astray during the burp, hope this is all of them.
Where’s the list which we each sign to provide our address so he can refund our money?
Easy solution: forward it all to his primary opponent.
http://www.andrewromanoff.com/
Should be a campaign for all of them to refund every last nickel they’ve taken in the last year from taxpayers in the form of pay and benefits.
It’s not that he doesn’t understand the legislative process. He’s just a shameless, baldfaced liar, like our president and his staff.
It is easy to understand his confusion. He also conflats Medical Insurance with Health Care.
What galls me about the “don’t rock the boat” Dems jabbing their fingers at the DFHs wanting action from any of those in Congress who mouth support for at least a public option but steadfastly refuse to *act* when it counts to make it happen is that they stammer and fume that we will RUIN EVERYTHING if we don’t SIT DOWN and SHUT UP and stop rocking the boat and go along to get along and at the same time completely ignore the fact that the guy at the helm of the boat has had his crew drilling holes in the bottom of the boat for the past year. And should the entire thing end up sinking we all know exactly whom they are going to blame. (Hint: not themselves and none of the veal pen crowd meekly doing what they’re told no matter how stunningly likely to result in failure.)
As to my appointed Senator Bennet, I let him know very early on that I would be tracking what he did on health care and making my decision about whether to support him or a challenger based on his behavior, not his rhetoric. And though his rhetoric has been generally what I was looking for, his actions belie his stated intentions. I’ll be letting him know that should he stick with his plan to insult my intelligence I’ll be doing all I can to support Andrew Romanoff in the primaries later this year.
Isn’t it amazing that out of 100 Senators, there is not even one that can do the right thing…or even one that can do what they said they’d do. Not one.
“Clearly Bennet doesn’t have the vaguest understanding of what the word “fight” means ……”
This would seem to be a virus afflicting many democrats. First it eats away your balls, then it goes after your intestinal fortitude and ends up lodged in your memory, presumeably forever.
Here are two others that are infected;
Dear Wm,
……..I’m Alan Grayson. I’m a first-term Congressman. I will have to live to 100 to accumulate a record that even remotely resembles the accomplishments of Dennis Kucinich. But I’m honored that Dennis Kucinich wants to help me in my reelection campaign. And he wants you to help, too, by contributing at http://www.CongressmanWithGuts.com.
If you care about justice, equality and peace the way that Dennis Kucinich does, then please help. CongressmanWithGuts.com. Help now.
Alan Grayson
Did I say it goes after your balls? Seems to have skipped Grayson’s because he must have a steel clad pair to send this begagram to me.
Isn’t this the same thing that happened when the ballots were counted in the 2000 election? No one out of the democrats would challenge.
I just posted the same garbage to the Kucinich thread. It boggles the mind, doesn’t it. Shameless.
I am reminded, in the worst possible way, of the events documents in Fahrenheit 9/11 in which the members of the CBC beg for a single Senator to step up to support investigating the widespread reports of voter intimidation and fraud especially targeting black voters in Florida in the 2000 election. And watching not one of these solemn-faced officials take a stand. We all know how that turned out. But they are all honorable men….
I didn’t really know much about him and didn’t have a lot of interest in the race. But I’m starting to like Romanoff for calling him out, and for refusing PAC money.
I could think of worse things to do for the next few months than watch the Colorado veal pen disembowel themselves trying to defend him.
We can all quit looking to the “reconciliation process” now as anything likely to “reconcile” the various disasters contained in the “historic triumph” we are all basking in around here. Alter budget the process may, change the outcome the process will not. Apologies to Yoda.
Look, when one of the most promising amendments in the “reconciliation process” is:
#3586 — To enroll Members of Congress in the Medicaid program. (LeMieux) — in other words, reduce the health coverage available to the Congressrats
you know that the overall process really only rates a laugh track played over a black comedy.
That’s good. We should put that up.
Would someone explain again what happens to *integrity* after a politician lands in Congress? Is it really that cheap a commodity to these people?
A lot of us were disappointed and mystified when Governor Ritter plucked the head of the Denver public school system out of nowhere to take over for Salazar and bypassed obvious and popular choices such as Romanoff or Denver mayor John Hickenlooper. We learned that Bennet had 1) money and 2) connections. I was actually surprised that Bennet has been paying lip service to progressive policies, which I attribute roughly 99.9% to the challenge from Romanoff. Should he fend off the challenge though, it’s a lock that he will make haste running to the right in the general election. The conventional wisdom out here is that with so many Republicans the only Dems that can win are those seen to be “independent” of the mythical liberal wing of the Party.
“Commenter: leliorisen
Submitted on 2010/03/24 at 3:56pm
The reason that NO Senator will not briong up the public option for a vote is very clear…they have been instructed by the White House not to.
And why is that? Because Obama and Emanuel made a deal months ago, in exchange for insurance industry dollars.
Since these meetings have been confirmed by a New York Times reporter, why has there been no follow-up?
And why the Hell are we acting like there is even the possibility that Obama wants one?
It is one thing for the mainstream media to cover it up, but we should be putting this out there front-and-center.”
Ditto.
Ever since I read that, been sitting here with this huge grin from ear to ear that just won’t go away.
The one thing I was never clear on while that was happening was what exactly would’ve happened if one Senator did object. Do you know what the procedure would’ve been after that?
CHICKENSHIT LITTLE DOOGIE HOUSER LOOKIN PUNK ASS!!!
Hi, Buddy!
I knew he was lying when he made the promise. Bennet was chosen by Obama over the objections of every county Democratic group in Colorado. Ritter alienated thousands of Democrats by passing over Andrew Romanoff. B ennett has no history giving a shit about Coloradan and he is wrong if he thinks the majority of Coloradans didn’t want medicare for all. There is a reason for that.
I get so damned tired of hearing that the voters don’t want “socialized medicine”. All we heard for years from the Republicans was one threat after another that “if you vote for Democrats you’ll wind up with socialized medicine. That is the Republican Battle Cry.
So, why the hell is there any controversy about qwhat the hell voters wanted? We don’t need a poll to figure out what voters wanted in 2008-2008. We were promised by Republicans that if we voted for Democrats we would get Socialized Medicine.
We voted in Democrats and we want our damned Socialized Medicine!
I do not – I was hoping we would all learn a civics lesson about the strength of our Constitution. Instead what I recall is endless solemn intoning from the Chris Matthews and others in the Village Punditry that the country could not survive waiting till votes were counted and We Must Decide Right Now!!!!
I have been reminded more and more of this particular style of bullshit during the past few weeks right up to today as all we keep hearing is You Must Pass the Senate Bill INTACT!!!! or the Sky Will Fall!!! ZOMG, the GOP will end life as we know it if you introduce that wildly popular amendment for a public option that a majority in the House already passed. Hurry hurry hurry vote today or You Will Kill Us All!!!!!
Although my bullshit meter exploded sometime in the past couple months, I’m pretty sure this particular rationale for why no one can do what the public wants and so many of them claim to want Simply Cannot Be Done At This Time would send the needle quite far into the red.
So, there will be no public option amendment; but we do get this:
An appropriate riposte now for a Dem would be to put in amendment to deny Viagra to John Ensign, Larry Craig, David Vitter, Mark Sanford, Mark Foley et al.
Come on, where’s our apologist who will say “What did you expect him to do?”, “He’s a good man, just like Dennis and others..”
Really? When will we learn? There is no downside for them ignoring us? What are we going to do otherwise? The old adage about insanity being the action of doing the same thing over and over and expecting a different result is beginning to come to mind.
The party needs to be abandoned. Change can not be fashioned from within.
Hereby abandoned. Smell you later ‘Democrats’, ya cheap shit little cowards.
Late to the thread, sorry.
There was good turnout today at the Petition Event. There were two people, of the veal pen persuasion there, holding up signs saying “Don’t Derail The Bill!”
Far worse to imagine the Colorado voters who take his words sincerely, and believe him, glad to hear that someone is going to “fight” for the public option.
Did you ask them what bill they were talking about?
LOL, I should have!
Oh noes! Another chapter in the on-going saga of Charlie, Lucy and the football. Who could have predicted?
On a more serious note, I’m gonna look up that Street article on the Left in the age of O. I gotta find something to do besides kvetch.
It’s become apparent to me that this lack of integrity doesn’t just apply to politicians. Look at all the Democrats that were swearing they would leave the Democratic Party if they screwed us on the public option, the same ones that are now touting this betrayal over at Kos and HP like it’s the second coming. We’ll have to face the fact that we are the minority, that integrity and a firm principled stand are too much for most.
Congress either. Guess that’s what we all get when almost all of the elected representatives are rich.
Vote this asshat out of office. Maybe the teabaggers should be turned loose on these cowards.
So, what kind of fun can we make of these Senators like Harkin, Bennett et al when the bill has to go back to the House despite their zero amendment strategy?
The whole shell game they are playing now is cringe-worthy…but I’m a little tired of cringing. Let’s have some fun with this.
damn lying republicans
After all this, I do appreciate fun. I am hoping for some ads running in Iowa telling the good people all about the money Harkin gets from the insurance industry. I am ready to fund that ad as soon as someone gets it going. He is a damn shame.
If Anschutz calls Bennett and tells him to breath in water – Bennett breaths in water… This guy is a stooge for Phil Anschutz and always has been….
I have a new name. Principled Progressive. Until we endorse candidates based on principles, we will not have principled politicians. After kos and moveon, I could no longer be a progressive.
Oh come on, he’s a Rahm man through and through.
Pretty sad, these are our leaders and if we keep supporting so called “electables, this is what we get.
Don’t worry, they plan to bring out the public option again right before the election so Harry can keep his seat.
Principled Progressive? If they’re in elected office, that’s a non-sequitur, a contradiction in terms.
“After all this, I do appreciate fun.”
Me too.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D2Ka2nkIi2I
Alright, that wasn’t as good as I remember, this should do it..
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8jvl8rs95pU
It’s the White House, stupid!