Marion Berry (D-AR) is unlikely vote for the Senate health care bill in the House, but he has recently submitted is own, less comprehensive health care bill (PDF). Primarily, what it does is fix the problems with the Medicare Part D program created by former Republican Rep. Billy Tauzin, which Democrats have been promising to fix for years. That is until President Obama promised now PhRMA lobbyist Billy Tauzin to not fix Medicare Part D as part of health care reform.
Marion Berry’s bill is a surprisingly populist, consumer-friendly affair. It contains some consumer protection regulations, it repeals the health insurance industry’s anti-trust exemption, and imposes a minimum medical loss ratio of 92%. Which, if properly enforced (and that is a big “if”), should effectively make it not worthwhile to be a for-profit health insurance company.
The biggest thing the bill does is fix the two most glaring problems with Medicare Part D that Democrats have been demagoging for years. It would allow for drug re-importation and direct Medicare drug price negotiation by creating a “Medicare operated prescription drug plan”–a public option on the Medicare Part D exchange to compete with the private plans.
Marion Berry’s bill is clearly not going anywhere and, strangely, contains abortion restriction language, which makes no policy sense because it does not directly expand coverage with federal money. What the bill does sadly show is that many popular progressive health care reform provisions, like drug re-importation, direct drug price negotiation, repealing anti-trust exemption, are even supported by very conservative Democrats. It is amazing that, while Democrats completely control Congress and the White House, core party platform planks like drug re-importation and Medicare direct drug price negotiations still go unfixed. Of course, I’m sure some magical Senate rule is to “blame.”




21 Comments

Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About FDL Action
“It is amazing that, while Democrats completely control Congress and the White House, core party platform planks like drug re-importation and Medicare direct drug price negotiations still go unfixed. Of course, I’m sure some magical Senate rule is to “blame.” ; Jon , we both know that drug re-importation was killed NOT by some Senate rule but by the Obama Admin. Durbin HAD the votes until the WH stepped in.
What I find amusing yet disheartening is the ‘blame game’ going on about the Senate and House with very little of the blame going to where it should be pointed and that is the Obama Admin.
You failed to recognize that this ridiculous proposal is nothing more than a simple act of ‘pandering to the base’. The “progressive” base, I suppose. It’s timing, that it seems to be in response to recent anger on the left over healthcare… don’t fall for it. There are other clues to:
Imposition of a medical-loss ratio 92%… Why would you want our government to illegalize or otherwise make unprofitable, the entire insurance industry? It’s one of the nation’s biggest employers… I just don’t understand this- and it’s clearly a bloated number to woo ultra-liberals and populists (hello Michael Moore). Also, connect the dots and see how Medicare D is exactly the same thing that this healthcare reform is- with the noted difference that D is prescription coverage only. There is no public option on Medicare D. There are exchanges, a minimum $ plan, people are auto enrolled in it if they are on Medicare- individual mandate.
I am not in favor of abolishing private insurance, and you need not be either. A public plan alone would force the ins companies to reform themselves, that’s the point. Reforming Med D would be done easily by establishing a prescription plan within Medicare itself. All done.
Now, abortion language, in a prescription bill????? Stupid. You also need to urge Democratic politicians to stop trying to cover abortions with anything, ever. Why do they do this? It infuriates 90% of the country and makes 12 femenist authors happy. It’s almost like a knee-jerk necessity, like how can I think of a way to torpedo a bill (or my entire political career) if I don’t want to have to vote for something later- oh I know! Suggest we cover abortions!
I guess you stopped typing because all that foaming at the mouth shorted out your keyboard.
Obama is good at Deception, very good!
Obama tells all these heart breaking stories about how Insurance Companies raises people rates. The audience thinks that Obama Insurance Welfare Plan wink wink “Health Care Reform” bill will reduce their Insurance Rates.
Obama never says his plans will keep Insurance Companies from raising your rates. (the blind and dumb americans are suppose to assume that Obama HCR scam will lower their Insurance Rates, Obama HCR will not lower Insurance Rates)
Again this is INSANE, Obama acts like people are not going to ask him and other Dems “WHY are my Health Care Cost still going up?” Obama what are they going to say? “We lied to the american people, so that insurance companies could make more money.”
Attention whoever believes that they are going to “fix” Health Insurance Company Welfare: I have a bridge for sale. Cheap!
I kind of laughed at abortion language in a *Medicare* bill.
There isn’t a whole lot of demand for abortion at nursing homes and retirement centers.
The only people who have suggested that this bill is going to cover abortion are right wing anti choice fanatics. The Hyde amendment clearly precludes federal money from paying for abortion services. Try again with less spittle.
I’ve read a few interviews of Berry in the last month or so… since he announced he won’t be running again.
Bitter… doesn’t begin to describe him well enough.
it’s not so much that he is good at BS, rather that the American public apparently can’t get enough of it.
…this goes to the middle of it…how come Obama WH is not taking more and harder thrown punches for it’s pathetic G.W.Bush cover version of giving AHIP what it wants…the propaganda catapulting is shameless–
…Barack Obama is showing himself to be more of a ward level politician who has no problem doing the backroom insider deals ( AHIP and PhRMA) and then telling his ward that he really is doing them a favor–what a great guy…and he has a great smile while he sticks it to you…good and deep…
…the politics of this HCR are so rotted and just plain vile when the ruse of what is being done here as opposed to what is being sold and yet the dumbshit Democrats think they can blame it on the Republicans and tell us how wonderful the Democrats are…Tammany Hall resurrected…
The dummies and easily duped are going for it too.
They deserve what comes next.
The rest of us malcontents do not but we will get it anyway.
The told you so’s are going to be brutal. Real brutal.
So well deserved by the dummies,dupes and democratbots.
A version of Saddam’s WMD that never were found. Who could have known?
What? That it was all a ruse? Or that it was transparent abuse of the easily duped and lead alongs? Barack Obama is doing the same with this fake HCR.
He deserves full contempt for betraying long term American HC betterment of poor,near poor,the economic abused and social ostracized American.
watertiger is upstairs!
Late Night: Yes, Virginia, There is a Sanity Clause
Michael Moore on countdown gave Dennis K. a super endorsement for everthing he is doing. Michael Morre said Dennis K. is the only congress person standing up for 300 million americans.
My name is Obama I am against Drug Importation
My name is Obama I am against the Public Option
My name is Obama I am for the individual mandate
My name is Obama I want to tax Union Health Care Plans
My name is OBAMA I want to roll back Roe Vs Wade
Who thinks Obama is a Progressive? Democrat?
What is the difference between Glenn Beck and Obama?
Some stupid Dems wants Obama to campaign for them? WHY?
Yes, the blame is on Obama and his administration. Because? Because early on they played a backroom game and met with Tauzin, one of the creators of PlanD the Senior Drug Plan screwjob handed to Seniors in Medicare Plan D. Obama made his deal with Pharma promising them…no importation, no negotiating for
wholesale Medicare prices that could help seniors, and a limit on releasing generics which save Senior and others a great deal.
Not to mention that the whores in the WHouse agreed to let Pharma contribute a lousy 80 billion [sure to be reneged on] over a period of 10 years. This is a birthday gift to big Pharma. Last year’s profits were 77 billion, net. Their promise? Election advertising and promise of no ads against this bill. What chiselers.
So I have concluded as a lifelong democrat that the sleazes in the WHiteHouse are a pack of cold blooded manipulating liars. Obama’s hypocricy and lies are unspeakable. He has repeadetly contradicted his own statements and assertions. Forget the hit on abortion rights and treating women as politically expedient and second class.
And has he or anyone else explanied EXACTLY WHAT THE MEDICARE AND MEDICAID CUTS WILL BE? AND WHEN DOES WHAT KICK INTO A SYSTEM THAT DOESN’T REALLY START UNTIL 2014?
THIS ENTIRE HEALTHCARE BILL IS CURRENTLY LIKE A STATUE BEFORE THE UNVEILING TAKES PLACE. WE NEVER KNOW WHAT’S UNDERNEATH IT’S COVER.
I know we need a third party. Something has to happen as the democrats are a disgraceful scattered group of misfits,liars,& panderers who have no political skills and no political center or will.
Obama is an old school Tammany Hall pol. Chicao style.
They’ll say anything and deal from backrooms whenever possible which is most of the time.
The threats and heavy handed thuggery politics to snare votes is a total reminder of corruption among ward heeling politicians which is exactly what Obama and Co. are. Pathetically there are those “progressives”like Markos on Daily Kos who fashion themselves politically knowledgeable and pull water on and on for Obama and Co. no matter what.
There is a disease among liberals and progressives who wish to remain blind rather than disappointed and they will turn out to be no better for avoiding the truth. They refuse to admit that Obama has sold out and is a totalitarian conducting ruthless nuclear hit politics as he professes to be a liberal pathfinder.
There is the disease of denial that you speak of, but I do think that people are getting over it. The hard-core DEMs I talk to in my social circle and community are more than disappointed, they feel down lied to and betrayed. I think this is going to a tough November for the DEMs and I don’t think they have any idea. Why, I don’t know. I suspect election day on November may well be renamed “couch potato day.”
Only on this blog could we combine a riff about “harcore Dems” with ANYTHING that has Marion Berry’s name on it….The perpetual bitterness has driven some, so far to the ‘left’ that they are now ‘right’…Where’s that righteous Grover Norquist’ post?
Since the Nixon Administration, Medicare has also covered the disabled (many of whom are, of course, women of childbearing age). So Medicare does cover pregnancy and childbirth.
It was nice to see Pelosi call out the White House on the PhRMA deal:
On the flip side, she used the White House as cover when she removed Kucinich’s amendment from the House bill, after it passed the Education and Labor Committee. His amendment would have prevented private insurers from suing states for violating ERISA if they enacted single-payer systems. Pelosi also made a fool out of Weiner, promising him a floor vote on his amendment for a nationwide single-payer system, then reneging, but still giving Stupak his vote on his anti-abortion amendment.
The House bill is dead, but this all goes to show Pelosi’s support for single-payer is a sham.
Ubie, I believe Jon was being facetious.
Yup and yup. As half-assed as the progs have been on the PO, they weren’t even in the building where single-payer was concerned.