Now we see one of the reasons the Senate is including student loans in reconciliation — they don’t want to tax rich people (as the House does) so they’re stealing the money from community colleges.
The Senate HELP Committee is currently writing the student loan reconciliation bill that the House has to pass (the House having become completely irrelevant to the democratic process). And all of that amazing $87 billion in savings couldn’t just go to the students and schools that badly need it. They’ve accepted Kent Conrad’s dictum that the lower CBO score be used, and they’re hacking away at it:
Democrats have had to get their knives out to get the student loan measure’s costs under the $61-billion-over-10-years ceiling. Some of the casualties — like $8 billion for early childhood education, and $4 billion for school modernization — didn’t trouble college leaders a bit, as they quietly opposed using savings from the student loan programs for those non-college purposes all along.
But some of the other cuts would prove enormously painful. Foremost among them is the apparent excision of the entire American Graduation Initiative, which would pour as much as $12 billion over 10 years into grants and construction funds for community colleges. President Obama has put two-year institutions at the center of his higher education agenda, a major change from previous administrations, and the American Graduation Initiative was designed not just to provide more money to the colleges, but to link the money to a set of quality indicators aimed at increasing accountability demands on them.
With unemployment soaring, so is enrollment in community colleges. That’s where many minority students who are unable to find work wind up, in order to increase their job skills and qualify for higher paying jobs. Historically black and hispanic colleges would still get money, but that $600 million over the next two years is small change compared to the $11.3 billion for K-12 modernization, early education and community colleges now lost (per the CBO).
The House health care bill paid for health care reform by taxing the wealthy. But Larry Summers doesn’t like to tax rich people, and the White House doesn’t want to be accused of “raising taxes.” Of course, they could just make up the money by including a public plan — even a weak one would save $25 billion.
Instead, the most economically vulnerable are having their futures hacked away to pay AHIP a 20% fee for doing nothing in the health care process. And Ben Nelson hasn’t even begun shaking the bill down for Nelnet, JP Morgan and Citigroup.
Sign the petition — tell the Senate to take care of students, not banks.





40 Comments

Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About FDL Action
On the Diane Rehm show Ezra Klein said that the public option is “dead”
And while you are at it look at the NYT piece on the trade school ripoffs. They are directly swindling these same people.
It is always amazing how Congress seems to bungle everything. It is fairly clear who they are working for, and it is not you or I, but so many people don’t seem to notice/care…
If I was in the House of Representatives I’d be sorely tempted to resign over this mess. The Senate’s all powerful now. The Constitution is being used as toilet paper to line AHIP’s pockets.
Hey Jane: O/T: Enjoyed the appearance yesterday on Ian Masters’ show. I notice that he posted his interview with Dennis K. to FDL yesterday. Took quite a bit of site heat for it, although I’m not entirely clear why. Anyway…Enjoyed your interview. Good stuff.
I’m telling you the Democratic Party is in serious danger of a full-scale mutiny if they don’t shape up. In fact it may be too late even if they do shape up.
Help for college students is just not politically “doable”. The money must go to rich people.
The Democratic Party has lost whatever bit of credibility it once had. I have voted the party line for two decades and contributed to the DNC, the DSCC, the DCCC, and presidential candidates in the past. No more.
The Senate doesn’t give a shit. We’re attempting to affect pro citizen legislation while they’re working on building a post modern totalitarian State.
By not organizing street protests alongside signing ‘pretty please’ petitions we’re only telling them that our patience is still far from being exhausted. They have declared class warfare on the people and there’s nary a peep from the unions, the students, the unemployed and ordinary working people.
We need bodies in the Streets! History tells us that and we’re not listening. WTF?
by the by…..our NOT for profit ins companies
Top Blue Cross salaries soar: report-by at least 48 percent, CEO by 62%
Top Blue Cross salaries soar: report
As President Obama rails against insurance company abuses in an effort to bolster his health-care reform bill, the salaries for top officials at Blue Cross & Blue Shield of Illinois’ corporate parent will almost certainly add fuel to his fire.
Crain’s Chicago Business says the 10 most senior executives of the nonprofit Health Care Service Corp. saw their compensation jump last year by at least 48 percent, thanks to huge bonuses. Compensation more than doubled for six.
CEO Patricia Hemingway Hall’s compensation spiked 62 percent to $8.7 million. That was $2.2 million more than Humana CEO Michael McCallister earned — even though Humana’s $31 billion in revenues last year was nearly double that of the Chicago-based Health Care Service.
“It’s greedy and outrageous,” Wheaton business owner Linda Cherrington told Crain’s. Her company switched insurers when Blue Cross premiums went up 45 percent.
http://www.suntimes.com/business/2101711,CST-NWS-bluecr…
Obama and his team of morons, are trying to run a campaign built around complete lies, that is going to back fire on them BIG TIME!
Obama talks and promotes his Health Care Reform bill like there is a tool in the Bill that is going to make Health Care Insurance Decrease. Obama and his bands of liars know that no tool exist.
Once the GOP and other Real Liberals groups run ads saying Obama just promoted a bill that is going to make you buy Well Point, Blue Cross Blue Sheild etc. with out a Public Option. No dem will be able to fight against this TRUTHFUL attack and survive.
Obama and his band of liars are trying to promote the IDEA that insurance companies hate the health care bill they wrote with Max Baucus. Once Insurance companies stocks soar, I don’t think the american people are going to buy this lie either.
Lying and trying to fool americans in the middle of a Depression is going to end badly for OBAMA and his band of liars.
Progressives and most people who consider Democrats to be the party of FDR, will consider OBAMA to be the biggest traitor to ever enter the White House.
Obama and his band of liars do not understand the new enemy they will face.
Depression politics forces you to tell the truth, because doing otherwise will result in a huge backlash.
Obama and his band of liars are digging their own graves, thinking MSNBC, Huffington Post, Daily Kos, and others will be able to save them is insane, the above groups will be force to tell the truth and will also turns their guns on the White House and lying Dems.
To maintain order in a DEPRESSION, govt must be honest with the people. If not govt will lose it purpose and people will take the law into their own hands. Ask the GOP what the tea party is up to?
‘Sticks and stones may break my bones but ‘words’ will never hurt me’, is the response of the Senators to their aids bringing them reams of petitions.
Candle light vigils mourning the demise of American pseudo Democracy? Is that too much to ask from the citizenry ?!
Thanks for the post Jane. Off to sign.
Is it me or is this a game of six-ways-to-Saturday’s beat the poor and low income citizens down?
It is as though someone has the numbers crunched for “destroy the poor” mode. It appears the plan to put something into the legislation whenever a gain is made to help lower income. A constant benefit offset game.
Our passivity is becoming dangerous.
is that Ezra not dry behind the ears Kline?
Jane mentioned in a post last week that she was thinking about running ads in college/university newspapers. Has anyone heard more about it? I’m hoping she’ll put an example of one of the ads up at FDL so we can see what she has in mind. The Democratic Party and individual Senate Democrats should be called out by name in those ads, imo.
so creepy , sites like kos and the rest of the msm fully on board with the lie
everyone wants to be in the in crowd,
once the in crowd becomes hated and despise, this is when the members of the in crowd start killing each other. Just like High School
it is always best to stand for something, because if you don’t you will fall for anything.
I doubt the corporate MSM will stop lying, since Walter Cronkite left CBS, the american news has become a joke.
Donald Trump statements last week on MSNBC, about how the Chinese consider american politicians to be complete morons, says it all.
The WORLD is laughing at the USA.
community colleges are an invaluable resource. its a shame they’re getting screwed over like this. I went to a community college 2 years before transferring to a university. I don’t think I’d have been able to go to college otherwise. CC’s have my heart, and Obama campaigned on expanding funding to cc’s. I’m so disappointed to see this…
Why all the negativity?
This plan is a big step in the right direction.
Rush Limbaugh is threatening to leave the US if it passes, so it’s got to be good!
Don’t side with him.
Support the president and the Ds!
When the student loan fix came out I was really surprised. Could they have been trying to mollify students so the demonstrations would stop? But as the process moved along they started to stripe out the bill due to pressure from the crooks?
Obama like Bush is continuing the direct attack on the Middle Class.
What ECONOMIST would promote cutting Community College funds in the middle of a Depression? Not one.
Obama and Bush are creating a new class of american society call the “PERMANENT UNDERCLASS”
Families in the “PERMANENT UNDER CLASS” will only get to experience the NIGHTMARE of america not the american Dream.
Can this zombie bill finally be killed? It’s become just another weapon in the plutocracy’s class war against those who must work.
In Greece last week 60.000 were on the streets of Athens. If the government of France attempted to do some of the things the Obama administration has done or not done there would be millions of people on the streets. In the U.S. the passivity of the American public is stunning. Could be that Europeans by and large live their lives “on the streets” whereas Americans live their lives either on their sofas or in their private automobiles.
Who’s your representative? Run against them. I hope everyone does.
one step forward, one step back
thanks dems!
8.7 BILLION??? My state, South Carolina, has been cutting educational funding like crazy. Everyone I talk to (Pro. or Con.) wonder why education is the first to get the axe. Why combine THE DIRECT STUDENT LOAN BILL with THE HEALTH REFORM BILL? Why are legislators afraid to fund education? THE DIRECT STUDENT LOAN BILL should stand alone. Maybe it’s the fear that young people will learn whats really going on in D.C. Students and faculty from Georgia are rallying in Atlanta today 3/15/2010.
The Democrats can count me out, as well.
I just can’t believe the extents the USG will go to in order to avoid presenting the richest members of our society with the same tax picture they would face in any other developed nation in the Western World.
They are working for ‘emselves,remember most if not all are multi-millionaires.
It was one day going to bites us on the backsides,where better than most of our representatives being very wealthy is not good for our democracy,that one day is now.
It’s hard out there for a serf when the leaders are busy creating a serfdom!
Well, if Nancy refuses to allow a public option, they still could strip the individual mandates, hell, all mandates out of the bill. That’s what those who signed the petition should do if you ask me. Say that the price for their yes vote is that mandates go unless a public option is allowed in.
Jane has an even fresher cross-post already in progress: Progressives Who Don’t Honor Their Pledge: Corporatists In Sheep’s Clothing
My rep is going to be Marcy Winograd, if I can help it, and I will try hard. Still, we need to lend physical support to petitioning if we care to get the least bit of reaction fro out current crop of critters. Why have we taken one of the best tools out of the process? Why are we so willing to ignore that tied hand behind our backs? Whu no multitasking?
Let’s cut community colleges that are accountable to the public, so everyone is forced into for-profit trade schools. They charges 10x as much, collect Pell grants and federal backed loans, and leave students with huge debts and no skills.
Some people might think that’s the plan all along. Just guess which investment bank owns one of the major chains Education Management Corporation(Argosy, Art Institutes, Brown-Mackie)?(hint: initials GS)
41,000 California Public School employees got “pink-slipped” today…24,000 of then classroom teachers.
Obama did give some warning of what he would do as president, but mostly to private fundraisers. This was reported by Charles Babbington and got much less coverage than Mayfair Fowler’s report on the private San Francisco fundraiser where Obama made his infamous remarks about “bitter” and “clingy” residents of PA.
At this private fundraiser he indicated he would have to cut back on promises he’d been making. As he has indeed done…. Begins with Paragraph 14.
Again, these are remarks made at a private fundraiser, not for the general public….
But Obama did say publicly back in April ’08 that politicians’ promises can’t be trusted:
Pot…kettle?
(I had a dickens of a time finding Babbington quote, needed better search terms. But my comment at TL still exists, thank you, Jeralyn!)
ARE THEY GOING TO MARCH? Lets see them sack their awful leadership and hit the streets. Then we can join them.
Granholm (D-MI) just put her retirement legislation up – through 4 Republicans- two in the house and two in the senate. She is an OBummer. She works for them. Doesn’t mind taking what is earned by others. Glad shes leaving. Worthless to the people and most certain to piss off all the public and state employees with its unfairness.