It looks like the DNC spent nearly half-a-million dollars to praise Ben Nelson for ruining health care reform. According to Joe Sudbay at Americablog:
Last month, Ben Nelson did a TV ad defending his vote on health care. He talks straight to the camera and disses those “who wanted a government takeover.” That sounds like an attack on people who supported the public option, because that’s as close as Congress got to a “government takeover.”
That half-million-dollar ad was paid for by the Nebraska Democratic Party. Where did they get all that money to waste on ads for a candidate not up for election for three more years? Turns out it was from the DNC:
Yes, the DNC and Organizing for America (OFA) have been asking supporters to chip in for the fight to pass real health care reform, including a public option. But, who does it look like benefited from those donations, your donations? Ben Nelson, the guy who worked to kill real reform. And he got the money after he killed real reform, almost like it was a pay off.
Nelson announced his support for the much-weakened Senate health care bill on December 19, 2009. He cast his vote for final passage on December 24, 2009. The DNC transferred money to the Nebraska party on December 28, 2009. You do the math.
Ben Nelson was partly responsible for demanding that the very popular public option and Medicare buy-in were dropped from the bill. His opposition to what was a very right-of-center reform package helped play right into the Republican narrative about health care reform.
The numerous days spent trying to appease Ben Nelson resulted in the Senate vote being delayed, and ended up pushing it very close to the Massachusetts election. The horse-trading Nelson demanded all year greatly damaged the bill’s popularity. The Medicaid deal for Nebraska, added to win Ben Nelson’s ultimate support, became a huge political issue in the Massachusetts special election. And, of course, that $500,000 would probably have been better spent at that exact moment helping Martha Coakley.
If the DC Democratic establishment wonders why the base is very depressed going into 2010, or wonders why House Democrats are on the path to suffering crushing defeats in the midterm election, actions like this from the DNC are probably part of the answer.



41 Comments








Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About FDL Action
I can’t imagine how you cover this corruption day after day after day. I don’t know how you do it, but I thank you.
I think the Ds don’t have a “base” anymore.
By any chance is there someone at OFA or DNC who will take “credit” for this brilliant strategy? Next time they ask me to donate I will have this handy.
Yeppurs, we should all give our dust to the DNC, DSCC and DCCC. Sure didn’t take them long to revert to the Clintonista vision.
It’s teetering to be sure and they did it to themselves.
Okay, someone please share some email addresses for the top folks at the DNC so I can politely provide them with my point of view.
There won’t be a progressive Democratic Party in the future if something isn’t done at each opportunity as it comes up.
2010 is an election year.
Something needs to be done this cycle to advance the mission.
It looks like the progressive part of the Obama era is over/never happened.
It’s been an amazing feat to watch. On top of the world one short year ago. Kinda like W in the year following 9/11.
There is no progressive D party. There are a handful of members of congress and that’s about it. The D party is now totally owned by the corps.
Does the DNC think the “base” is not going to find out about this crap?
I need to intensify my calls for someone to do a story on the “responses” the DNC/OFA et al. get to their pleas for $$$$. ‘Cause my friends & I are sending neither $$$ nor Valentines.
I’d really like a count of how many “fuck you’s” they’re receiving. Talk about “firing up the base for November . . . “
It’s a two party system, so which one should we work on? Better chance of capturing the Democratic Party than the Republican Party.
You really should embed these truly awful videos, they are a sight to behold.
There is no doubt that this man is a republican.
The DNC is taking credit using counter-intutive reasoning that they have to counter the insurance cos that have given him about a 1/2 million.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4p5RhqJirNQ&feature=player_embedded
I haven’t a clue what to do. Both parties are hopeless.
It’s primary day in Illinois, and teh suck is evident everywhere. The democratic party in Illinois is so beyond redemption, that there will be little surprise when a Republican takes over Obama’s Senate seat and the Governor’s office. Same story as Massachusetts.
This little calf has escaped his pen and refuses to be someone’s veal.
Time for Kaine to be fired. We’re going to get creamed all over the country and he’s wasting 500K on Nelson?
Moron.
There will be NO more donations to pols from me. I can never outbid the big players at the table to buy a politician. Guess who wins when ONE person puts a million dollars in the pols pot, and a two million plebes put in a dollar each into the pols pot? …. Suckers game, that.
Can’t tell for certain if the last rights were given but I know for real..no public option no Dem Party. Predicted this at beginning of HCR and it’s a NO brainer!
No matter how much money is given to candidates they can’t buy an election, they need votes.
They could have spent gazillions more in Massachusetts, but it would not have won the election for the Democrat.
We need to organize in voting blocks and build representative strength as feasible each cycle until we have an important representative block.
Probably should be national candidates operating from a small locale. A number of liberals in red states are disenfranchised. Constituent service should expand beyond geographic borders. It’s not like Wall Street funds only its homeboy Schumer.
with this news, let us remember David Dayen’s reporting from last week: Nelson claims he would have filibustered anyway
take a cursory skim of Dayen’s article, you tell me, do ya think his DNC colleagues didn’t know this ??
Oh well.
Deadthreaded again.
Jennifer Brunner could have put that money to good use in Ohio’s Senate race against Rob Portman.
Or Gov. Ted Strickland in his race against John Kaisich.
How many voters in Nebraska anyway? 500k seems like an epic buy for the Omaha market.
agree with you. believe I read something about DNC giving Bruner grief about her fundraising, apparently wishing to go with some 3 time loser
What a bunch of fuckin’ assholes.
We need to identify folks who worked with Dean on the 50 state strategy and put ‘em back to work somehow. We might actually be able to build an opposition party between now and 2012. Peel off the Tea Partiers who haven’t crossed over into batshit ignorant. Tell the Greens to either shit or get off the pot. Tell the Dem and Rethug Parties to get fucked.
Here’s the contact page from the DNC website:
http://www.democrats.org/contact.html
There are no specific names, but there are categories to click on.
I didn’t see that post by David Dayen on Nelson, but after I read the whole interview, I’m really glad that Brown got elected. At least he is pro-choice.
http://www.lifesitenews.com/ldn/2010/jan/10012603.html
Nelson was really trying to pull a fast one, even worse than was reported (!) and I feel dirty after reading that. To think that the Democrats would rather let Nelson wipe his ass all over it and then shove it down our throats, rather than bring back a real filibuster in order to get something resembling real reform says a lot.
This looks a lot like a suicide pact to me, they are attempting to triangulate for blue dogs favor and showing themselves to be idiots.
I’m for something like this. We can’t reform either party, it’s time to realize that and start fighting to break up the 2 big to fail political parties with one that actually represents sane, thinking Americans.
That is an excellent idea.
Off topic a bit –
Will someone at FDL please verify the WH line that they are only “one vote away” in the House from passing HCR.
And what does that mean?
What about other stories of a new try all-together?? Not seeing any recent blogs reporting on what’s going on..
Good reason to stop giving to DNC and give to progressive web sites. No way do I want to give money to thank Ben Nelson for killing the public option.
That is why I will not give to the DNC, DSCC, DCCC for the foreseeable future and return the solicitations with a little love note.
Why isn’t anyone holding Tim Kane to task for the horrendous operation of the DNC this last year. It is true that Michael Steele is an idiot, but at least he is visible and active in the political environment. So while the DNC is raising funds for healthcare reform including the public option, they are spending the money campaigning against it. How often has Kaine even mentioned the words public option? To my knowledge he never his rare appearance on a Sunday talk show. So far under his leadership (could not think of a different word to use here), we have lost two Governorships and one Senate race. One of the Governorships was for the seat he has been holding. I think it is time for Kaine to spend more time with his family. If he provides anymore leadership, the democrats will be back to holding meetings in the capital basement with the lights out.
We need Dean back as well!!!
There have been six of your holy revealed two-party systems throughout this country’s history. Are you so married to the marketing message of the D party that you’re not willing to go for #7?
Do you think the DNC reads FireDogLake?
DNC may not need FireDogLake, but it needs the money of the FDL regular readers/activists.
I will try to explain why the DNC would give to a Democrat who support the DNC and President on Obama on healthcare. Senator Nelson voted “for” on healthcare reform. Yes “for” means he supports healthcare reform. His “for” vote is the same as Bernie Sanders “for” vote. The DNC wanted “for” votes.
Nebraska is a very Red state. When a Senator from that state votes “for” something that is unpopular in his state it will hurt him politically. Therefore the DNC will fund some ads for him in the hopes it will increase his political strength so he will vote “for” DNC policies again.
Luckily for us the good folks of Nebraska sent us Ben Nelson instead of opponent a Republican who would have voted “against”.
Now I want everybody to understand. If Nebraska sends a Democrat to the Senate healthcare reform gets a “for” vote just the same as if they had sent Bernie Sanders or Tom Harkin. (Is this to complicated for anybody?). If Nebraska sends a Republican or somebody like Dennis Kucinich then healthcare fails.
So here is why the DNC helps Ben Nelson. It is in the interest of the DNC to have a Ben Nelson who votes for DNC positions. It is not in the interest of the DNC to see a Republican win his Senate seat.
Now I hate to disappoint all the TEABLOGGERS at FDL suffering from Nelson Derangement Syndrome but this a question of political math.
The Senate leadership and the DNC should be punishing Nelson, and forcing him to switch parties. He’s dangerous as a Democrat, but as a Republican would be just another nutcase nuisance.
58 is as good as 59. For that matter, oust Landrieu and Lincoln and pare the majority down to 56 who can be counted on not to stab the party in the back.
I received 2 emails from the DNCC via James Carville and some other mope requesting contributions.
I sent them both a response starting with “F#@k the dems who can’t govern”.
well said, Tomh. spending money to educate voters in places like Nebraska is a good use of DNC funds.
the notion that this was a major issue in the Massachusetts election is absurd. Scott Brown won because he’s not Martha Coakley, and people here wanted to shove it to the national media, who kept talking about “the Kennedy seat.”
corruption or not. public option or not. we are pulled away from THE ISSUE affordable Healthcare… anyway I can get it I will take it. Amjad Hourani
tough to get around the lobbyist. The peasants are at the back of the long $$$$ line.