In the Senate, Kay Hagan sponsored an almost identical piece of legislation to Rep. Eshoo’s on biologic drugs, which would keep important lifesaving treatments for breast cancer and other diseases which can cost $50,000 or $300,000 a year from every becoming generics.
Even if you’ve got an 80% insurance copay, as Sherrod Brown notes, that’s a hefty tab:
All too often, the pricetag for this type of drug is simply too high for the patient who needs it. For instance, annual treatment for breast cancer with the brandname biologic drug Herceptin costs $48,000. Even if you are lucky enough to have health insurance and you are paying 20 percent copay, that is $9,600 a year. More than 192,000 American women will be diagnosed with breast cancer in 2009. How are they going to afford that kind of drug?
Paying for these drugs routinely drive breast cancer patients into financial ruin. Senator Brown is trying to decide whether he’s got the support to offer up his better bill as an amendment to the Hagan/Eshoo PhRMA boondogle. His cosponsors are Chuck Schumer, Debbie Stabinow, Susan Collins and David Vitter. (Yes, David Vitter’s position on these lifesaving drugs for breast cancer patients is far, far superior to Anna Eshoo’s.)
If the White House is looking for bipartisan support for an issue in the health care bill, this is it. The President himself supported a 7 year monopoly rather than Eshoo’s 12 year monopoly (even though the FTC recommended “zero.”)
Senator Chuck Schumer (D-NY): 202-224-6542
Senator Susan Collins (R-ME): 202-224-2523
Senator Sherrod Brown (D-OH): 202-224-2315
Senator Debbie Stabenow (D-MI): 202-224-4822
Senator David Vitter (R-LA): 202-224-4623





32 Comments
Spotlight




Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About FDL Action
Advanced search
To the phones, people !
Also, call Pelosi’s office and tell her to include Dennis Kucinich’s amendment into the House Bill.
Pelosi’s D.C. Office (202) 225-4965; San Francisco Office (415) 556-4862
Signed. Are these people ever going to break the hold the murder by spreadsheet industry has on them?
Thank you, Jane!!
Thank you, Knox!
I spoke to a woman in Eshoo’s office this morning. She was very good and knew the talking points. She told me that the things that were troubling to people had been removed from the amendment. I asked what if a small tweak was done to the drug which appeared to be a loophole. Her reply was that “what is a small tweak to us can be a huge cost to the drug company.”
I think that’s the answer – the loophole is there and will go forward apparently. She said it would probably come to a vote possibly this week.
Read lowering of profits and executive bonuses.
and therefore Evergreening.
David Vitter to the left of Eshoo on this issue.
I know you had to read that like ten times Jane before publishing that. Maybe more.
Jane, I have a suggestion. The POP buttons are nice but I think next time we do buttons they should be a little bigger. Folks have to get right up on it to see what it says. Having had to order campaign buttons for 3 congressional campaigns I know they’re not the cheapest thing in the world but visibility counts for a lot.
You should do a Seminal diary on that, Twain.
You mean one that isn’t filled with hate and such? *g*
Give it up, Jane. This is a garbage bill and not even lipstick can give it a better rep.
Now listen up a bit… Obama is doomed if it gets signed and he’s doomed if it does not.
If it does not get passed, everyone’s worst fears will be verified about his abilities and his staff. His mistake was to kick his base in the face, trust bribed politicians to write it, and not to stand for anything…
If it does get passed, it will be the biggest rallying point for single payers who will be fed up. A rallying point for seniors because of the lethal cuts to Medicare. A rallying point for the young who WILL NOT be forced to pay the equivalent of a mortgage for something they don’t want or need. A rallying point for anti-death panels (which are still in there) and a rallying point for people WHO ARE TOTALLY FED UP WITH CORPORATE STEALING BILLIONS.
But please don’t bother defending any part of it. Lets move on. It will be a total car crash. Your best strategy is to realize this and get on with becoming part of the solution. THis bill is not part of the solution.
Not to mention the gouging that has already started and will continue. But let it go, perhaps next time we can put them in jail.
did she even try to offer up any proof it had been removed ?
Jane ,can i send you a package,at the Va post office box?
And what about the next time and the one after that? Do we just walk away? Nope. Not in my nature to do that. We make them fight us every step of the way. Maybe they will be the ones to give up.
Well said and a lot nicer than I was going to be. I’m not feeling kindly toward quitters.
Never. Give. Up.
tell the reps the story of Jonas Saulk,a true American hero,who gave the world the POLIOvaccine to SAVE LIVES….PATENT FREE
HI…Harrys ear on the mend
No, but reading for the 4th time Anna’s writing in the Huff Post, I think what was taken out was the part about “new indication, route of administration, dosage form, etc.”
That’s what I wanna hear!!
thank you. and thanks so much for calling.
that someone I once so highly regarded has become a treacherous shill coldly wreaking havoc on women fighting for their lives has really sent me around the bend. which is a long way of saying I wont be talking to any of her offices anytime soon.
Maybe you should call. Or e-mail. Don’t know any other way to get our point across. I’m way too old to picket her office. Anna, in the past, has been very sensitive to other people’s feelings about her. It upsets her so maybe now would be a good time to upset her.
Signed but I still think the bill should be defeated. Again, where is the outrage about the deals the Obama Admin made? Where is the outrage about the lack of transparency?
There was all kinds of hell raised about Cheney and his secret meetings with energy producers; why hasn’t there been the same sort of response to Obama’s deals?
Signed. And, a note to him/them.
Sometimes we have a hard time paying the rent/mortgage, and food. We need generic drugs. Please, please do this.
I will eventually get around to it – just so spitting angry right now, don’t want to serve as a foil in their That Hamsher woman sent her uncivil flying monkeys to attack us ! bs, that is no doubt coming.
Here’s what I sent to Eshoo’s staffer:
Having an actual email address for a staffer is a big win over the web contact form. Using the web form means no context from previous emails, you can’t even cc your message to yourself. So you get a boilerplate response that doesn’t address your issues, rinse, repeat until frustrated. I’ve complained about it during calls to her office.
With a live person’s email that shouldn’t happen. I’ve had some history on this with Baron Hill (email to staff ignored), Evan Bayh (ignored), Richard Lugar (long term engagement with staff – they read the books I sent and clearly read and digested the information). My hope is Eshoo’s staff will be responsive.
signed and called.
I’m nobody’s flying monkey!
And we can be civil, I think we gain a lot more that way. Leave the anger and rancorous debate to the teabaggers.
Excellent reporting (if I may call it that).
Seriously, if you have time, you should follow Jane’s advice @ 10 and submit a Seminal diary on that call and your insight re the answer.
Seriously, is it ok to refer to bloggers making such inquiries and getting information as “reporting” (which is what I’d call it), or does that upset the journalist types?
I call it reporting. You’re making a report on something.
It’s even journalism, as in making a journal entry. captain’s log, web log, journal entry are semantically equivalent in essence.
signed will call tomorrow.
Ohio is proud proud proud of our dear sincere Senator Sherrod Brown!
“reduce health care cost and expand quality care to all Americans”