When the Senate Finance Committee starts work again on Tuesday things should get heated. Here are some of the more interesting amendments to watch out for.
Free Choice Amendment – Wyden C1 :
What it hopes to do:
It would allow employees who do not like their current employer provided health insurance to ask for a voucher to buy insurance for themselves on the new exchange.
Background:
Wyden’s Free Choice Amendment is very important to the Senator. He has gone so far as to say that it is “a prerequisite to supporting the bill.” The CBO concluded it would have very little effect on overall health insurance and only save $1 billion. Wyden has been selling his amendments to conservatives as a way to increase choice and to liberals as a way to give more people access to the public option. This amendment is a wild card with the possibility of some bipartisan support. The amendment is opposed by the Chamber of Commerce.
What to look for:
Watch to see if any Republicans (especially Snowe) decide to back Wyden’s free choice amendment. Also check out how Baucus and Conrad vote. The amendment may upset the delicate balance of backroom deals and compromises Baucus has tried to achieve.
Applying Regulation To Large Group and Self-Insured Market – Rockefeller C1 :
What it hopes to do:
It would apply all new insurance regulations to the self-insured and large group markets from day one of reform. (i.e. 2013)
Background:
The bill as currently written would exclude insurance provided by large employers from most of the new consumer protection regulations. While big business (i.e. the Chamber of Commerce) is opposed to the amendment, it should be very difficult politically for any Democrats to vote against it. No one wants to be on record voting against protecting everyone from some of the worst insurance practices.
What to look for:
Watch to see if any Democrat besides maybe Baucus votes against the amendment. Also it’s important to see how Snowe votes. If she supports the amendment it will probably make it into the final bill.
Various Public Option Amendments – Schumer, Cantwell, Rockefeller :
What it hopes to do:
Add a public option to Baucus’ bill.
Background:
Senators Rockefeller and Schumer have been the most vocal supporters of the public option on the Senate Finance Committee. Rockefeller is likely to introduce a robust public option tied to Medicare, while Schumer plans to introduce a “level paying field” public option which must negotiate its rates independent from Medicare. Schumer and Rockefeller have been working closely on the issue and have not yet decided on the best political strategy. They may choose to only introduce Schumer’s weaker public option in an attempt to show that the idea of a public option has strong support. They also might introduce two public option amendments hoping to give conservative Democrats the cover of voting against the robust public option while supporting the weaker “compromise.”
What to look for:
First watch to see how many public option amendments are debated. Pay close attention to the CBO scores each public option gets. Baucus’s use of the second lowest cost plan as the benchmark for determining tax credits may prevent the CBO from scoring the public option as saving money. Secondly, pay attention to how conservative Democrats (Baucus, Carper, Lincoln, Conrad, Nelson) vote on Schumer’s “level playing field” public option.
“Safety Net” Trigger Amendment – Snowe C1 :
What it hopes to do:
It would trigger a weak state-based public option if a low standard of affordability is not met in any state at some time in the future.
Background:
The new message from prominent Democrats seems to be that whatever Sen. Snowe wants is a great idea. Despite being a worthless fig leaf, Peter Orszag, Harry Reid, and Bill Clinton have all talked positively about it. The idea of a trigger is opposed by all the other Republicans on the committee along with many liberals who think it is worthless.
What to look for:
It is possible liberals could join with Republicans to kill Snowe’s trigger. Pay attention to how the more progressive Democrats like Schumer, Rockefeller, Stabenow, and Cantwell vote. If they vote for the amendment, it is probably because they got pressure to do so from leadership. Also pay attention to how Baucus votes. A trigger will likely ensure that the final bill won’t get more than 1 to 3 Republican votes in the Senate. If Baucus supports the trigger amendment it is a clear sign he has fully given up on any hope of broad bipartisan support.
If Snowe’s trigger amendment is not brought for a vote in committee it might be a sign that enough liberals on the committee have threatened to vote against it. If it failed in committee, it would be more difficult politically for Reid to insert the idea when he combines the two committee bills.
Eliminating The CO-OPS – Rockefeller C11 :
What it hopes to do:
Remove co-ops from the bill
Background:
Conrad created the idea of the non-profit co-ops instead of a public option in an attempt to find broad compromise. The idea failed miserably. Liberal Democrats and conservative Republicans both attacked the idea. The idea seems to be losing support with even Conrad admitting they should be stronger.
What to look for:
Watch to see which progressive members of the committee vote against the co-op idea. The votes of Republicans Snowe, Grassley, and Enzi should be interesting. All three were part of the Gang of Six that negotiated the co-ops idea. With Grassley and Enzi unlikely to support the bill, it will be interesting to see if they will vote against the co-ops idea they themselves helped create.





65 Comments
Spotlight




Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About FDL Action
Advanced search
Thank you!
This makes it a lot clearer for me now,
and will be a handy guide for tomorrow.
“Getcher programs…. Programs! Can’t tell the players without yer programs!”
Excellent work, Jon, thank you. Will definitely have this handy when the Committee votes tomorrow.
On anotherwise really crappy day, may I say, I am damn proud to be a constituent of North Dakota’s leading senator, Byron Dorgan.
Thanks, Jon. good info. Read today that 12 states are trying to put a law on the books that would keep people from being forced to buy insurance if they don’t want to. Could make for some interesting days ahead.
I must say this is only some of the ones I think will be most interesting. There is a Cantwell “basic plan” for everyone below 200% of FPL and a Rockefeller early Medicare buy in that should always be good to watch for.
Great insight on the players and what to watch for!
Now how can we put some pressure of our own on these guys
EXCELLENT QUESTION!
I keep suggesting placing an ad in one newspaper in several of the districts represented by Blue Dogs whose Democratic constituents appear to be supporting a public option by more than 50%.
If even just a few ads are placed, other media will notice them and give them more air time.
I put up a Seminal diary about this REALLY great news!
Thanks, Prairie
What do they want that we can give or deny them? Who is giving them what they want and how can we ruin their day? Consumer boycotts maybe? Glen Beck is losing advertisers we are showing we got muscles to flex.
I like it i think Blue America is running a few ads already. We need more ideas.
Somewhat OT, but do we know if HR676 is being scored? Is there going to be an up or down vote?
Early Medicare buy in? Splendid idea. I remember thinking this was fantastic about six months ago.
If I could pay the premiums myself AND continue to pay for Medicare outta my taxes, I would.
What would you write in an ad? A general ad is good but if we can tailor make ads for each District by using our local commentor insight I think we can destroy!
Btw, I have heard that the ad to tell Arkansas Sen. Blanche Lincoln and Rep. Mike Ross to stop doing the bidding of the insurance industry by blocking the public health insurance option started running. Is that correct? I’m happy to say that I contributed toward the goal of raising enough money to run it, which appears to have been achieved:
http://www.actblue.com/page/arkansaspublicoption
But, if it’s running, shouldn’t it be getting attention like the ad running in Max Baucus’ state? Here’s an example from today’s news at CNN: “Baucus targeted by liberal groups in new ad.”
http://politicalticker.blogs.c…..in-new-ad/
Any idea on what will happen in House Senate compromise?
Reid’s office is suggesting there won’t be major changes in the Senate bill from here on out. So I would expect all the above amendments to be defeated. If any one of them passes, it would strongly suggest that Reid has lost control of his caucus and the entire bill will fail.
Do you know who makes the final decisions about how to use FDL resources? ActBlue is an arm of FDL, right? Would Jane be the right person to whom I could make such a proposal about newspaper ads? It seems like a good idea because they’d be cheaper (I think) and would still have a punch if other media report about them.
TradMed like CNN are going to great lengths to present these as isolated, single-state occurrences by outside parties, not a great risiing up funded by the American people against recalcitrant Democratic lawmakers everywhere. The White House relationship with the gatekeeper press is very strong; Rahm Emanuel has most of them on speed dial and is said to speak with many of them at least DAILY.
This means that the ads against Democrats (which Rahm called “fucking stupid” about a month ago) have a VERY hard time breaking through the filter, even once. And they are never presented as part of an organic effort; you’ll always see it made to look like a DeeCee-centered effort imposed on the state or district. That people across America are contributing to put these ads on the air is usually a very minor part of the story.
It’s all a part of the WH effort to control the message and manage floor votes without outside pressures the WH cannot control.
Blue America and FDL Action PAC are affiliated with FDL.
Act Blue is an fundraising aggregator open to ALL Democrats; people build their own funding mechanisms within Act Blue, of which Blue America and FDL Action are but two very small efforts.
No Actblue is a very big organization that works as a single clearing house for donations. Think of it like paypal for liberal causes. It just hands the processing.
Talk to Jane act blue is supported by several blogs
Fantastic summary.
Why do I get the feeling that we should be having a march on DC tomorrow to support the Public Option. All we need is about 1000 people that way we could claim a crowd of 370,000
It is truly sad when most of our senators sound like we have annoyed them by interrupting their golf. My senator has a science fiction scenario where all the characters and the facts are fluid. Where there is no limit to creativity and pure fiction. Sadly, he is from Oregon and our senior senator.
Dear Senator; your option is refused. It means nothing to anyone but you and the persons unknown that helped you write it. We need a single payer system that is paid for by taxes because our country’s inaction for all these decades that has allowed the U.S. to become insolvent and non competitive throughout the world. The words you use to confuse everyone about obstruction of this single payer, universal health care that has nothing to do with insurance, or someone having to pay for it out of their own pocket is the insurance company talking and we don’t want to hear that even one more time. Oregonians are over 70% in favor of a public health care mandate. Almost every one of those voters expected you to be the guy to deliver it, not take it away. What is it going to be? Single payer, Medicare for all of us without conditions, or nothing?
I’m hoping you realize that I wasn’t calling You rude in my comment to your diary. You two just use similar metaphors.
If you have an idea lets hear it I’m curious.
Landrieu’s out.
Perhaps, but the following are stories on CNN’s Political Ticker just from the last couple of days alone.
9/28: “Baucus targeted by liberal groups in new ad” (Progressive Change Committee & Democracy for America)
9/25: “Liberals seek to defeat Democratic congressman” (Thanks, Jane!)
9/24: “Maine TV is key front in health care battle” (Health Care for America NOW!)
9/23: “Dem congressman defends pharmacy sale” (FORCED TO DEFEND, THAT IS!)
She’s On…my list!
Isn’t there a song about having a little list?
What a vile POS.
Pardon my Cajun.
Nixon had a list :)
Everyone has a list. I haven’t told my stepgrandchildren that their father is on mine.
Oh dear. It just occurs to me that I should wonder whose list I’m on.
Not happy.
I just left the following comment at that site:
I was thinking more along the these lines
http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0077975/quotes
Landrieu well what could I do to her that God hasn’t already done to her…suggestions:)
I think something can come to me regarding Cooper’s district.
Right now I am ridiculously late and have to run.
Be back later!
Whats to wonder Darth has all our numbers
Gee, if only I were that important.
Catch you later if you have an idea for Cooper’s district if we can pool our individual knowledge on our separate districts I think we can get great dirt and tailor make/micro target messages specific to each district in a way Mark Penn never could.
BWAHAHAHA!
To a paranoid maniac no threat is to small to be ignored
U ‘cusin’ me of being paranoid? *g*
Is this hearing going to be televised anywhere?
No of course not I’m accusin Darth
It will be on CSPAN 2 or 3 and you can watch it online at CSPAN.org
Oh, old news that Darth is paranoid. Has it been inherited by his daughter? (Rhetorical Q)
FDL mentioned on Countdown wrt Cooper primarying.
Tell me more?
No more than what I said. Odonnel is host. Goes on with Howard Dean to a more in-depth discussion.
TX Free Clinic Fair director now on Countdown. Something like 2000 showed up.
2009: 8 million people show up at free medical clinics. Didn’t catch what the earlier figure was, but quite a bit lower.
Gawd. The Free Clinics director is doing a great job of shaming the U.S. medical system.
4 million in 08
new thread
Nicole Lamerueau, or spelling to that effect. We need to get her more national publicity.
Thanks. That’s what I thought I heard, but wasn’t sure.
They have mentioned the Anti Baucus ad on the Ed Show and here but no mention of the FDL ad in Arkansas
Progress in our time. Key Q: is it enough to make a difference?
OMG. Cameroon had an economic development ad on msnbc.
I think it is important to support this reporting. When Rick Sanchez started showing more guts than some of the others, I contacted CNN to let them know that I used to watch MSNBC’s competing news show but had switched over to CNN for Sanchez. There are big viewer wars going on so if CNN can boost its viewers by telling the non-WH sanctioned version of events, maybe they will.
I wanna be a fly on the wall in tomorrow’s oval office meeting on Af.
Good point.
Good report from Landay. Iran missile tests were regularly scheduled. Didn’t know that.
I saw the FDL Arkansas ad played on MSNBC, on the Rachel Maddow show, I think.
Also, just a reminder to those who are thinking “rally” . . . the Mad as Hell Doctors tour will be in D.C. on Wednesday. They’re caravaning from the west coast in favor of single payer, and have made stops (and many friends) all along the way.
Their website is: http://www.madashelldoctorstour.com. They’re also on Facebook, with close to 6,000 “fans.”
Let’s support them!!
Criminally corrupt politicians are the reason the U.S. is ranked near the bottom of every catagory when ranked next to other modern, industrialized nations. Time for publically funded elections.
The Congress is back in session and doing the dirty work for the Medical Industrial Complex.
mcconnell $3.3M, hatch $2.9M, baucus $2.8M, grassley $2.7M,
lieberman $2.6M, burr $2.4M, ensign $2.4M, cornyn $2.2M, kyl $2.1M,
conrad $2.1M, cantor $1.8M, boehner $1.7M, coburn $1.2M, j wilson 800K
were paid by the Medical Industrial Complex to kill Health Care Reform.
(Source: OpenSecrets.org)
Co-Author Dr. Steffie Woolhandler of a Recent Harvard Study on Annual Deaths of America’s Uninsured, says the lack of coverage can be tied to about 45,000 deaths a year in the United States. The only way to affordably cover all Americans is through a Medicare-for-All, Single-Payer System. A Single-Payer System would generate $300-$400 billion in administrative savings annually, enough to cover all of the uninsured, and to plug the gaps in coverage for Americans with only partial coverage. Obviously, Medicare-for-all is anathema to the insurance industry. What politicians are doing is saving insurance industry profits, by sacrificing American lives.
12 Million Americans were denied health care coverage by the Medical Industrial Complex because they had a pre-existing medical condition. 12K Americans are denied insurance coverage everyday by a for-profit Insurance bureaucrat. (Source: WaPo Article 05′ by Harvard Prof. E. Warren)
Medical malpractice lawsuits are a hot topic but, are they? Tort Reform is such a “Red Herring” and is easily disproved. A 2004 report by the Congressional Budget Office said medical malpractice makes up only 2 percent of U.S. health spending. Even “significant reductions” would do little to curb health-care expenses, it concluded.
bush(43) economic speech writer david frum, at least, is willing to admit the idea about selling insurance across state lines is a crock:
New Jersey health policies cost more in large part because New Jersey hospitals and doctors charge more. If I buy a cheaper Kentucky policy that reimburses my providers at Kentucky rates, leaving me to pay the balance, how much good does that do me? And if the Kentucky policy is made to pay New Jersey rates, there vanishes my low Kentucky price.
These are some of the easily refuted arguments bought and paid for by the Medical Industrial Complex to derail any chance of their criminally massive profits being reduced.
Follow the Money: Link
Call Congress and demand, Single-Payer Health Care for All!
(Toll Free # House and Senate)
1-866-338-1015 _____ 1-866-220-0044
1-800-473-6711 _____ 1-866-311-3405
Sign Single-Payer Petition: Link
Don’t let the Medical Industrial Complex steal your Health Care from you and your family by donating huge sums of money to Crooked Politicians in order to maintain the Status Quo. Keep up the good fight.
SEMPER FI!