Even though it was widely known that there would be massive pressure on members of Congress during the August recess, Organizing for America does not seem to have done much in the way of planning for the month. On Sunday, August 9 they finally sent out an email asking supporters to request meetings with their representatives.
The LAT talks about what OFA has done – or hasn’t done — with its 13 million member email list:
The network is powered by local volunteers who often have left-leaning goals. But the president, now that he is in office, has in many cases adopted a centrist approach that accommodates Republicans and business groups.
That means some activists are being asked to devote evenings and weekends to build support for policies they may feel only lukewarm about.
Last year, "Obama’s sexy, he was hot, and everybody wanted a piece of that," said Candice Davies, a speech therapist in Cary who trained canvassers for last year’s campaign and is trying to organize support for healthcare legislation. "Now, people are going to have to work for something that is not quite as slick or sexy."
Officials in charge of the network concede that opponents of the healthcare overhaul have been more organized than Democrats had expected.
What Democrats? Who didn’t see this coming?
Chellie Pingree on July 22 warned everyone from the floor of the House:
If we go home for recess without passing this bill, we will give special interests and their lobbyists five weeks to dump millions of dollars into ad campaigns that spread misinformation and fear and confusion.
I wrote on July 23 when Obama himself urged the House to stay in session until they passed a health care bill:
The lobbyists plan to use the month to hammer House and Senate members with millions and millions of dollars in ads and hire Dick Armey to picket them. We’ve heard over and over again from every single person we spoke with on the Hill on all sides that leaving is a disaster that will only make it harder to fight for a public plan, because well funded freak shows like this will be greeting members of Congress when they’re at home.
And from July 17, writing about Robert Wexler getting picketed by — you guessed it — Freedomworks:
Because of Wexler’s commitment to support a public plan, Dick Armey’s astroturf teabagging organization, Freedomworks, is picketing outside his Boca Raton office on behalf of a Republican who is running against him.
Look, it’s going to get rough out there for members of the House who are committed to holding the line against very well-funded opposition to healthcare reform, and the Dick Armeys are always going to be available to dispatch canned teabaggery to embarrass and smear them for their conviction.
HCAN and OFA, the two organizations that were tasked with conducting the ground battle, were well financed to engage in this battle by foundations, individual donors and every big liberal interest group in town. That they were caught completely off guard is manifest. It didn’t take the Amazing Kreskin to suss out what was going to happen.
But there is an even bigger problem:
Davies, the North Carolina speech therapist, said she attended a recent organizational meeting but left "without any clear script or anything to do."
Organizing for America "hasn’t contacted me with a really clear mission," Davies said. "If they came to my door and said, ‘Here are the 10 things we want you to do,’ then I’d probably do it."
One complication is that activists are being asked to sell an evolving plan; even Obama hasn’t committed to details.
The teabaggers know what they stand for. The White House, in its desire to take credit for whatever passes and call it a "win," has remained deliberately vague. Nobody wants to walk into the right wing meat grinder with a bunch of crazies over an issue as passionate as health care when the only thing they’re rallying around is a bunch of vague platitudes.
There’s only one thing that can fight back against big lobbying money, and that is popular support. The failure of the President and his support organizations to inspire and mobilize those who want to support health care reform well in advance of this moment is short sighted almost beyond belief.





67 Comments
Spotlight




Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About FDL Action
Advanced search
Thank you, Jane, for all you’re doing.
Just goes to show you how far the progressive movement still has to go–from top to bottom: organization, communications, and real Democrats on our side in Washington. The defeat of the GOP in 06 and 08 was not the defeat of the conservative establishment, which is still robust in terms of its network of think-tanks, media, PR, organization and funding. Nonetheless, not preparing well in advance for August and going on the offensive was a huge mistake. Hard to imagine how it happened. I can attest to getting several pre-August HCAN emails which said nothing except inviting me to a health care “event.” No explanation as to what the events were or what I should do if I went. Only today did I finally get an email that focused on organization and action items. What on earth is Soros sending his additional $5 million in for? Seems like money being thrown away.
Obama isn’t providing any leadership, except that he wants to change things. The cynic in me says he’s just trying to piss on the fire hydrant to leave his mark, he doesn’t care what the end result is. Moving the rhetoric from “health care reform” to “health insurance reform” to whatever the next watered-down gobbledegook doesn’t exactly show he has a specific objective driving this.
The lesser cynic in me says his community organizer instincts are undermining his agenda, since he’s working too hard at coming up with a compromise to make everyone happy. Unfortunately for Obama the republicans aren’t rational actors, and community organizing techniques don’t work too well when the opposition has no goal except to stop everything.
Finally, the slight optimist in me thinks maybe, just maybe, the plan was to let the wingers get all their storm and fury out of the way and then get serious about delivering specifics. Sometimes the best way to deal with little children is to let them throw their tantrums until they become tired and powerless, and then provide the firm hand of an adult.
But mostly I’m discouraged by the whole process.
“The failure of the President and his support organizations to inspire and mobilize those who want to support health care reform well in advance of this moment is short sighted almost beyond belief”
Sad it is to be in a position where you hope the reason the people supposedly on your side are doing what they’re is doing merely because they’re stupefyingly short sighted and aren’t pursuing some agenda of their own.
It’s not almost beyond belief. . . it is beyond belief.
It is also not really Obama’s fault. A lot of people in OFA are single-payer supporters and have not worked hard for Obama’s plan for health reform. They supported Clinton’s plan over Obama’s and were still trying to push in that direction after the election. OFA ended up somewhat frozen by inaction b/c of this and the result is a free ride for the deathers. Guess it is easier to organize for no-to-anything than to get people behind a national goal.
No one could have predicted …
if you look at OB’s life story, a mother who died young of cancer and had to fight for coverage on her death bed, you know that he is not giving up on this issue short of a public option.
that the OFA org has been less clear, may be settled tonite in a phone call at 8 eastern with David Axlerod.
register here:
I’ve set up a conference call for Tuesday night, and I’d like to invite you to join us.
What: Health Care Conference Call with
David Axelrod
When: Tuesday, August 11th
8:00 p.m. Eastern Time
http://my.barackobama.com/AxelrodCall
The problem is that the WH and OFA are not aligned. How can I support OFA when Obama seems to slide on the public option, or puts his energy behind Baucus, or caters to the Blue Dogs, or makes secret deals with Pharma?
DFA, Move On, and FDL are going to get my support.
I think our President’s achilles heel is his need for consensus over everything. Health Care Reform should be the cause of his life and he has to realize to make it happen, he’s going to have to tell the Republicans to go Cheney themselves. I am getting ready to watch the Town Hall, see how he handles the hecklers they are predicting. A question I have, as late as last week, my Senator Sherrod Brown was saying to expect the Senate bill to have a strong public option. Is he wishful thinking? He is on the HELP committee, and this seems like it should be the “lead” committee for a health care reform bill. Would appreciate what you think, especially Jane, who IS advocating Health Care Reform like it is the cause of her life. Many thanks to you for what you are doing Jane. You are an American treasure.
The problem is that we haven’t been given anything to work FOR… just a mish-mosh of conflicting, stupid, non-productive hints and feints. If single-payer were truly on the table, I’d spend all day calling and raising hell.
Leadership? I haven’t seen any goddamned leadership from the Dems. Any organizing for THs has been done by local folks. Dems in a “leadership” position in the Village couldn’t lead a pack of hungry wolves to a fresh carcass.
I’m poor and I gave some of my last dollars before getting booted from my job to support Obama. I also traveled to Nevada to work on a voter protection hotline. As soon as he was elected his entire “community organization” fell apart. I question how good of an organizer he ever could have been. Has he been all ego all these years, even though he had a couple of good moment. People talk about how smart he is. If he’s all for preserving his power in order to get his agenda done – he would have planned to have this very good organization continue seamlessly to put people to work on his political agenda. Obviously, his agenda changed COMPLETELY once elected. If he’s so smart, then he knew from BEFORE he won that he needed this. So WHY didn’t he plan for it? If he wanted to be re-elected, he needed to have worked on support for his agenda, most of which was ACTUALLY popular with the PEOPLE – not the corporations. He is appearing to be less intelligent politically and less honorable ethically, and worse, he had the option to take another path. With better planning and better people around him. In addition to risking his own career, he’s putting huge numbers of POOR AMERICANS (working or otherwise) at risk. They supported him, yet he is not supporting the ONE thing that would make a huge difference to poor people. Going bankrupt because of medical bills? Imagine being completely poor, even though you work your butt off. They have ZERO HOPE now for CHANGE because it looks like not only will they not be covered by the government, now they will be REQUIRED to pay for health care. Thanks a lot, Obama, you liar.
I seen this movie before in the early 90s. And it wasn’t Pulp Fiction.
most likely too little and way by far and away TOO LATE!
Applauding! If they were true leaders they would INFORM their constituents regarding the issues. Pathetic bunch.
I get almost daily E-mails asking for me to canvass or man the phones however I don’t know what is being sold. Yes I want at least a strong public option but what impact is Baucus and his band of corporate shills going to have on legislation?
Who did not see it coming? The spineless dem congressional “leadership” for 1. All the dems in congress who seem to think that since they won they will always win for 2. And finally, all the dems who have been in congress for the past 50 years. Actually, since the era of Goldwater and then Nixon, the rethugs havew been out lying the dems. The rethugs got the message a long time ago. Whatever you say, no matter what the lie, the MSM will put it out in public, then other rethugs can repeat it endlessly gaining more public acceptance by the sheeple. The thugs also learned years ago that they could lie like hell and the sheeple are dumb enough to believe it.
The dems are totally tone deaf. The thugs have been doing this kind of krap to the dems over and over and over, yet every damn time the dems are taken by “surprise”. What, the dems have some kind of collective blindness when it comes to rethugs? When the same thing takes you by “surprise” over and over, don’t you think that means there is something basically wrong with the dems collectivly? Esp. since almost every dem who is not on TV or in congress has been yelling from the rooftops about this for months?
HUBRIS is what the dems suffer from, it appears to be terminal and highly contagious.
Reid, Pelosi and all the other dems in congress are brain dead idiots if they did not see this coming. Idiots.
I guess Obama will ride up to the Capitol on his unicorn name Rahm save the day when the time is right.
wow–i am amazed at the level of negativity.
too little, too late?
there is much of august left. I went to my cong office yesterday and pushed the public option and she is a blue dog.
how about you all?
Last year, “Obama’s sexy, he was hot, and everybody wanted a piece of that,” said Candice Davies…… “Now, people are going to have to work for something that is not quite as slick or sexy.”
Oh, WHO among us has not at one time or another bemoaned to him/her self..
“The screwing I got ain’t worth the screwin’ I’m gettin’….” ?
Yes. I’ve been calling. Thing is, why do we have to beg and kick and scrape for the public option? The majority of Americans want a public option. The President says/said he supported a public option. Why do we have to beg? The Democrats need a boot in their ass and I don’t know who is the right person to administer that boot. It should be Obama, but he’s just not a “boot-in-the-ass” guy. You are right, there’s more than half of August left and we should try not to lose heart.
Hello Peterboy:
You must have some clout if you can set up a conference call with David Axelrod–I’m impressed!
The problem is that OB has hired people who are undoing his agenda. When Rahm slaps the progressive base around or cuts deals with Tauzin, he is tampering with O’s credibility. Where is the discipline inside the WH?
OFA’s success mirrors the clarity of messages from the WH. This is axiomatic and no amount of stroking from Axelrod will change anything.
I guess it’s true what they say …. trying to organize Dems is like herding cats.
At least the S.O.Blue Dogs respond to the GOP whistle,and heel on command.
Negativity? Nope, just a little dose of realism. The current dems in the village ARE useless because the rethugs have been doing the same damn thing to the dems over and over for the last 40 years. And every damn time the dems are taken by “surprise”. What, the lessons learned from Kerry in 04 are totally forgotten in 09? Useless! The dem “leadership” is useless. The dems in congress who were “surprised” are freekin useless. Damnit. I want the dems from the 60s and early 70s back. They had spines and were not afraid to investigate a sitting prez. The ones in office now are unprincipled hacks who run scared every time a rethug clears his throat.
First we claim that an overwhelmingly majority support a public option and healthcare reform, then we claim we saw this strong opposition coming?
This doesn’t add up.
Not only that. but it puts a lie to all those that think Obama is playing some kind of 11 dimensional chess and leaving all his detractors shaking their head.
I dont have clout. I have just stayed on the OFA list and done some things and gone to some meetings, when they sent out an email.
So I got this email.
I am making calls this week to Blue Dog constituents.
That I am unemployed gives me the time.
That I am on COBRA with a pre-existing condition makes it personal for me, too.
I agree with timr about being realistic about spineless CONG Dems. But that doesnt mean I am folding the tent on this.
Yes we can.
The problem is that OB has hired people who are undoing his agenda……………….
I can only speculate WHOM is undoing WHOM’S agenda?
Right. Remember when LBJ called Dan Rather at 3am and asked, “Are you trying to f**k me”?
Can you imagine Obama calling Max Baucus two months ago at 3am and asking the same question!
Was it over when the Germans bombed Pearl Harbor?
I have to fight this battle for the public option. I have to win or lose this battle for the public option. The problem is that my insured, employed, otherwise retired people on Medicare, and single payer loving friends don’t feel or think that they have to fight this battle. They are entitled to vote their conscience. But so am I.
Apples and oranges. Ninety percent of the 76% percent who support a public option or single payer don’t show up to meetings and it only takes 3-4 people to disrupt a meeting. Those of us payin’ attention knew what was coming but the leadership ignored the situation. These are people who are used to being fawned upon at these kind of things. Those days are over. Where the town halls have had minimum disruption was due to the local folks organizing the event, taking their cue primarily from online groups not clueless staffers from DC.
That’s because they’re “keeping their powder dry”. Silly Dragon… any similarities to NARAL is purely coincidental.
Yep. Just because the Dems wanna play spineless doesn’t mean I have to. I’m not a Rethug. I toe nobody’s line.
Look, I’m fighting it too. It would help if the wind from the WH were at my back and not in my face. 76% (pre-noise) want this and I don’t see how any dem has the right to go off and line their pockets by freelancing.
Pretty much since election day, Obama has told the progressive community to sit down, shut up, and fuck off. While he’s open to Blue Dog and GOP suggestions on health care, he ruled out listening to progressives’ ideas before the debate even started. We came into November fired up and ready to fight for reform, but now we’re just a bunch of dirty fucking hippies again.
But if we just elect a few more Democrats, everything will magically change!
Keepin’ their power dry, my ass. More like tryin’ to figure out how to keep the big donor bucks comin’ in.
Was it over when the Germans bombed Pearl Harbor?
If they had, it might have been.
BT’s up
Obama’s Town Hall in New Hampshire – Live Video
Jane, I wrote on another thread about the crap e-mail I received from OFA, urging me to visit my senator and “fight” for such worthy and controversial issues as “no gender discrimination” and “extended coverage for young adults.”
NOTHING about single payer, public option, portability, etc.
It really looked like it was written by the WH’s high school summer interns.
The word “action” has been converted into “auction” and they are all looking for the lobbyist who will pay the most to play… led by Mike Ross, and every other Blue Dog. Gotta love’em… give’em a job, and they’ll always find the money (for themselves).
This is the way that the rahmbama team wanted this to play out IMO. The big donors get their way … and keep donating to the dems … but obams still gets portrayed as fighting for the american people’s interests. With the bill likely not going into effect until 2013, the people won’t have the opportunity to see what effect the legislation will have on their lives and experience how the loopholes will be exploited by those corporate interests that are writing them into the bill as we speak. They will also have the advantage of blackmailing the american people to vote for obama in order to get their universal healthcare becoz a republican may take it off of them. Meanwhile, tens of thousands of people will die. The pope of hope is a disgrace.
Z
The Republicans have it easy. What could be simpler than “Just say no.” As for Obama and the Democrats, it is hard to say exactly what they want other than to say it is much less, and much less clear cut, than what most Americans want. I see the American public as more props than players in this debate. No one is asking us what we want. We are just being told what politicians of various stripes want or don’t want. And most of this tracks with what BigPharma, insurance companies, and the medical profession are angling for. So except to protest the dishonesty of the whole process, I don’t see any position to really get behind and support.
Yep, that’s the line of the DCCC, DNC and DSCC [as they shill for more $$$$].
I don’t know about you, but I’m through being Charlie Brown to these guys’ Lucy.
are you aware there is COBRA assistance available through the Stimulus pkg ??
basic info here
what part of this town hall going on now with OB shows that the president is not behind the public option?
i dont see it.
thanks, very muc.
but not for the long-term unemployed such as myself. I was laid off before September 2008.
Call me the vanguard.
Reuters Blogs
July 17th, 2009
Pfizer seen circling top Turkish drug company
Pfizer, the world’s largest pharmaceuticals company, is lining up Turkey’s largest drugs company, Abdi Ibrahim, for a deal, according to an M&A banking source.
There are no talks so far, and what form a potential tie-up would take is not yet known.
Only last month the president of Pfizer’s emerging markets business unit revealed that the drugs company was considering new acquisitions.
“We see opportunities coming from the financial crisis… opportunities to build partnerships in emerging markets,”
am so sorry to hear.
like many here, I consider myself well read but was stunned to find out about this benefit only last month – I am truly at a loss as to why this wasn’t more widely touted
The issue is not about what he says he is for. He said plenty during his campaign that he has reneged on; his eloquent oratoricals mean absolutely nothing. The issue is what he effectuates, what he signs off on.
Everything else is substance-less soundbites and photo-ops.
Z
There should be massive demonstrations.
Who is organizing them?
Where is the progressive organization that is independent of any one politician and any one issue of the moment?
There isn’t one. Not one with nationwide reach and not a coalition with strategic focus.
Until we create one with reach into 192,480 precincts, we will face the same situation of waiting for politicians to pick us instead of us picking politicians.
Of course, the corporate lobbyists out-organized us. They’ve been doing that forever.
Of course, the conservative wingnuts out-organized us on an issue, they’ve had their networks in place for 40 years and have penetrated local centers of authority, like churches and most of all the national media.
Of course the Obama White House missed what was going on. Their focus on winning an election meant that organization was center stage. Now what is center stage is governing. There aren’t the resources devoted to organizing that there were in the campaign. Whoever was supposed to keep OFA going was asleep at the switch. Are we clear who had that assignment in the White House? Or did it fall by the wayside?
Why did we not see this coming and actually do something about it until it was almost too late? Why weren’t we whipping Congress for single-payer from last November? You can bet that the lobbyists on the day after the election started pushing to make single-payer unacceptable. Where were we? We were waiting for Obama.
Too late we realized that “It’s the Congress, stupid.”
Not sure why you’re bringing HCAN into this, Jane. Irrespective of what OFA has or has not done, HCAN has been prepared for this for a while now.
What exactly did you push? Be specific.
People don’t mobilize over a long time. Organizers have been struggling with how to focus the energy.
I know that in our community, the people in OFA are not a cohesive group. They had a lot of different reasons for joining the effort to elect Obama, but they have a diverse set of issues they are individually interested in pursuing. There is no large group of paid organizers now that the election is over.
I think we should set up a national day of mobilizing for health care reform. We should march in the streets all together across the country on one Saturday in September, or whenever.
We have to do this, it will not be done for us. Unless OFA wants to set the time. Someone has to do it who has the communication together to alert massive numbers of people.
Perhaps young people are not as engaged as those of us who have been struggling with health care issues for some time. I did not buy health insurance until I was about 40, I have always been a single person “group”/payer.
I know that OFA organized 400 people to see Sen. Bingaman at his offices this week. That is not bad for 2-3 days of lead time. Now we need to hit the streets.
While that may sound impressive, if it’s a result of the same milquetoast bs I got from OFA, I wouldn’t start clapping.
See my #41 above.
Weak, weak bullshit they’re “lobbying” for. And in my case [re Sen. Inouye], the “organizing” was just getting people to “sign up” that they’d go deliver this pablum of a message. Hardly “pressure” for “change.”
obama would help if he would say no bill unless a pub opt. threaten a veto. will it happne-um no. the pub opt is the only thing dear to liberals in thsi bill. he wont make a stand on it re final terms. this is why grassrots dems i know all over arent doing alot on this. they read what we read.
Is there really still any question that Obama does not support legitimate health care reform and the citizens who are dying for it? Clearly we’ve been sold down the river. Thank you President Obama for betraying your countrymen/women.
There’s no doubt for the people that have an objective mind and open eyes instead of having their heads buried up their party’s ass.
The rahmbama team got their all-important photo-ops and soundbites today with obama “fighting” for the little guy by performing his empathy act in eloquently articulating what is in the minds of the american people … with the flag waving in the background. Meanwhile, behind the scenes they’ve made sure that none of these token efforts that the pope of hope is belatedly making will have any effect on the corporate friendly bill that they will very likely pass. It’s enough to make you throw up.
He’s a disgrace. We probably would have been better off with clinton. We may have gotten better legislation … at least she wouldn’t be kissing the republicans’ asses and we would have very likely gotten a better stimulus package. And the progressives may have begun to the hard work of building the infrastructure necessary to go around the corrupted democratic party becoz we already knew what clinton was about. Instead, they got doped up on hope and we’ve wasted 6 months trying to work with him when he is not on our side at all and we actually have to work against him to gain representation.
Z
I went to the opening OFA for health care reform meeting in my area. Over 80% of the attendees were for single payer (one of the leaders thought closer to over 90%), a very few said they would do anything for Obama, and some were just learning what was being proposed.
Everyone except for the OFA people leading the meeting was over 40, most well over 40.
When people were asked to sign a petition for Obama’s plan, the immediate reaction was to ask what it was; few wanted to sign on to something that was unknown.
Obama and the WH staff have to have known that people were extremely worried that there was no clarity about what Obama really wants to accomplish.
BTW, does it bother any here that Obama continues to say that people don’t have to worry about losing their doctors? If their employers change plans, they may very lose their doctors. Why is Obama saying this? It’s not realistic and undercuts other things he says. I cringe when I hear him say it.
Did George Bush turn and run for cover when Iraq attacked us on 9/11? Heh.
Speaking from what I have seen in Louisiana, the problem with OFA is that it views itself as “the President’s organization,” which is completely different from the more grassroots, bottom-up approach that characterized the 2008 campaign.
The focus is on the president instead of listening to people.
OFA’s operation in Louisiana has violated the first rule of democratic politics — “all politics is local” — and refused to put healthcare in the context of what it means to people here. They a set of marching orders that they are following, regardless of whether ordered tasks work or not.
They have been trying to recruit 2008 workers to phone bank and door-to-door canvass while leaving the public space open to the deluge of distortion.
This in the face of evidence that there is a significant segment of the population here (Yes! Here!) that is still open to suasion by facts on this issue.
OFA is not the 2008 campaign in a lot of ways, most disappointingly in its tone-deaf approach to the local political environment and how their core issue can play here.
65% [give or take] of the population supports single payer. 60% of doctors support single payer. many ofa members want single payer [and said so in the ofa house parties last december], or at least a public option that is explicitly set up to morph into single payer in their lifetimes.
the short-sightedness on the administration’s part, if they wanted public support, was in deciding to go with forcing us to buy an expensive product we don’t like from companies that we hate.
I guess Obama will ride up to the Capitol on his unicorn name Rahm save the day when the time is right.
An oil painting of Barack Obama riding up to the Capitol on his unicorn named Rahm to save the day when the time is right-
http://www.faithmouse.com/obam…..nicorn.jpg
Thank you.
My friend in Ithaca emailed me this morning to report that after registering with Organizing for America to go to Rep. Maurice Hinchey’s office at 9:00 a.m. yesterday, she and her neighbor arrived there to find the office closed. Great.
We all know President Obama isn’t stupid, so we have to wonder if (a) he really wants serious healthcare reform, or — as with so much else in his evolved agenda — (b) he prefers something George Bush would like. I’m beginning to think (b) unless the President is so smart he just knows these wingers are going to whirl around till they melt in a pile of butter, & he can march down Pennsylvania Avenue carrying a healthcare bill titled “Everything I Want,” & shove it down the throats of open-mouthed Blue Dogs & the kings of the Party of No.
The Constant Weader at http://www.RealityChex.com