Ellen E. reports from the Kathy Castor event in Florida that turned ugly:
The best sign I saw was held by an elderly gentleman. It read "If I had Obama’s healthcare, I’d be dead by now". Do these people even know what Medicare is or are they just beyond facts and reason? Sorry I could not report more. Castor should have planned better the crowd was huge, and I think think that our side made a good showing.
Eric G. reports that Eric Massa would vote against H.R. 3200 in its current form:
Wide range of ages, about evenly split male/female and pro/anti-reform. Many of the anti’s were affiliated with WeSurroundRochester, which apparently is the local chapter of a Glenn Beck inspired group. These were the least civil participants.
I’d say about 40% were friendly and 60% unfriendly. Friendly questioners were often shouted down with "Ask a question!", while unfriendlies often gave little speeches or asked gotcha questions based on some strange interpretations of the bill, or reality. Massa did a fairly good job of answering, under what must have been fairly intimidating conditions.
He is not a fan of HR3200 and said that he would vote against it in its current form. He is particularly unhappy with the "savings" being taken out of Medicare.
The atmosphere was tense, but in no way was the meeting shut down. It definitely helped that as many pro-reformers showed up as did.
Mary Beth O. was at the Donna Edwards event:
Clearly there were teabagger plants there with scripts, including: a lobbyist type waiting in the front row, a PA from Suburban Hospital (MoCo), some AMA type who showed up with a prop of stacked paper wrapped in red ribbon. Fox loved that last guy. All of the plants got TV interviews.
Of course the did.
Thanks to everybody who reported back about what happened at the events they attended. You can sign up for events here, and report back here.



8 Comments








Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About FDL Action
Why won’t the ‘critters who want rural Medicare rates kept high or raised admit that this makes the health care bill MORE expensive? They act like they are all about the fiscal austerity until it comes to rationalizing Medicare in their area, and then it’s hands-off.
Massa is a great disappointment so far, but I am glad to hear he held his own at the meeting today.
I hope the caucus leadership is providing some guidance to these congresscritters; I predict there will be real violence soon, and they’d better be prepared for how to handle it.
Limbaugh promoted town hall hours before disruption
by Jed Lewison
Thu Aug 06, 2009 at 07:46:05 PM PDT
Hours after Rush Limbaugh boosted the prominence of Democratic Rep. Kathy Castor’s health care town hall in Tampa, Florida, angry protesters drowned out discussion, their chants of “tyranny, tyranny” forcing Castor to cancel the meeting early, before having a chance to hear and address concerns from her constituents.
You can see video of the teabaggers drowning out discussion at the townhall starting about two minutes into this video clip.
Teddy, I think your unhappiness is more than a little misdirected.
Massa’s is a supporter of HR676, he’s not a Blue Dog, and he’s not objecting to HR3200 based
on bogus fiscal discipline arguments.
It’s clear that reform needs more support from the elderly – just look at the polls. Anything that makes them think that Medicare will suffer is doomed.
By the way, this meeting was in the most liberal, affluent part of Massa’s district.
I hate to think how the events down in the Southern Tier (along the PA border) will play out.
Pearlstein is calling the Republicans “political terrorists”. I think I have to agree with him on this and his points are very well thoughtout. Too bad the opposition is illerate.
Dingall townhalls diary at DKos Excellent reading.
These townhalls are obviously an irrelevant distraction. It pits right vs. left in a way that the media LOVES to cover. But we don’t need a single republican vote to pass this. We all know that.
How about a single report on the difference between a co-op and public option in the media? I have no idea what the fck a co-op is and very little idea of what a public option is. If theres a co-op vs public option arc, maybe people will start to see the huge compromises that are being made at their expense.
Jane/all been thinking that Senator Voinovich (R-Oh) should be focused on. Voted for the Clunker funding, for Sotomayor.
Remember watching Voinovich during the John Bolton hearings. Voinovich seemed genuinely concerned about the direction of our country and the nomination of John Bolton to the U.N.
Wondering if we can get to Voinovich’s compassionate side having to do with Health Care for All.
I will be calling his local offices today. Will let you know how it goes
Voinovich’s local Ohio offices
http://voinovich.senate.gov/pu…..eLocations
Jane/all Just called the district office of Senator Voinovich in Nelsonville Ohio (740-441-6410) Ohio for his schedule in August. Katie at the office did not have much information and let me know that South East Ohio does not have a district Rep at this time. She could not tell me anything about Voinovich’s schedule for August and recommended that I call the Washington office (202-224-3353)
Called the D.C. office and Joe was not very friendly (let me know they have been getting these calls). I let him know that I was a member of group of folks here in Athens who are all respectful single payer advocates and had no plans to interrupt any town hall events or any other events that Senator Voinvovich would be holding. That what we were interested in were thoughtful, respectful dialogue. Joe said that there are no town hall meetings on Voinovich’s schedule. I asked what Voinovich’s stance was on Health Care Reform? These are Joe’s exact words “he opposes both single payer and the public option” I then asked what does he support. Joe answered “the Senator supports increasing competition and lowering cost”
I asked “how does he suggest that happen” Joe “the public should be able to go over state lines to access health care plans”
I then called the Cleveland office (216-522-7095. Spoke with Lucy (she also said that they have been receiving lots of calls) She suggested I talk with our district Rep I let her know that there was no Voinovich district rep in s.e. ohio. She put me through to John who was the most helpful person I spoke with. Let him know we wanted to get with Voinovich directly
Set up a meeting with Voinovich during the recess. Here is Voinovich’s direct scheduler.
Beth Martins
Fax 216-522-7097
email bethmartins@voinovich.senate.gov
Now here is the best part of these calls. When I asked John (who was the most helpful and well informed)what Senator Voinovich’s stance was on health care reform. He said that Voinovich had “concern” about single payer and the public option. When I let John know that Joe in the D.C. office had said that the Senator “opposed” both single payer and the public option. John repeated that the Senator had “concerns”
John and I had a short conversation about the distance between “oppose” and “concerns” He agreed.
I hope folks in Ohio contact Voinovich and slip through the crack between “oppose” and ‘concerns”. Sounds like we can work on Voinovich. Touch his what I believe to be truly compassionate bone in his body.
If folks are interested in any events that he may attend in Ohio during the month of August you need to either contact the district office regularly and they sometimes post his calender under press releases