Gabrielle Giffords, a Blue Dog Democrat, wrote an editorial in the Arizona Daily Star, about the need for health care reform that includes a strong public option that lowers everybody’s costs and competes with private insurers. Here’s an excerpt from her editorial about the public option:

We need reform that puts patients first. It is not right and not fair that insurance companies can deny coverage because of pre- existing conditions or impose lifetime limits on service.
I support reform that allows Americans to keep their current health-care program, keep their doctors and keep their hospitals.I support reform that creates competition through a strong public option that lowers everyone’s costs and competes with private insurers.I support reform that allows Arizonans who lose their jobs to afford insurance so they can get back on their feet without fear of getting sick.
I support reform that will slow the growth of health-care costs and does not impose new taxes or burdens on our nation’s most valuable economic contributors, small businesses.
Here’s how the House health care bill will help Rep. Giffords’ constituents in her Arizona district:
America’s Affordable Health Choices Act would provide significant benefits in the 8th Congressional District of Arizona: up to 13,400 small businesses could receive tax credits to provide coverage to their employees; 12,400 seniors would avoid the donut hole in Medicare Part D; 950 families could escape bankruptcy each year due to unaffordable health care costs; health care providers would receive payment for $69 million in uncompensated care each year; and 52,000 uninsured individuals would gain access to high-quality, affordable health insurance. Congressman Gabrielle Giffords represents the district.
This is why I know that if the House Tri-Committee health care bill gets onto the floor with the public option, the national insurance exchange, and the subsidies for the middle class intact, that we have the votes to pass health care reform because the Blue Dog Democrats aren’t united as a caucus against the public option.
Right now, the seven Blue Dogs on the Energy and Commerce Committee don’t share Rep. Giffords’ opinion on having a public option that lowers everybody’s costs and competes with private insurers. The seven Blue Dogs want no subsidies for middle-class families, only for the lower class families, prefer state-based co-operatives, and would love to have the public option as a fallback. The only reason that health care reform on the House side is bottled up is because of the seven Blue Dogs on the Energy and Commerce Committee.
We’ll see if the seven Blue Dogs accept Chairman Waxman’s suggestion about an Independent MedPAC authority as a compromise in order to support the passage of the bill out of the committee and onto the House floor. I’ll be on the alert for any scheduled mark-ups in the Energy and Commerce Committee this week so we can do liveblogging here at the Campaign Silo.
Also, Chairman Waxman has proved to be rather helpful by publishing a district-by-district summary of how the House health care bill will benefit the constituents in the districts of these lawmakers on the Energy and Commerce Committee, including the constituents of the seven Blue Dogs. Please feel free to check out the district-by-district summary for these seven Blue Dogs below:
Shameful, isn’t it? Want to help keep up the pressure on the Blue Dog Democrats, the Congressional Progressive Caucus, and the Tri-Caucus members to do the right thing for us Americans by working to pass health care reform this week that includes a strong public option within a national insurance exchange and offers subsidies to the middle-class along with stringent regulations on private insurers? Then please help donate to our campaign in this fight for health care reform. We’re going to raise up to $32, 274 to continue this fight with more resources and get more people involved in this once-in-a-lifetime fight.





30 Comments
Spotlight




Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About FDL Action
Advanced search
Thanks slinker!
You’re welcome!
That’s the way to lay it out for everyone!
We should talk more about the tax credits available to small businesses who decide to insure their workers. One example from the OEA report from the WH was a 50% payout against the premiums the business paid for. So for example a 32000 group plan would cost the business 16000. I noticed today that the NBC, CBS, CNN, ABC articles did not say anything positive or even mention the tax credits.
Also I saw reporters using 8% loosely as a penalty to small businesses who don’t insure. It’s different than that. They measure by payroll. If your total payroll amount is 400K or greater that is when the 8% penalty would kick in. Penalties start at payroll of 250K but only as 2% which increases as payroll increases toward 400K. My point is that this is non punitive. It is commensurate to what it would cost to insure your employees. I need to be more exact when I am talking to others about mandates and subsidies. What is helpful to me is when I get more information about the House bill. People I meet are scared that this is just another rip off.
Well hey! maybe my letters had some effect. Would be nice to think so.
What makes their seats on Waxman’s committee sacrosanct? Can he or Pelosi pull them off the committee? That happens in Sacramento all the time. These losers need to understand that if they are going to act like Republicans, they are going to have to line up with Republicans to get a committee seat, and that Democrats will be appointed in their stead.
Seriously, it’s time for some hardball, and not the Chris Matthews kind, the Henry Waxman kind! Either eject these losers from your Committee, Mr Chairman, or bypass your Committee altogether.
Great post, slink.
Really helpful, thanks.
Great comment Teddy, as always.
The Blue Dogs are defecting if we keep up the pressure how many more do we think we can get? Was there any indication before this that she was going to change her mind?
Keep up with the letters! :-)
Great Idea – and does Waxman have to remove them or can Nancy? I’m tired of these strutting blue dogs. Ross acts like a child who has just won the first grade election – this is all about him and nothing else.
I have let Gabby know several times that I am not happy to have a Blue Dog representing me. I gave her poor aide a real earful this past week on my feelings about the Blue Dogs on the Energy & Commerce Committee.
For those that are represented by Blue Dogs – give them Hell when they deserve it. I have also given her several atta girls when I thought she had done a good thing.
hiya npb!
AND THE KILLIN’ GOEZ ON AND ON AND…
Citizen slinkerewink and the Firepup Freedom Fighters:
It has been my opinion all along that there is enough progressive power in the House of Representatives to get a real public option written into the healthcare bill and forwarded on to the Senate and from a purely political view, it is necessary to get it out before the August recess so that even if corporate money can stall it in the Senate, it will sail through a supplemental budget and set the stage for a 2010 election sweep for progressive Democrats in both the House and Senate.
The real question is just how much anti-abortion violence we will experience and how much unrest will come out of the police and fire departments of our major cities that will be designed to delegitimize the entire undertaking. The corporate fascists will not lose this battle without using the forces of political terror they have carefully cultivated and put in place over the last 28 years.
KEEP THE FAITH AND PASS THE AMMUNITION, THE WAR IS NOW IN OUR LIVINGROOMS!!
I’m not positive, but I believe the idea of the House bill is that an individual shouldn’t have to pay more than X% of their income for health care insurance and that in today’s market it’s more expensive than that, so they need a subsidy (paid for hopefully by the Rich who received tax cuts under Bush).
The debate about how far above the poverty level they should go to give such a subsidy has largely centered on two things: ensuring that practically everyone can get insurance and yet not breaking the budget.
I think it’s a healthy debate and I think it’s good for such a large program to be discussed by the public and their representatives over the August break.
If the public still isn’t on board, then Democrats shouldn’t force this on them. I think the public knows the current system is a disaster for some people and for the nation and so I don’t worry that they will send a clear message that this should get done.
The electorate voted for Obama and this was a very big part of his agenda. Now it’s time to do it.
Glad to see Representative Giffords joining Representative Sanchez, another Blue Dog, in coming out in full-throated support of the public option. Now if only they’d take The Pledge, they could shame some more of the Progressive Caucus into doing the same!
What
PW said!!
Hey Teddy have you posted the Pictures yet??
How about an amendment which would deny employers an income tax deduction for the cost of providing health insurance as an employee benefit if the provider pays physicians on a fee for service basis. I merely suggest that so long as we are going to have private health insurance providers they must have a critically important incentive to change the physician payment structure or, I submit, the public option alone will be to insubstantial to control these costs while simultaneously improving patient outcomes.
I’m not an economist unfortunately, but I fail to see how this would be bad policy and I think it could be a very good policy with some further study.
Photos are here.
I’ll add them to the Late Night comment thread too.
Great Teddy!! Sure was a great time yesterday!! Now we can’t wait till the GREAT BBQ Cook off in October!!
Simply amazed….. Tax credits and incentives for business to insure worker? Leverage for the business owners? Just make the employee, part time…..
Again why not revoke the tax exempt status of corporation in healthcare, they are not public charities folks, they are businesses. Use tax incentives as a mechanism to control the ever rising cost of healthcare within a service industry insulated from change using tax incentives, by virtue of tax exempt status.
What a notion……..mandated healthcare use the tax code to penalize citizens who cannot afford to purchase health insurance from a tax exempt corporation like Blue Cross Blue Shield or Kaiser or the plethora of tax exempt public charities?????? THE GRAND ILLUSION!
Like Massachusetts……. the new “life tax” with no mechanism to control inflation within healthcare? CORPORATE SERVITUDE UNDER THE COLOR OF LAW!
When will the astute people on this site….. “GET IT!”
http://nccsdataweb.urban.org/P…..search.php
Check out the “tax status” of your
hell insurerpublic charity? This is a joke!!!Folks…. take the time to research the tax structure within healthcare??
Anyone with half a brain seeing the degree to which healthcare is subsidized by the taxpayers, by virtue of corporate tax exempt status will realize America has subsidized healthcare for decades……………………….
We are being fucked hard here in America, and the systemic abuse of the American as taxpayer continues. Perceptions have little to do with reality.
We are at a civil crisis in this country!! Protect corporations at the expense of American lives for profit! The same fuckhead mentality utilized in the Dred Scott case which led to civil war……….
Protect the economic interests of a slave owner society / Protect the business interests of corporate healthcare and render subservient to corporate identity the life and liberty of individuals………..
Is this not what SJC did in Dred Scott!!! Protect the slave owner’s interests in the South……………..
Life Liberty slavery and corporate servitude! GO to hell corporate American slime!!!!!!!!!!!!
Just a few Public Charities in health care in Arizona!!! Banner Health care’s 990 tax return for 2007! A tax exempt corporation considered a public charity!!!
12 Total revenue Add lines le, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6c, 7, 8d, 9c, 10c, and 11 . . . . . . . 12) 3,239,739,982
2008 – Ajo Community Health Center (860871311)
2007 – Amalgamated Retiree Health and Welfare Trust (860353695)
2007 – American Health Legal Foundation (362991388)
2006 – Arizona Adolescent Health Coalition (860854346)
2008 – Arizona Association and Health Underwriters (860687107)
2004 – Arizona Association of Adult Day Health Care (860540600)
2004 – Arizona Association of Adult Day Health Care (860540600)
2008 – Arizona Association of Community Health (860494702)
2007 – Arizona Behavioral Health Corporation (860888064)
2007 – Arizona Bricklayers Health and Welfare Trust Fund (866052292)
2007 – Arizona Foundation for Behavioral Health (860926611)
2007 – Arizona Health Care Association (860227208)
2007 – Arizona Health Care Foundation (311628106)
2007 – Arizona Health Information Management Association Azhima (860341667)
2007 – Arizona Health Information Network Incorporated Azhin (860746437)
2008 – Arizona Institute for Breast Health Inc (860940150)
2004 – Arizona Laborers Teamsters and Cement Masons Health Welfare Trust Fund (237347729)
2008 – Arizona Mexico Border Health Foundation (860536693)
2008 – Arizona Public Health Association (510198821)
2007 – Arizona School Based Health Care Council (869908047)
2007 – Arizona Valle Del Sol Association of Occupational Health Nurses (860589899)
2007 – Arizonans for Access To Health Care (201339809)
2007 – Arnold Keogh Health Foundation (200251176)
2008 – Atwood Health Foundation (860975231)
2007 – Banner Health (450233470)
2002 – Banner Health Arizona (860957500)
2007 – Banner Health Foundation (942545356)
2007 – Banner Health System Group Return (900054273)
2007 – Behavioral Health Coalition of Southern Arizona Inc (860858075)
2008 – Behavioral Health Consumers in Action in Dba North Phoenix Visions of Hope Center (860981209)
2002 – Belle Fourche Health Care Center (460428064)
2007 – Birth and Womens Health Center Inc (860839469)
2008 – Canyonlands Community Health Care (860350153)
2007 – Capstone Health Plan Inc (860444142)
2007 – Carondelet Health Network (860455920)
2002 – Catalina Family Health Services Inc (860362118)
2007 – Cathedral Health Services (861023074)
2007 – Childhood Diabetes Research Institute Diabetes Health and Research Ins (860963786)
2008 – Chiricahua Community Health Centers Inc (860814898)
2004 – CO Sales Health Benefit Trust (860838385)
2008 – Cochise Health Network (010569967)
2007 – Codac Behavioral Health Services of (237086112)
2008 – Community Behavioral Health Services Inc (860473221)
2002 – Comn Hosp Home Health Agency (500147308)
2008 – Compass Health Care Inc Dba Compass Behavioral Health Careinc (953280475)
2008 – Concerned Citizens for Community Health (953416943)
2007 – Copper Basin Community Health Care Foundation (860684167)
2006 – Copper Basin Community Health Care Foundation (860942342)
2007 – Covenant Health Network (364133330)
2002 – David M Dorsett Health Care Facility (460428063)
2008 – Dna Peoples Legal Services Inc Health Plan Trust (311491785)
2008 – Eastern Arizona Area Health (200218600)
2005 – Eden Center Adult Day Health Services Inc (860976629)
2007 – El Pueblo Health Center Inc (860276135)
2007 – El Rio Santa Cruz Neighborhood Health (860285857)
2002 – Eureka Health Care Center (460428057)
2007 – Flagstaff International Health and Education Fund (203407099)
2006 – Foundation for Health Research and Prevention (860371322)
2006 – Foundation for Health Research and Prevention (860371322)
2008 – Gila Bend Health and Emergency Medical Services Inc (237444690)
2008 – Greater Phoenix Association of Health Underwriters (860536747)
2007 – Havasu Community Health Foundation (201839858)
2007 – Health Care Trust of Sundt Corp (866139042)
2008 – Health Evaluation and Longevity Planning Foundation H E L P (860309342)
2007 – Health Industry Business Communications Council (363313052)
2008 – Health Is Wealth Foundation Inc (522165034)
2007 – Health Restoration International Ltd (870701647)
2008 – Health World of Scottsdale Ltd (860870332)
2002 – Hillcrest Medical Clinic Banner Health (450437171)
2007 – Hope Community Health Center (201526381)
2007 – Infant Toddler Mental Health Coalition of Arizona (860981892)
2005 – Inst for Behavioral Health Inc (203682234)
2005 – Institute for Health Professions Education Inc (860658005)
2007 – Institute for Mental Health Research (861030444)
2008 – Institute for Safety and Health Manageme (352202914)
2002 – Inter Tribal Health Care Center (860292175)
2007 – International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers 0769 Health and Welfar (866056282)
2007 – International Health Partners Us Inc (204108237)
2007 – John C Lincoln Health Foundation (953320185)
2007 – John C Lincoln Health Network (860117301)
2007 – Laborers and Operating Engineers Utility Agreement Health and (860576428)
2005 – Laborers International Union of North America Liuna Indian Health Serv (753069021)
2007 – Las Fuentes Health Clinic of Guadalupe Inc (860830225)
2008 – Little Colorado Behavioral Health Center Inc (860250938)
2007 – Liuna Indian Health Svc NC (870758894)
2007 – Marana Health Center Foundation Inc (202990000)
2008 – Marana Health Center Inc (866053462)
2007 – Maricopa Health System Outreach Trng Research and Patient Welfare FO M (860777567)
2008 – Mariposa Community Health Center Inc (860524321)
2006 – Medicine Tree Natural Health Resource (562518697)
2005 – Mental Health Advocates Coalition of Arizona Inc (953424503)
2008 – Mental Health Association of Arizona (860129976)
2007 – Mental Health Guild Inc (860412022)
2008 – Mental Health Resources Inc (860277999)
2002 – Mersco Medical Rapid City Banner Health (450448250)
2002 – Mersco Medical Spearfish Banner Health (450448249)
2007 – Mogollon Health Alliance Inc (860147128)
2008 – Mohave Mental Health Clinic Inc (860214457)
2007 – Mountain Park Health Center (860498020)
2008 – Mountain Park Health Center Foundation (205241918)
2007 – Nanas Children Mental Health Foundation (861001583)
2007 – Native American Community Health Center Inc (942540194)
2008 – Navajo Family Health Resource Network (860286934)
2007 – Navajo Health Foundation Sage Memorial Hospital Inc Sage Memorial Hosp (237314364)
2006 – New Beginnings Health and Fitness Ministries Inc (050584011)
2008 – New Mexico Upcw Unions and Employers Health and Welfare Trust Fund (656012357)
2002 – Northern Arizona Family Health Plan Inc (942850210)
2007 – Northern Arizona Regional Behavioral Health Authority Inc (866037149)
2008 – Nutrition and Health Education Resources (860583430)
2007 – Operating Engineers 428 Health and Welfare Trust Fund Local Board of T (866025730)
2008 – Pantano Behavioral Health Services Inc (861027534)
2008 – Psa Behavioral Health Agency (860220306)
2007 – Regional Center for Border Health Inc (860561847)
2008 – Rio Salado Behavioral Health Systems Inc (860717396)
2008 – Rural Arizona Group Health Trust (721525749)
2007 – Sage Foundation for Health (861026436)
2003 – Salud Para Todos Health for All (860801477)
2007 – Scottsdale Memorial Health Services Company (942735859)
2007 – Sierra Vista Regional Health Center Inc (860186064)
2007 – Southeast Arizona Area Health Education Center Inc (860520996)
2007 – Southeastern Arizona Behavioral Health Services Inc (860325741)
2007 – Southern Arizona Association of Health Underwriters (900221772)
2008 – Southern Arizona Mental Health Corporation (860806975)
2008 – Southwest Behavioral Health Services Inc (860290033)
2007 – Southwest Catholic Health Network Corporation Mercy Care Plan (860527381)
2007 – Southwest College of Naturopathic Medicine and Health Science Inc (860702049)
2007 – Southwest Health Professions Education Center Inc (860767024)
2005 – Southwest Preventive Health Fdn (743095396)
2005 – Southwest Preventive Health Fdn (743095396)
2008 – St Lukes Health Initiatives (860097240)
2002 – Sturgis Community Health Care Ctr (460428062)
2002 – Sturgis Health Care Center Ltc (460445589)
2007 – Sun Health Corporation (942745413)
2007 – Sun Health Foundation Inc Dibia Boswell Hospital Foundation (237107959)
2007 – Sun Health Properties Inc (942745411)
2007 – Sun Health Properties Leasing (860796948)
2007 – Sun Health Research Institute (860768795)
2008 – Sun Life Family Health Center Inc (860296211)
2007 – Sunset Community Health Center (860893305)
2007 – Superstition Mountain Mental Health Inc Smmhc Inc (860554593)
2007 – Touchstone Behavioral Health (860223116)
2008 – Town of Cottonwood Employee Health Benefit Trust Fund (866149544)
2008 – Triple R Behavioral Health Inc (860318272)
2007 – Tuba City Regional Health Care Corporation (043651340)
2007 – Tubac Health Care Foundation (860531821)
2008 – United Community Health Center Inc (942905416)
2007 – United Food Cw and Employers AZ Health and Welfare Trust (237244353)
2003 – University Physicians Health Maintenance Organization (860541442)
2002 – Villa Maria Health Care (450322127)
2004 – Villagelink Home Health Care Services Inc (860739096)
2007 – Winslow Indian Health Care Center Inc (810549382)
???????????????????????
Blue dogs should protect American families and the individuals which comprise our families. Blue Dogs should not be protecting corporations which use the color of law to extract liberty from of Americans!
Life Liberty and corporate dictates. GO TO HELL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
I wouldn’t read too much into this. Gabby Giffords’ 8th Congressional District has a large impoverished Hispanic constituacy, so I can understand her support for a public option. She replaced the well-liked moderate Jim Kolbe in her district when he retired, and on most issues she is quite conservative. Tucson is not exactly a bastion of progressive thought, although I don’t think she has much to worry about next election.
Wow – just looked at the fact sheet for my district. 3,400 people would have to pay a surtax, 126,000 are uninsured. My congressman, Allen Boyd, is against the house bill and against a public option. Guess we know who he represents.
Real simple answer to this is that most employers don’t have a choice in how an insurance company pays for service. In fact, most employers don’t have much choice about what insurance company they can use. Not a whole lot of competition in my area.