So much of DC politicking over the last few years has been centered around the idea that if Democrats actually act like Democrats, they’ll lose their seats "just like they did in 1994". Guess what? It’s not 1994, chronologically, culturally or demographically.
For one thing, Republican favorability stinks right now. Democratic fave ratings may be dropping slightly — which one would expect to see after the post-election highs — but Republicans are breaking through the floor. This after two solid years of demonizing Democrats and especially Barack Obama. Result? He’s now President Obama. Smooth move, guys.
For another thing, guess where the favorability ratings for Republicans are dropping the hardest? That’s right, among non-whites, most especially Latinos.
Remember when Latinos were going to be the new Republican base? The GOP was banging the culture-war drum and the anti-choice drum to woo Hispanics and other Latinos. But that plan ran up against the GOP’s longstanding Prime Directive, otherwise known as "the Southern Strategy". You know, the one where tax cuts for Big Business and the rich are justified by saying "you don’t want that money going to colored people, do you? ‘Cuz that’s who the government’s spending it on!"
The Southern Strategy is an old, old Prime Directive. It’s not only how the GOP ditched its "Party of Lincoln" heritage to win over the South in the late 1960s and 1970s, it’s also how they’re won the White House for most of the past four decades. Read Reagan campaign strategist Lee Atwater’s 1981 comments on saying "taxes" as a code word (or "abstraction") for "nigg-r" and justifying cutting taxes with the idea that doing so hurts blacks (and Latinos) far worse than whites.
The GOP’s loss of Hispanics can be encapsulated in the political career of Loretta Sanchez. She began her political career as a moderate Republican, but couldn’t get anywhere as one, so she switched parties to take on the ineffably wacky"B-1 Bob" Dornan in 1996 — and beat him. (He took the loss so hard he had to almost literally be hauled out of his Capitol Hill office.) She’s part of the Republican-emulating, corporate-worshiping Blue Dog Coalition, but has been differing with the BD’s leadership on key issues, most notably on health care reform — where she supports a strong public option and they don’t.
Playing to (and worse, coddling and encouraging) the racism of whites, especially Southern whites, for the past three generations has now locked the Republicans in a Hobson’s Choice: They can either appeal to a rabid hardcore white base, or they can try to woo non-white voters, but they cannot do both. They just can’t.
One of the more amusing reads I’ve had lately is Republican strategist Bill Greener’s Salon piece. In it, he laments that a) white non-Hispanics have dropped from 90% of voters in 1976 to only 75% in 2008, and b) non-white voters in general hate Republicans more than ever — but fails to mention the GOP’s role in making non-whites hate the GOP, and why the GOP’s wedding of low taxes to race hatred make it impossible for them to be more inclusive of people who aren’t white. (Worse yet, the GOP’s movers and shakers have been steeped in their own foul Southern-Strategy brew for so long that they can’t help but be racists themselves, as they keep proving over and over again.)
Sow the corporate-racist wind, reap the electoral-defeat whirlwind. Blue Dogs, take note, lest you wind up like the Republicans. Loretta Sanchez has noticed — it’s about time your leadership does, too.





38 Comments
Spotlight




Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About FDL Action
Advanced search
I wish the non-Blue Dog Democrats would call Animal Control and get ‘em impounded. I sick of their blackmailing good legislation under the guise of fiscal responsibility when all they are doing is serving their corporate masters and gorging on pork barrel projects.
PW, bearer of good news! Is the Bill Greener piece entertaining enough to bother reading, or shall I skip it since you’ve done it for me?
Interesting about Loretta Sanchez – I didn’t realize she had been a Republican. That explains a lot – I’ve found many of her stands disappointing, but am really glad to hear she supports a public option.
Now, what can we do to the other Blue Dogs? I’m more and more convinced they’re just, like your description of Sanchez’s background – Republicans who would’ve fit when Nelson Rockefeller was around, but have nowhere to go now that the crazies rule the party.
I get really irritated when I hear “news”folks ask Dems, “well, you have sixty votes, why can’t you pass XX easily?” because I don’t think we really have 60 Democrats. the blue dogs just don’t belong in the count.
Follow the Money… Link
Call Congress and demand,
SINGLE-PAYER HEALTH CARE FOR ALL NOW!
SEMPER FI!
Coming down the pike…will they make their decision based on what the Insurance companies demand or what the American people need?
I was really impressed with several things that President Obama was willing to say about Insurance companies and our health care system.
“Take the profit margin out”
I could just see insurance company executives head doing 360’s in response to that statement by the President.
The other one
“insurance companies have had record breaking profits while Americans are being hammered”
The new War on Health Care led by compassionate warmongers like Bill Kristol “kill it” comes down to a contest between the insurance companies profit margins and the welfare of the American people.
Looks like the Republicans and some Dems are choosing the Insurance companies profit margin.
It sounds like the idjits in the TV news business never heard of Will Rogers.
I’ve been having the same thoughts about the Blue Dogs: that they’d have been GOoPers (probably without a second thought and quite happily) if the GOP wasn’t batshit insane.
Blue Dogs should take note: They Plus Republicans equal a Governing Majority (see Ronald Reagan)….
We have to go after them. Lou Dobbs may get the axe for his birther bullshit. Rascist McKalip may get removed from the Florida Med Board. They said they’ve been barraged by calls. How best to contact & dog the Dogs??
no less than Nate Silver agrees with Phoenix Woman:
and he closes with a veiled warning:
That’s a great single source document, so thanks a lot for that hoss!!
Can I ask please, for the SOURCE to the money numbers for the Congress Crits, so I can QUOTE that source to whomever I speak with? And I guess, what period of TIME do those numbers cover? Are they lifetime numbers, this year’s, last years’ etc?
Again, great work, and a GREAT document to have at hand! *G* *waves*
My bad, PW, a GREAT thread topic, well done!
We’re all gonna hafta pour on the pressure to our GOOD guys and gals, but also lean even heavier on the Blue One’s. Really, really, heavy. Like, they LOSE their jobs in ‘10 if they’re up for re-election if they DON’T serve the interests of 76% of those polled in favor of a vibrant public health reform option, that starts NOW, covers EVERYone, and does NOT allow exclusion for pre-existing.
We got what, 30-45 days now with the recess coming up?
Gonna hafta work hard and loud to counter the lobby money . . . .
Progs can do it! *G*
I just posted this on the post about Dr McKalip.
Dr McKalip was a guest on True Talk, a Muslim hosted talk show on WMNF Tampa this morning. On the air he announced that he would not take up his post on the board. State Rep Daryl Rousson (sp), who had called for the Dr’s resignation was also a guest.
On edit: The archived show should be up on WMNF’s site sometime this weekend. Go to http://www.wmnf.org/programs/256 and follow the directions.
Wow, blowback and feedback got him this quick?
Astounding! Outstanding!
Are there any negative takes on this, SD?
Rule #1: Always trust Nate Silver.
That is all. :-)
Not that I’ve heard but it’s early yet. True Talk has a large audience so I would imagine I had a lot of jaw dropping company this mornin’. As Tom Henderson, host of This is Bluegrass sez, “WMNF. Always on the far left…of your radio dial.”
If Lou Dobbs got the axe at CNN, he would be immediately employed by Fox News.
Late lunch. Back to the cesspool.
Namaste
Hell, they’re prolly drawing up a contract as we speak.
The Silver Rule? ;)
Namaste
*waves* Don’t get to talk with you much lately.
Dylan Ratigan, man to watch on the health care debate on MSNBC. This morning he likened the status quo to Russian oligarchs.
As far as favorability numbers go, it’s worth pointing out that one big big reason that Democratic numbers are slipping is because they’re being stupidly ineffectual. There is a need, a leadership vacuum at the federal govt level, that has to be filled. The Republicans abrogated their governance the day Reagan announced that the govt was the problem (they’ve done their level best to prove as much ever since). But if the Democrats too are incapable of governing (albeit not for the same reasons), where does that leave us?
Personally I’m pretty disgusted with the whole lot of them. But I’m not rich and powerful and my views do not count to them.
You know PW
When you write like this, I really enjoy and agree with it. But when it comes to economics, you are an old Blue Dog your own self. From your glorification of the stock market to your demented defense of Bondad, you are considerably to the right of most of the Republicans I knew as a child.
Someone once told me you work for the Minnesota Department of Agriculture. On the off chance this is true, I would like to point out that both my grandfathers were real shovel-the-cowshit farmers. One was lifelong Kansas Republican of the Alf Landon variety, the other was a volunteer for the Farmer-Labor Party and helped organize several cooperatives including one successful venture called Land o Lakes. One was a Lutheran deacon who played cello in a string quartet, the other spoke four languages fluently. Both were so well read they made your typical college professor look functionally illiterate.
And both of them were FAR more progressive economically than you have ever been–and I have been reading you for several years. It makes little difference how progressive you are on something like say, energy policy, if you support an economics that has plunged the whole world into total chaos. Do you really think we are going to make a successful transition out of the Age of Petroleum with Goldman Sachs–and their thinking–running the show??
Trust me on this–I detest the Blue Dogs at LEAST as much as you. But folks who subscribe to neoliberal economics should be considered, by definition, Blue Dog no matter what else they may believe politically.
The man has potential.
SD, you a picker or a fan of the BG and NewG, JamG variety?
I know
How are the cat children?
MIne are lovin’ this mild summer. Altho I had to close off the back door and kitchen window after dark because of a possumz invasion
Welcome !
if you are interested in really doggin’ their asses, Letters to the Editor of papers in their districts would be even better than phone calls to their offices:
Go Here – I have links to newspapers/radio/tv in all the places they have district offices – starting about comment #5 in the thread
p.s. am suggesting you do this – after you’ve made calls to Reps who can help us – mea culpa, I spent almost a whole day this week on my Mike Ross crusade – in hindsight, I should’ve spent that time on the phone with potential allies
If Dobbs goes to Fox, CNN dies as a news outlet. They are already trailing very badly…
never mind…
I hope you don’t mind the Off Topic PW but here is a link to a story on HuffPro about the Racist Pig on CNN Lou Dobbs
It is high Time Mr Dobbs pays for all his insane blabber on CNN.
Jane did a good job on MSNBC even if she did forget her scoop to shovel the BS from the right winger guy
And Yes Single Payor! No Triggers or COOPS or anything but immediate start of a program that every citizen in Our country can sign up for on day one!! I know it will take a bit of time to get all who want such a health care plan but hey this is what the good people of this country want. Not some 1/2 way fucking measure that continues to reward the Private Health Care Rip offs!!
LOL
What do the private insurers really get out of reform failure? They avoid the public option, admittedly, but also lose a chance to pick up many millions of new customers that are crucial to their future.
Under the status quo, the insurers are faced with offering an increasingly unaffordable, defective product which employers are increasingly going to want to drop, and the current 35% share they have of health expenditures will drop further.
The will alienate more and more people by continuing to offer less and less.
The insurers have no real future under the status quo, so I would not be so quick to assume they will kill the whole thing.
“Attention Blue Dogs” COOL! They’re all reading FDL!!!!!
This is EPU’d but I’m only a bg fan. NewG and JamG not so much. My dad got all the musical talent. He was a piano player, pop and jazz.
That’s why the “reform” they favor is what the US Chamber of Commerce proposes: Forcing all Americans to buy private health insurance — yet refusing to make employers shoulder any of the costs of it.