According to sources familiar with negotiations on the Senate Finance committee, there is a "bipartisan" deal in the works between Baucus, Enzi and Snowe that will not include a public plan, which could pass in the next couple days. It will include John Kerry’s plan to tax insurance companies on their most expensive plans (those valued at over $25,000 a year).
Once a bill passes the Finance Committee, it’s up to Harry Reid to reconcile it with the HELP bill. Because Reid knows there aren’t enough votes in the Senate to pass a public plan, he will not include that part of the HELP bill. Spending bills have to start in the House, so Reid will attach it as an amendment to some bill to fix potholes or something that passed the House at some point.
Sources indicate that this is all expected to move quickly — although the situation is still extremely fluid, it could happen in the next few days.
Nancy Pelosi, on the other hand, affirms her commitment to pass a bill that has a public plan, and says that now that the "fiscally responsible" Blue Dogs shook everyone down and added a bunch of pork to the bill like they always do, they are willing to vote for it. The stumbling block is the chickenshit Democratic freshmen who are squeamish about voting for yet another big spending bill and getting reelected.
Anyway, as was always going to be the case, the only hope for the public plan is coming out of the House. And the only hope of forcing the Senate’s hand is if there is a roadblock in the House that can’t pass a health care bill without one. It puts them in the position of tanking health care because they petulantly insist on refusing to give in on something that 76% of Americans want, and the public pressure becomes enormous.
So please tell members of the House to stick around and fight, because with 50 million people in this country uninsured, it isn’t All About Them.
Update: Reid now says the Senate will not pass a bill before recess. Obama wants them to stay and keep working.



18 Comments
Spotlight



Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About FDL Action
I am hopeful that Schumer, Rockefeller, and others make it very clear that they will ‘HELP’ pass this out of committee but they will not support a final bill that does not have a robust public option and the other critical pieces that are needed.
I think we should be focusing on financing options to be merged with the HELP bill, rather than the policy sections of the Finance bill, which is going to be utter crap.
That would be very important. I know there are a couple of Senators who have been rumored to privately say this, but I don’t think it’s Schumer or Rockafeller. More like Sanders and somebody.
It would be great to have them say it publicly — almost nobody remembers this:
http://firedoglake.com/2009/04…..blic-plan/
It gave me the idea for the “40 vote strategy” (albeit for the supplemental — which served as a dry run for health care).
Reid gets to do what he wants, nobody has any control over what he decides to take from each bill.
and here they are in all their chickenshit glory
(h/t my hero slinkerwink)
1 ringy dingy . . .
I finally got faxes to Reid and Baucus last evening about 7 pm.
Jane, You’re always two steps ahead of everyone.
This is quite horrifying reporting, though.
Sorry to be brief I have to get back to FDL Book Salon.
Thanks, Eve.
As I said at the top of the post, though — things are moving very quickly and it could all change in a heartbeat.
We just have to stick to our plan and not get blown around by what the news is.
Why has Russ Feingold sent me this this morning?
Is Sen. Feingold late to this game?
Subject: The Pressure is Working
(my bold)
It sounds good. (?)
Is it good?
Coming from a Senator, that’s good. Keep the pressure on!
http://www.charlierose.com/view/interview/10496
Denis Cortese (Mayo Clinic CEO) on Charlie Rose last night had some serious and constructive criticism of Obama’s healthcare plan.
He talked about how delivery model is broken, not just cost controls.
He said that it won’t do any good to insure everybody if the actual care we’re paying for is of low value. He said the reform had to be two-track: coverage and delivery value.
If the Dems could sell their proposal as an attempt to improve QUALITY instead of just provide accessibility and affordability, the opposition would cave.
The problem is that the Blue Dogs and the GOP are the ones talking about QUALITY, not the Dems who are talking about “covering everybody” and mandatory buying.
There have to be prominent & specific selling points for INCREASING VALUE to deprive the obstructionists of political cover.
Baucus, Snowe, Enzi’s bipartisan plan
Bipartisan
In
Name
Only
There is no “quality” when it comes to health care. You either have health care or you don’t. It all should be of the same quality. It’s not like going to a mechanic who might cheat by fixing your muffler with some coat hangers and coke cans. If a doctor or nurse or technician is not giving their best all the time they need to look for other work.
Value is the right argument.
If you have a pinched nerve in your back and your doctor says surgery, that’s not value because you have only a 5% chance of getting it fixed.
Americans equate Quality with Quantity not remembering the first tenet of medicine is Do No Harm.
Aravosis had it right in his recent post about it doesn’t matter what kind of care you have now, if you get really sick you’re screwed. The site seems to be down right now but here’s the link in hopes it will soon be back up.
I am in NY and just got petitioned by the Working Families Party to convey my unhappiness that these representatives oppose the surtax form of funding HR 3200, and are siding with the wealthy against the bill:
Nita Lowey (18th-Rock./ West.)
Dan Maffei (25th-Central NY)
Eric Massa (29th-Western NY)
Mike McMahon (13th-S.I.)
Scott Murphy (20th-Cap. Region
When I called my Rep, Scott Murphy’s office to challenge this decision, I was told that he, Mr. Murphy had never committed himself to Hr 3200. His phone number in DC is 202-225-5614.
My letter to my Rep:
Earl, I appreciate your efforts in the health care debate very much. At this point, I want to urge you to commit to rejecting any health reform bill that does not include a public plan. I believe the public plan is essential, but it is in trouble in the Senate. Let’s force the hand of the Senate by letting them know that the House insists on a public plan and will not vote for any bill that does not include it and will not accept any poor substitutes for it. I’m sure your constituents will support you in that position. I don’t think many Senators will want to be seen as defeating health care because of their opposition to one component of it, especially when some are already embarrassed by the money flowing to them from insurance companies. Thank you
Paying for the public option is a no-brainer
http://assets.ourfuture.org/do…..xation.pdf
http://www.cbpp.org/cms/index……38;id=2874
Yellowdog, Saint Russ is collecting e-mail addresses for a money push. He bugs me. I’m still waiting for any help from the Beatified One on health care. But he’s too busy bashing Obama about whatever the hell he is miffed about on any particular day. Sign your own freaking petition, Russ.
Who’s the Beatified One? Russ?