Here’s a round-up of the latest news out of Capitol Hill on health care reform. Apparently, Orrin Hatch walked out on the "bipartisan" talks on health care reform in the Senate Finance Committee. Here’s a quote from Senator Hatch:
“Right now, with some of the provisions in there, I just can’t do it,” Hatch told reporters in Washington today. The Utah senator said he can’t support a measure that costs as much as $1 trillion, and opposes other provisions he sees as likely to be included in a final measure.
Hatch said he fears that if Baucus produces a bill, Democratic leaders in both chambers won’t allow it to be the framework for final legislation and will instead press ahead for provisions Republicans oppose. He said the provisions he can’t agree to include a public option, the employer mandate and the individual coverage mandate.
“They’re going to pass two very partisan bills, and then put the crunch on Max,” Hatch said. Hatch is one of four Republicans who had been meeting with Baucus and Democrats Kent Conrad of North Dakota and Jeff Bingaman of New Mexico on a possible compromise. Republicans in the group include Charles Grassley of Iowa, the ranking Republican on Baucus’s panel; Olympia Snowe of Maine and Mike Enzi of Wyomi
That same article talks about the current negotiations going on which involve the creation of non-profit co-operatives to compete against private insurers. It’s not clear whether these co-operatives will be state-based or nationally based. If they are state-based, then that falls very closely in line with what the Blue Dogs want. The only reason they’re pushing state-based co-operatives are because that’s what the private insurers are pushing as well behind the scenes because it affords them an opportunity to game the system.
And on the House side, Speaker Nancy Pelosi’s making the right sort of noises about having Congress stay to work on health care reform. However, there is one big caveat in the article where she talks about having Congress stay to work on health care reform:
But Pelosi also said she believes she has the votes to pass the bill on the floor of the House. Still, she indicated it will be important for members to look at the Senate Finance Committee’s version, which is not yet finished. That suggests she may change the House version to more closely resemble the Senate bill.
The Senate Finance version should have broader appeal with Democratic centrists and Republicans, particularly if it does not include a government-run insurance option to compete with the private sector, as expected.
You know what’s likely to be in the Senate Finance Committee bill? State-based health co-operatives or a national health care co-operative. If they try to change the Tri-Committee health care bill to look a lot more like the "co-op alternatives to the public option," in the Senate Finance bill then it would be the worst possible course to happen, including the dropping of the subsidies for the middle class from 400% of the federal poverty level to 300% of the poverty level, in order to win the votes of the Blue Dog Democrats.
It’s why Jane Hamsher has been working so hard on the Public Option Whip Tool count to make sure we have a progressive bloc of Democrats that refuse to pass out a badly weakened health care bill with no public option out of the House. We have to keep up on the phone calls to Members of Congress asking them not to go on recess, and to pass the Tri-Committee House health care bill as it currently stands out of the Energy and Commerce Committee.
We can’t afford for them to go on vacation while we suffer from claim denials, lack of claim reimbursements, fighting for pre-authorization, and being dropped from insurance policies due to pre-existing conditions. Thousands of Americans are also facing medical bankruptcy this week from medical bills they can’t afford to pay because their private insurers refuses to do so.
I’ve had enough of this dithering from Congress. Will you please join me in signing the petition and asking the House to stay in session to pass health care instead of going on vacation?





32 Comments
Spotlight




Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About FDL Action
Advanced search
Done!
Thank you!
The longer the bill hangs out there, the more it smells like a dead fish and the people won’t buy it…you want to rush something that will cause harm? First rule of Hippocrates: Do No Harm.
Vacation is a bad idea, and Pelosi knows it. They’ve been working on this for fifty years; the American people elected Barack Obama based on his promise to fix health care. Now it’s time to make it happen.
And I think The Hill injected its own thinking into the idea that Pelosi would consider the Senate Finance Committee bill; if anything, she’s simply trying to get them to do their job by indicating the House would consider it. I don’t expect her to sell us out.
Words are words–what matters to me is what kind of action they take.
Here is an interesting statistic that is not funny at all: Almost Five Million Adults Have Lost Their Insurance Since September 2008
Sam Stein just put this up.
Already signed it. Hatch can go hike the Appalachian Trail.
Thanks for signing the petition!
meanwhile your President is meeting with insurance lobbyists and citing Bush era precedents to refuse to disclose who was there!
http://www.salon.com/opinion/g…..index.html
Signed. Sent on to others who likely will sign. Let there be a sign!!
You know, it occurs to me that as we’re contacting legislators, we also need to be contacting Obama. Let him know you’ve got his back or what’s missing for you. Either way, make some noise, eh? Omygosh, thunder in the northland. (A sign? See #10 above.) Few of those so far this year.
May the bill cause a world of harm to the malefic insurance companies who feed on dead Americans who have been denied medical care.
Thank you for signing it and passing it to your friends as well. The more, the better!
I agree with the dead fish analogy. This is stinking worse all the time. We are seeing concession on top of compromise until nothing or worse than nothing is left.
Two words for Hatch: boo hoo.
Signed. Glad we’re doing this. CNN had Susan Molinari (had almost forgotten who she was) on today and she said the Dems shouldn’t worry about the Rs – that the ones bringing the health care problems are the BLUE DOGS. Don’t know why they would even have her on but that’s just me.
Signed earlier.
Senator Escape Hatch…..
Old Italian proverb-
“Fish rots from the head.”
Signed.
They have to get this done before the right wing pundits tell so many lies that the American people have no choice but to believe them.
Here is a perfect example of a Republican lying through his teeth.
http://progressnotcongress.org/?p=2233
yes, instead of drawing a map of the different coverages, private, healthexchange, the public plan, Medicaid expanded, with overlapping colors to show subsidies for different income groups…………………the no-neck monsters are free to lie their asses off on TV to an uninformed and unsuspecting public.
Great job. Thanks for round-the-clock action and updates.
Be alright with me if all the Republicans left….AND the Blue Dawgs.
If we get a “co-op” we may as well send them all home. that’s why single payer should have never been “taken off the table”. They should have negotiated from THERE, then we WOULD have gotten a decent “public option”. FAH!
Signed, of courses, and I sent it to friends
In response to Twain @ 16:
This just really pisses me off!!
Rahm Emanuel ought to be out there twisting the arm of every damn Blue Dog and telling him/her to get in line in support of the President’s program.
Rahm was SO anxious to fund these losers with our donations to the DCCC when he headed it. Now look what he’s got: a bunch of idiots who won’t support Democratic values.
This “oh, we’re in conservative districts” is just bullshit. With 76% support for getting a good public option, the Blue Dog weasels should be told they can’t AFFORD to oppose it.
No further money for them from the DCCC or DSCC; no visits by Obama; just freeze-outs and shame.
Finally, Obama ought to point out that he speaks for the American people. The lobbyists have been swarming all over the Hill to plead their greedy cases. Real working Americans can’t take time off, or pay $3500 for a seat in the hearing room, to have their voices heard. Obama should make a forceful case by saying he speaks for the people.
Signed, with a note.
Also: Shorter Hatch: “Hey, if they get this thing going — which also happens to double as an additional $1T of economic stimulus — then it might actually turn the recession around. And then I’ll have to keep wearing this frickin’ D suit!!”
(By the way, if socialized health insurance is the road to all ruin and downfall, then why exactly are all the European countries with socialized health insurance doing so very much better than the US, economically speaking?)
I totally agree.
That’s why I was so pissed at the beginning of this when Pelosi et al. deemed single payer “not realistic.” That motion narrowed the playing field considerably, and not in a good direction.
Just think if all that $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ the insurance industry is bribing Congress with would be put into the fund for paying for healthcare?
It’d pretty much be paid for.
If they’re making THAT much $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ off our suffering, they’re making too much. period.
Signed.
Wrote in that they’ve BEEN taking a vacation from decency for far too long.
Signed. Here’s what I wrote:
I heard a Blue Dog – didn’t catch his name – on Npr nattering on about co-ops. I can’t imagine anything more useless — except maybe what we have now. Why doesn’t anyone know that these have been tried and didn’t work?
So where is the petition for the Senate? This one is obsolete already, no?