Yesterday we asked people to call their representative and let them know that they should stand up to Rahm Emanuel and demand "no triggers" in the House Democratic Caucus meeting last night.
Yesterday afternoon, Emanuel himself headed to Capitol Hill, where he heard complaints from liberal lawmakers. The idea of a trigger option is popular with conservative Democrats — but according to Roll Call, legislators the chief of staff met with yesterday told him its inclusion in a final health care package would cost the proposal their support, sinking the measure.
House Energy and Commerce Chairman Henry Waxman said Emanuel had said what members were hoping to hear. "He doesn’t stand by the trigger," Waxman told Roll Call. "He said the president and his administration and he are for a public plan as one of the options."
There are still plenty of ways for Rahm to screw up a public plan, the most likely being the acceptance of Kent Conrad’s co-op plan, which is something the White House is also actively pushing — or so I’ve heard. But good job Raul Grijalva, co-chair of the Progressive Caucus, for showing impressive leadership on this and creating the space for other members to step into.
And bravo to MoveOn for stepping out and taking a bolder and more aggressive stance against Rahm’s inside moves than any progressive group has done yet:
"Can you call the White House switchboard and tell them you’re disappointed in Chief of Staff Emanuel’s comments supporting the ‘trigger’?" MoveOn asked in a message sent to supporters Tuesday. The e-mail included the number for the White House switchboard. "Tell them voters want a strong public health insurance option-not half-measures like the ‘trigger.’"
Yesterday truly was one of the most satisfying days of my entire life. Thanks to everyone who participated in "this is what you can do with your triggers, Rahm" day.





37 Comments
Spotlight




Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About FDL Action
Advanced search
that makes me happy. these efforts must feel Sisyphean to you at times, they do to me, and I’m only dealing with the critters – I don’t have to deal with so many well intentioned but contrarian dfh’s on this end – your patience and steadfastness has been something
p.s. didn’t even know about Move On’s effort until late last night – my inner pollyanna thinks Rahm may have done us all a favor – yesterday was like a Perfect Storm
Everyone should know “trigger” was invented by the Third Way. (Blue Dogs, Lincoln Pryor Senate Dems, and their buddies inside the insurance industry.)
http://www.thirdway.org/
Third Way on Source Watch
Open Left with the rest of the Third Way story.
What more does one need to know?
Thank You Jane! You are one in a million.
Jane thanks to you, Move On, for “triggering”us to continue to make phone calls, emails, applying pressure.
Really something that Rahm would have rather protected insurance companies over the American people.
a sign on Rahms car in D.C. seems appropriate
“Save the Insurance Companies”
Congratulations, Jane. Your hard work is paying off, as is that of the dedicated pups who make their calls even when the odds seem hopelessly long.
In essence, that’s what Gandhi told the Indian people.
i live in jane harman district.
why is she off the list of CDs in CA?
i called and they said she hasnt taken a pledge but is absolutely for the public option.
any reason she is not listed?
Jane Hamsher’s Whipping tool work well in conjunction with knowing what scams are being used to decieve us or disquise legislation. Thank you. Feels like a change is gathering momentum for the coming unemployment storm that will bring more people into activism. The horizons are broadening as moe people are left out of the economy.
checked in with Harman again–absolutely against a trigger.
she has not taken a pledge though to oppose any bill without a public option.
Jane, You are a true leader and an inspiration.
Dogged, determined, relentless, despite the slog that democracy requires;it is because you have creative ideas and the ability to use your excellent blog to communicate them that a difference is being made – the progressive caucus is awakening to their true power.
Thank you
fyi – the Whip list is comprised of members of the Congr Progressive Caucus – Rep Harman is a member in good standing of the Blue
CrossDog caucus – and good on ya for calling !I had my daughter at the dentist’s office this morning and the TV was on CNN. There was an ad from “Conservatives for Patients’ Rights” (or something like that) scaring us about how bad it will be if “government beaurocrats” get between us and our doctors if we get a government-run health plan. It would be a very easy ad to parody, showing how now we have MBA’s making the medical decisions for us at insurance companies. Calling Watertiger….
Another stellar appointment.
I found this via C&L. This appointing corporate dogs to oversee Federal agencies is getting real old, real fast.
What great news! All evening yesterday I found myself looking at the clock, wondering what was going on/had gone on at that meeting.
Seeing the post about Rep. Grijalva’s letter was somewhat encouraging —
thank you again, Jane, for your leadership and your ‘whipping.’
“It worked.” Today, two of the loveliest words in the English language.
thank you Secretary Vilsack, may I have another ?
believe that is Rick Scott’s handywork -
was over at a WH FB ‘event’ on Healthcare about an hour ago – concern troll city
Why does Rahm want Obama’s health care plan to be a giant gift to Insurance Companies at the expense of the public? Why does Obama want his health care plan to be a big ol’ flop?
ot
fox news contributor slams Sarah “inarticulate and under educated”
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/…..26370.html
great news. I do have to say, though, that this does raise some questions about our leadership . I mean, is this what Rahm’s job (on behalf of Obama) comes down to: to float the more-conservative-than-acceptable trial balloons demanded by corporate lobbyists – just to see whether the American people are attentive, organized and motivated-enough to pop ‘em? Is this really leadership? ;-P
Its all kind of Max Headroomish (remember that show from the ’80s)? The show portrayed a turn-of-the-century capitalist dystopia here amoral corporations control the media and use it to govern by instant push polling… not that that is what we’re doing, but it there does seem to be some shades of such an approach in the admin’s thinking about how to govern.
Geez, I’d forgotten about Max Headroom.
Too many things that once seemed impossible to imagine happening in this country are happening, or very close to happening.
Way too many occasions in the last 10 years to say, “never thought I’d see the day…”
Hey Rahm: Trigger this.
yep. We’re not quite there on the artificial intelligence technology that show predicted, but otherwise it proved to be rather prophetic. Murdoch/Fox is Channel 23. Political will independent of corporations (and the occasional grassroots reaction to those corporations) has essentially evaporated. Civic responsibility as an end unto itself is purely reactive to and a function of public opinion and public relations campaigns. Public welfare is defined by whatever can be sold in a few jingles in political ads. All-in-all, a sort of techno-mob-rule, exactly as predicted. Woe be us.
I wish I had a buck for every time I’ve thought of the world of Max Headroom when reading the news. I loved that show. Do I miss the command line text only machines? Sometimes. Programs written in Assembly or C ran like a mother…
Are Rahm and Joe Lieberman lovers? Terrifying, I know, but I thought someone should ask the question.
Blue Texan’s regularly scheduled post is up and ready: “Biden to Smack Boehner Around on Stimulus”
Just a quick question: Why isn’t Betty McCollum (D-MN 4th), included in this list? I know that she has been a consistent advocate of progressive causes. Is it because she isn’t considered a member of the “progressive caucus”? I really don’t know. Please note, this is not a criticism at all, I totally support Jane’s efforts, I’m just curious if this may be an inadvertent omission.
We are a feisty bunch, aren’t we.
Thanks Jane for your leadership on this but I have one very small issue.
Couldn’t we use a pic of ‘Cool Whip’ rather than ‘Miracle Whip’?
Miracle Whip tastes like ass.
Just a thought.
To add to gonzoid23. Where’s Norm Dicks? He’s progressive on social issues.
Special mid-week Book Salon over at the Mothership with George Soros’ The Crash of 2008 and What It Means hosted by Daniel Davis
Let’s not put the cart before the horse.Until we get significant health care reform please keep calling your Senators & congress peoples.Harry Reid letting it leak out that Baucus ought to ditch Repukes is a ploy to get “yous” to ease off the peddle.Think it’s strange the WH is announcing that”Hospitals promise to save you 150 bl in 10yrs” ? It’s all a crock of BS.You think the hospitals can’t change their minds after you letup on congress & once again gets screwed by watered down Health reform ?Please don’t stop calling & bitchiin,it’s the only way.
Does this appt need Senate/House approval?
Jane I am sure you are aware that OBAMA is some kind of trouble and the REP are trying to get some traction on the issues of the economy,energy and heathcare. However we must become even more determined and relentless on the DEMS and not let upon them up period. It seems as though the ADMIN does not have the fight or want to fight for there own programs. However, all of us in the progressive community need to let all them know that we are not have willing to settle for nothing as suppose to going for something that is meaningful and worthwhile. In any case Obama has to get in the fight like it or not. WE Must continue to fight,but also this a struggle between us and them. By the way we must stay united in our effort whatever it takes.
I’d like to learn more about this hospital deal VP Biden is trumpeting.
If the hospitals are going to accept medicare/medicaid reductions in payments, won’t this mean a cut in SERVICES to those who use medicare/medicaid?
That’s the LAST thing on earth any boomer wants to see, hear, learn!
So, I’m REAL curious as to what this new deal is all about, and what it REALLY means . .
Any Pups know?
And a big thanks to Mz. Hamsher for leading this drive on public option. I don’t think I’ve EVER seen such a fast and large turnaround on WH/Admin/Congress rhetoric other than when corp lobbyists make a call and forward boatloads of money to same!!
Great, great job everyone, and thanks FDL for leading the charge.
There is already a deep reduction in services in Medicaid. There are so many drugs that one can’t get, can’t get alternative/preventative treatments, no real dental (unless you want that tooth pulled) and shady Docs doing nothing but collecting the money. Yes, I speak from experience.
Jane I am proud to serve.
I feel sorry for you Americans.
As if insurance bureaucrats are full of humanity and empathy for their clients…