I’ve been fighting breast cancer for 16 years now, and am gratefully in recovery from my third bout.
I’m lucky to be one of the ones who fought and won, but there are many who fought and lost.
The New York Times has a story this morning about the number of people who had health insurance that were nonetheless driven into personal bankruptcy because of their medical bills. I’ve written before that despite being fully insured by Blue Cross, the cost has been enormous.
Fighting for your life and knowing you could lose everything you have in the process is agonizing.
So when I see women like Kay Hagan who oppose a public plan because she wants "to ensure private health insurance isn’t going to be destabilized," I take it pretty personally.
Then there’s Olympia Snowe, who worries that a public plan will keep prices low and cut into insurance company profits, because keeping the Blue Cross healthy is evidently more important than keeping the public healthy.
And there’s Diane Feinstein who says criticism from the left "doesn’t move me one whit" when it comes to supporting a public plan, as if her vote is a matter of personal fancy and not her responsibility as a public servant. (This from a woman who has never worried for one minute about how she could pay for a catastrophic illness — most of us don’t have the luxury of casting votes to award our husbands billions of dollars in government contracts.)
There’s Mary Landrieu, who says a public plan "undermines the essence of our efforts to create a real market-based private sector model," and Blanche Lincoln, who worries about "usurping" the insurance industry’s ability "to compete in the marketplace."
Well, none of them will ever have to worry about what it’s like to be at the mercy of the insurance industry when your life hangs in the balance.. They’ll enjoy being a part of the Federal Employee Benefits Program for life, so they are free to focus on keeping their millions campaign donations from the insurance industry flowing.
These "fiscally responsible" women fret about how much a health care bill is going to cost, even though none of them withheld their vote from the bank bailouts because there was no way to pay for them. Nor has any of them made the slightest protestation as Merrill Lynch and Citigroup raise wages by 50% this year, or as Goldman Sachs pays out the biggest bonuses in its 140 year history.
So I asked recently where Emily’s List was on all of this, since they have supported many of these women Senators in the past. I got a note from Emily Lockwood of Emily’s list, saying that "as an organization, we don’t lobby on any issues."
So I started thinking — why do I care if there are more women in office if they don’t care about women’s issues? What on earth would be the value of having a woman who saw her primary function in this battle as guarding the profitability of the insurance industry, as opposed to a man like Bernie Sanders whose commitment to a strong public plan has been one of the only firewalls in the Senate against this turning into nothing more than an insurance industry bailout?
How are these women any better than Joe Lieberman, who never met a war he couldn’t afford, but now says we can’t pay for a public plan?
Women in Congress who will stand up and say "enough, there is a line I will not cross" are in short supply — even among our friends.
So together with BlueNC and Pam’s House Blend, we reached out to my fellow breast cancer survivors in North Carolina. Women like Hazel and Connie, Juanita and Gail and Patricia and Yvette. Dorrita, Connie, Linda and Lotie. Mary, Pepper, Waddeah and Felicia. Women who have triumphed, women who have fought breast cancer and won. Women of all ages and races and sexual orientations who are not afraid to tell the truth and speak up on behalf of other women.
Because many of our sisters did not survive. Getting early treatment is critical to recovery, and women often put off getting exams if they don’t know how they’re going to pay for them. Young African American women are twice as likely to die of breast cancer as young white women, and are five times as likely to suffer delays in getting treatment.
Kay Hagan has been the sole obstacle keeping a public plan from coming out of the Senate HELP Committee. On Friday, Pam Spaulding and breast cancer survivors of North Carolina will go to Kay Hagan’s office carrying their signatures and those of the people who stand with them, asking Hagan to stand with us, too. We want to get 20,000 signatures of support for them to deliver in the next 48 hours.
We survived because we had the medical treatment that many of our sisters who died did not. As survivors we want to speak out and demand access to health care for the women whose battle is before them.





43 Comments
Spotlight




Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About FDL Action
Advanced search
Oh, Jane, this is so powerful and deeply moving. Thinking about my next step . . . .
Signing the petition . . . duh!!
Thank you, Barbara. Appreciate your support, as always.
Our Most precious Jane…what would we do without you….going to sign now…SS was put into place by FDR,because SO MANY women were dying in the street,when they outlived their husbands
ARGH!@#$%^&!@#$%^!!!!!!
{{{barbs}}}}….been looking into moving to France…mebbe visit in Sept
Thanks for this, Jane.
And there’s Diane Feinstein who says criticism from the left “doesn’t move me one whit” when it comes to supporting a public plan, as if her vote is a matter of personal fancy and not her responsibility as a public servant.
************************
of course the corollary,is…DIFI has, NOT ONE wit…sad that
Thank you for remembering.
Always appreciate your support, PW.
Seriously? Wow!
My cousin, Pat, was diagnosed with breast cancer when she was not much more than 40 years old. Like so many survivors, she went through the living hell of chemo, radiation, mastectomy. She was principal of a special education school in Illinois. A powerful advocate for individuals with little apparent power. She was sister of a twin brother who has profound mental retardation and multiple other disabilities.
Pat died when she was 46, roughly 12 years ago. Was her insurance adequate to meet the financial (and emotional) challenge? I don’t know. I wasn’t involved in that aspect of her life. But my guess is that her husband and kids were buried in debt. And the shovel-wielders were insurance company claims analysts, hired to save the company money (as documented in Michael Moore’s “Sicko”).
For survivors (and hopeful blessings on every one of you!), for future survivors (we’re all in this together, one way or another), and for those who did not survive, it behooves us to stand, to march, to speak clearly with those who can and for those who can’t.
Really. I mean every word of this.
this country does NOT care or love its women or elderly,one i am,one i will become if im lucky
What would it take to remove health insurance from the benefits enjoyed by elected federal officials. Is that something that would be done with a national referendum? I know it’s nothing these people would ever write and vote for themselves.
really WHAT DIFFERENCE…does it make,what the serious illness is…we will ALL be hung out to dry in this system…its a matter of fate and time
i gather much strength from these TWO
http://www.history.rochester.e…..ge/sba.jpg
i set up and ran healthcare rally at the fleamarket last Sat.,had a blue grass trio play…we handed out 800 brochures…im emailing my compatriots with Janes post…
Don’t know what it would take but that’s a great idea. The PR coverage alone would be fantastic. Why can’t the people have the same healthcare afforded to the ruling elite? If Congress can’t give the people the same coverage then rescind the benefits of members of Congress. Most people would sign on to that and it could become a terrible embarrasment and expose the hypocrisy of Congress.
I received a phone call from Emilys list last week, where I told the reason I would not be contributing was because of disapointment with Kay Hagen there was an audible groan a few words of backpedaling and an abrupt end to the call.
I am a 5-year breast cancer survivor in Chapel Hill. I signed this petition, but I have already emailed Hagan and telephoned her office to support a public option. I’m afraid she’s much influenced by Blue Cross/Blue Shield of NC. I voted for her, but I’m disappointed that she’s not much better than Liddy Dole in that corporate profits matter more than people.
Thank you for your ongoing advocacy, Jane. But I’ll ask everyone to be mindful that this is not just a woman’s issue, this healthcare reform. It affects everything and everyone. Getting it right matters.
Our old friend who came to the hospital in Fargo as we were awaiting the ambulance to take “Mr. Sunshine” to Mayo/Methodist Hospital didn’t know he would find the buzzsaw of advocacy at full speed. Telling him exactly what we wanted him to tell Kent Conrad, our Senator, about health care reform.
We’re cautiously optimistic, ever mindful that we are in a high risk situation, even from the treatments…but if all goes well, we’ll be here awhile. So Kent, if your interns are reading here… Senator Hagan, Senator Baucus, Senator Dorgan…we’re here at Mayo.
MayoCare is an outstanding model for what health care should be. Patients first. Come talk to us, the patients, the families, the healthcare professionals.
And listen.
The cancer on health care must be excised from the system. The remedy won’t be easy, I know. But I see the stories on the faces of real people here. And we need you on our side. MayoCare, not K Street greed. If they say they’re too big to fail, they’ve already failed.
I got a similar call just yesterday, and basically asked why they aren’t in the forefront of this campaign. There was lots of stammering. I hung up.
Well, you see, THEY’D have to give up their coverage. They gave it to themselves,like they give themsleves raise all the the time.
Jane, I’m speechless by your post. What courage you have!
Of course they would have to give up their coverage which of course they would never do. The point is that a movement demanding the same healthcare they already have would be a means of exposing their hypocrisy to more than just progressives but to the average Jane and Joe Citizen.
Jane, thanks for the action page, signed & sent. I am a resident of NC and work as an administrator in a rural health clinic, I’ve been calling Kay Hagan every week reinforcing the need for a public option and encouraging our patients to do the same.
Makes me crazy that the public is overwhelmingly for a public option and our elected Democrats are rooting around in the pockets of big insurance/pharma.
Signed, with pleasure.
thank you to jane for this post and for all who were willing to tell their stories for it.
this is a very personal issue for so many. and for me too.
CALL chicken noodle news…CNN,and ask them pointblank…WHY some people who cant afford insurance will be left to die
steam emitting from my ears!!!!
http://www.cnn.com/2009/POLITI…..care.poll/
Time Warner Inc.
One Time Warner Center
New York, NY 10019-8016
United States – Map
Phone: 212-484-8000
Fax: 212-489-6183
Web Site: http://www.timewarner.com
Donna Edwards, Where Are You?
Jane, thanks for all you do.
Did you see my brief run-down of the Udall event yesterday?
once they are elected
THEY ARE SET FOR LIFE
300,000,000 plus other Americans………..not so much
KISS argh!@#$%^&*@#$%^&@#$%^Y&!!!!!!!
WE WANT THE SAME HEALT HCARE AS WE PROVIDE OUR LEGISLATORS
period
simple enuf?
okay must deTox now…bbl
Jane and Pam,
wonder if the Susan G Komen/ NC people would be willing to lend some of their clout to actions like this – they do have an office in Raleigh
I have read their advocacy pages and Kay Hagan is standing in the way of everything they are working towards
I think of them pretty much as a fundraising behemoth and frankly don’t know much about them other than the fact they pack serious heat and influence –
just wondering if NC affiliates would help us much like CT’s Planned Parenthood and NARAL did in 06.
I am a Lymphoma survivor that just moved to NC in January.
I’ve been NED for 5 years,but it took 4 years to get over the side effects of the chemo treatments. I have been very lucky with my fight with cancer but not with my personal fiances. Even with excellent health insurance it cost us our saving, investments and my company.
I was recently informed by NC BC that they would NOT accept me even though I have had BC in another state for 20 years. I have no hope that I will be able to buy insurance from any other insurance company in NC.
I relayed all of this to Sen. Hagen last month and received a non-reply reply. The woman is a coward.
Best of luck in your visit ladies, all of us are supporting your efforts.
((((((george))))))
signed the petition, jane.
Jane:
Absolutely required reading!
My sister, who lives in Canada was diagnosed with Acute Myelogenous Leukemia (AML) in September–a disease that, without expensive treatment, is an almost immediate death sentence. (Our mother died of it 23 years ago.)
Because my sister was cared for under a single-payer system, plus an inexpensive supplemental policy (like our Medicare works), her 10 months of treatment (much of it spent in the hospital), for extensive rounds of chemotherapy, radiation and finally a stem-cell transplant–well over a million dollars worth of treatment–cost her approximately $1000, for a single room, rather than a double. Wonderful care, and I’m happy to say that she is leukemia-free, with an excellent chance at life.
Kay Hagan, Olympia Snowe, Diane Feinstein, Mary Landrieu and others–listen up! You may have a policy (courtesy of the government) that gives you wonderful coverage like this, but so many of the rest of us do not. Those of us with pre-existing conditions, unable to get good, reasonably priced coverage, live in fear every day that we will be be diagnosed with a disease that will leave our families destitute. Where is the empathy and understanding??!!
Thanks for your great article…
hi Jane. I wonder if those folks would realize just how grave an insult it is for you to compare anyone to Joe Lieberman.
Silly me, I thought “destabilizing” private health insurance’s racket was the whole point of credible health care reform. Tens of millions of Americans, probably more, desperately need better access to health care. The principal bottleneck to improving access to health care and its cost is today’s health insurers.
Making progressive noises then voting to protect big insurers’ profits is like spraying a little room deodorizer on the mess the cat left in the middle of the living room carpet. It might feel good, but it won’t help much.
Jane,
I wish you the very best of luck in fighting your battle with cancer. It is something that no one should have to go thru. However I do find it rather interesting when you say “Well, none of them will ever have to worry about what it’s like to be at the mercy of the insurance industry when your life hangs in the balance…” How come you are so willing to put your life to the mercy of the government when they have a terrible track record of managing things? Do you want the government deciding whether or not it is “worth it” to cover the medical costs? This is a reality. Check out the Canadian and European model. Not everyone is covered for everything all the time. If they feel your cancer has advanced to far they will not cover your expenses. My wife has RA and she takes injections every 4 weeks. The cost is about $3600 a month which my insurance company covers all of it. I have no doubt that if we had public plan that there is no way that the government will approve this treatment. Be careful for what you wish for, because you may just get it. Your contempt for insurance companies is clouding your judgment.
Fredric
Just wait until your private health insurer decides your wife cost then too much to insure and jacks up your rates or drops you with some bogus excuse.
It will happen one day since insurance is for profit and sick people are not profitable. When they do dump you, I pray there is a public option so you can buy coverage from the government.
Big thanks Jane. I forwarded this to my sis in SF. She’s already reported back that she’s signed on too.
If you have them, get them checked: Breast Cancer Awareness works on a LOCAL level. Find and Get a Mammogram here!
Kay Hagan has accepted far too much money from health insurers and pHarma. But the real problem is no publicly-mandated control on campaign spending and 503 PAC influence-peddling. So politicians seeking tenure feel entirely justified accepting what amount to bribery in campaign fundraising, compromising all morality in a race to the ethical bottom. Free speech is not money, and money is not free speech – money is too-often a vehicle for bribery, plain & simple, and its use in political campaigns should be entirely outlawed.