"Give me HR 676 with a good set of canines."
Rochester Turning blog has a intelligent post up about the misuse of the term "public option." Evidently Senator Schumer is advocating a "public option" that is hamstrung to such a point that the idea of "competing on a level playing field with private insurers" has been rendered toothless.
Such an entity wouldn’t be able to use its sheer size to set prices the way Medicare.
-snip-
Please, what kind of mamby pamby crap are they peddling here? What is the point if we can’t set prices, or negotiate for lower priced drugs? And, a level playing field? What does that mean and how does one accomplish that? As stlo7 says, this undefined, "public option" is some nebulous, placate the people with something that uses the word public kind of plan. It has no teeth and it will not bite.
Buffalo Pundit notes:
The plan that’s being proposed for the US would let people keep their private health coverage. Supposedly everyone just lurves their health insurance, even though I’ve anecdotally never heard a single person gush about how awesome and easy to deal with their health insurer are. Obama’s plan would offer up a public health insurance option. No mandate – just an ability to buy into a public health insurance scheme.
Just like those pinko lefties Michele Bachmann and Mitch McConnell get to use.
But some congressional Democrats are, as usual, caving to Republicans. They’re caving to the masters of the think-tank op-ed -> right wing blog -> endless #tcot re-Tweets -> nightly news/cable news reports on the "wide dissent" on the internet against an Obama/Democratic plan.
Obama. effing. won. He won handily. He ran on a platform promising a public health insurance option that would be affordable, fair, and available to anybody at a reasonable price. He ran on a platform that would offer up universal access to health insurance which resembles that offered to members of Congress.
Democrats have to stop being afraid of the right-wing chatter machine and start acting like Goddamned winners.
‘Nuff said.





15 Comments
Spotlight




Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About FDL Action
Advanced search
Thanks Cynthia.
Gotta preserve the entities that pay campaign bills.
Here is a video that says a lot about “Our” Insurance companies
I sure hope we get Single Payer and put these greedy bastards out of business!! They have had Their way our Health Care for over sixty years and what do we have??? Record numbers who have no coverage, Record numbers who HAD coverage but because the health insurance companies worry more about their Profits, these Good Americans are forced into Bankruptcy because the Insurance companies refuse to cover their medical needs.
This Must stop and STOP now!!
Single Payer with the Government overseeing the health care, Use the VA as a starting point of how to do it!! The VA provides good health Care with little overhead!!
hr 676 is conyer’s single payer bill. with it we could have comprehensive universal healthCARE with no copays, no coinsurance and no deductibles AND control total healthcare costs.
but that’s NOT what obama and sebelius have proposed (although it’s what i think we need to be fighting for).
from drsteveb: Important Public Message: Public Option is NOT Single Payer
all public option plans preserve a multi payer system with private insurance companies.
more on single payer from pnhp:
http://www.pnhp.org/facts/sing…..ources.php
I have used the VA extensively (but not for a few years). I was very satisfied with the care I got but The doctors and nurses etc are employees of the VA. That dog ain’t gonna hunt.
Book Salon up at the Mothership with Robert Wright’s The Evolution of God hosted by John Horgan
Why not?? They attract good Doctors and other health care professionals! But I as I said use it a a model of where to start. They Dr and others don’t necessarily need to work for Uncle Sam!! But their delivery system holds costs down and the price of Meds to the patient with low co pays.
Use the medicare system but incorporate the efficiencies of the VA.
Works for me!! Just get rid of the insurance companies, they sucked the money out of the Public for long enough!! I wonder how many have died because of their GREED!
have you read this one?
Horror stories from doctors about dealing with the insurance companies.
thank you for the link. wow.
If 70% of people like their insurance then 30% do not.
If 45M people are uninsured that’s about 15% uninsured.
30% + 15% ==> 45% of Americans who want change!
I still oppose single-payer as I don’t think it’s the role of the federal gov’t to put people out of business if they’re not breaking the law.
That said, I see no reason we should leave 135M people unhappy.
And, now that we know the Repubs aren’t interested in voting for a public option bill, Dems should simply push it through.
I also prefer dropping the mandates as there’s no good reason to assist the private insurers in their raping of Americans via high prices & low service. We should also remove any other public assistance they might be receiving.
Let’s help people the private insurers won’t help.
Let’s do it cheaper and with better service.
Let’s do it now!
Taking money for services you don’t intend to provide is probably illegal. Taking money under false pretenses is definitely illegal.
Cancelling coverage for things the covered didn’t know about certainly should be illegal. Claiming pregnancy is a pre-existing condition should be illegal, too. Cancelling coverage, or denying coverage, for treatment
ought to be grounds for removal of the company’s charter and major fines for the officers as well as the corporation itself.
The only reason they are not breaking the law is because many of the rules and regs were changed. They need to be strengthen so that we no longer have murder by spreadsheet.
It’s not enough said. What also has to be said is that if the Democrats keep representing people like Grassley and not us, we’ll start a real Democratic Party and let this bunch of elitist fools go to hell.