The malfeasance committed by the Coleman camp with their star witness Pamela Howell may well have knocked away whatever remained of the Coleman case, which as TPM’s Eric Kleefeld notes was already on shaky ground with their admission that the 132 missing ballots from a Minneapolis precinct did indeed exist: "This past Monday night, the court denied Franken’s motion for summary judgment on this — but it was only because the existence of the ballots was still a point of factual contention in the case. Furthermore, the court acknowledged in their opinion the body of case law pointing to including the votes. But they had to settle the factual dispute." If the facts are all settled, that’s all, folks — at least for the trial phase. We can then move on to the appeal to the Minnesota Supreme Court.
How weak is Norm’s case? Kleefeld stated last Tuesday — and remember, this is before the Coleman case was buffeted by the Howell catastrophe and the admission that the missing Minneapolis ballots really had existed after all — that a recent ruling by the Election Contest Court showed that the court had serious doubts as to whether the Coleman case could actually succeed on the merits. This, after the Coleman team spent five weeks presenting it in court!
And as frequent FDL commenter Sara notes, the ECC is going to be looking today at the Franken call for summary judgment to dismiss the case in its entirety. If the ECC grants the Franken summary judgment motion, then Al Franken could be seated in a few weeks if not days. Fingers crossed!
Even worse, the whole rationale for the Coleman camp’s carrying on what they know is a lost cause — the desire to delay Franken’s being seated and hope that the Republicans have enough senators to block Democratic legislation — may be rendered moot by Jim Bunning’s temper tantrum in Kentucky. From the Louisville Courier-Journal, by way of Howie Klein over at DownWithTyranny!, we discover the following:
Already in conflict with his party’s leaders, Sen. Jim Bunning has reportedly said privately that if he is hindered in raising money for his re-election campaign he is ready with a response that would be politically devastating for Senate Republicans: his resignation.
The Kentucky Republican suggested that possible scenario at a campaign fundraiser for him on Capitol Hill earlier this week, according to three sources who asked not to be identified because of the politically sensitive nature of Bunning’s remarks.
The implication, they said, was that Bunning would allow Kentucky Gov. Steve Beshear, a Democrat, to appoint his replacement– a move that could give Democrats the 60 votes they need to block Republican filibusters in the Senate.
“I would get the last laugh. Don’t forget Kentucky has a Democrat governor,” one of the sources quoted Bunning as saying.
“The only logical extension of that comment is, ‘(Make me mad) … enough and I’ll resign, and then you’ve got 60 Democrats,’ ” said another source who was present at the event.
That was the clear message Bunning was sending, said a third source who heard the senator’s remarks at the fundraiser, which attracted about 15 people.
…“Why would he say that?” attendees asked each other, according to the source.
One source said he contacted a Bunning campaign official and warned, “This is going to get out– there were 15 to 20 people who heard this and it’s newsworthy.”
Now, Bunning almost immediately issued a pro forma denial, but the bell was already rung. When well over a dozen of the state’s most well-connected people hear you say something, it’s kinda tough to pretend it never happened. Denied or not, as Howie says, the message was already sent to Miss Mitch McConnell and the other high-powered Republicans trying to force Bunning to forego his re-election campaign (as they know he’ll go down in flames) and serve out the residue of his term while somebody else runs in his stead.



12 Comments








Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About FDL Action
the repuglitard death spiral has reached a new stage
KITSCH
nailed em
hey lushbo, we got yer number
Hey, freepatriot, thanks for the linky. The comments over there are fascinating.
One month since Franken went before the MN Supreme Court asking for an immediate certificate. Court said a decision was forthcoming. A month later and still nothing?
The MN SC doesn’t want this appealed to the Federal level. Giving Al a cert before Norm’s finished with his court challenge would be in direct violation of state law — and that would enable Normie and Crew to drag this out an extra six months. Right now, we’re on track to be done, as Al says, in two to three weeks.
Why won’t they just say they won’t rule, then? It’s odd (not in a biased way) that they said a ruling was coming, and then have been silent. I guess there’s a chance they’re going to rule a certificate must be issued after the recount is certified, but are waiting for the Coleman suit to finish first. That way no interference and they can clarify the conflicting MN statutes.
at this point, can’t some MN resident sue for judicial relief on the basis that their state is being denied adequate representation at a critical time in the US Senate, due to frivilous and obstructive legal maneauvering ont he part of the rethug party and the Coleman camp?
Well, assuming that Coleman loses, he can always run against Klobuchar in 2012. /s
DIGG is Open Pups!
I am happy to see the repukes wasting their money on this case! And I am sad that Minnesota is still short one Senator! Coleman should be sent to the hinterlands of Minnesota in mid winter naked for all this mess he created. He got into office by dirty tricks and he is now living with the results and he is just too fucking stupid to realize it!
I think it’s bizarre coleman can lose decision after decision malfeasance all over the place and franken cannot win a summary judgement
they know they can’t win but for as long as possible they don’t want the democrats having another vote
me wants franken and fast
Ya know, the longer this lasts, the more the NRSC fundraises and spends on it, the less prepared they are to defend their incumbents in 2010. I wish Al Franken godspeed, but I’m happy to have this clusterfuck cost Norm & the NRSC big bucks. Because those bucks won’t be available to spend in 2010.
On the other hand, of course, Minnesota deserves two Senators, and Senate Democrats need 59.
Yes, but this is still funnier. Well, mostly.
It’s hard to imagine Beshear, even though a Democrat, naming a Democrat to fill Bunning’s seat in the Senate. It is still Kentucky, after all. Maybe I’m just too used to our current Democrats’ accomodating, capitulating ways.