As of 03:31:10 pm Central Standard Time today, Norm Coleman’s lead over Al Franken has dropped to 206 votes:
| Totals | Pct | Graph | ||
| Independence | DEAN BARKLEY | 437389 | 15.16 | |
| Republican | NORM COLEMAN | 1211565 | 41.99 | |
| Democratic-Farmer-Labor | AL FRANKEN | 1211359 | 41.98 | |
As Nate Silver explains at FiveThirtyEight.com, any cuts in Norm’s lead before the results are finalized this week is really bad news for Coleman:
Until now, however, we have been assuming that ballot tabulation errors are equally likely to favor Franken and Coleman — but this is probably not the case. Why not? There is substantial evidence that undervotes and overvotes are significantly more common among what we might call vulnerable voters — in particular, minorities, elderly voters, low-income and low-education voters, and first-time voters. A 2001 study for the House Committee on Government Reform, found that undervoted ballots were more than twice as common in minority-heavy, low-income precincts than in predominately white, upper-income precincts — even when using the relatively reliable, precinct-based optical scanning system that Minnesota uses. (The discrepancies are significantly higher when using less reliable technologies like punch cards.)
While Minnesota’s elderly tended to favor Coleman, all the other groups cited in this paragraph of Nate’s did not. In fact, most of them went for Franken by large margins.
Nate, working from a 221-vote figure, gave Franken between a 39.3% and a 44.3% percent chance of winning; I suspect that, with the new 206-vote figure, the odds in favor of Franken may have topped 50%.



25 Comments








Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About FDL Action
PW, if Norm gets dragged off to jail does the governor appoint or a new election?
This is so good!
Just dreaming…
Franken raises his hand and takes the oath from – Shooter!
You can be sure that bama’s legal team is there. We can hope for the best.
Hey, Normie, just for your information: this is NOT a mandate.
I know I’d like to raise my hand for Shooter. Guess how many fingers.
Just make sure he has not had a couple of beers.
Good news, PW. More of the same is that in MN if the intent of the voter can be determined, the vote is counted, i.e., ballots are not discarded on technicalities.
I love seeing Norm go down. It’s so pleasing to the soul.
Horsey cartoon – Somewhere near Wasilla just to keep you all smiling!
Ha-haaaaa! Actually, that’s exactly what I imagine the Palin home looking like.
w00T!
great news PW
Similar situation in Alaska. Without the history of clean counting.
more good news I hope
Anyone know anything about McCaskill succeeding Howard Dean? I’ve heard it several times today. Wouldn’t she be better off staying a senator? Who would replace her, if she took the job?
i LOVE this news.
She’d be able to stay on, I think. Isn’t that what Dole was doing for the GOP?
Aha. I didn’t realize that. But then Dole did such a great job, didn’t she?
HA! Forgot to watch out for her ownself! And had such good judgment that she let someone talk her into the godless ad.
I think that was Mel Martinez of Florida but same difference.
2008 Repug strategy … “Beat a dead Horse”
Digg
Hasn’t Reid tried to convince Franken, in the spirit of bipartisanship of course, to withdraw from the race. Why go through a messy recount when it might give the impression that Democrats are sore losers?
Looks like Nate is pegging recent calculations at just over 52% for Franken!
http://www.fivethirtyeight.com…..dness.html
Cross your fingers and hold your breath!
That is great news but off topic for one moment, that puppycam
has made my day. Thank you
I’m growing concerned about Alaska. Suddenly there are 10,000 MORE uncounted ballots (absentee and “questioned”). If I count right most of those (about 75%) are coming from Mat-Su (Palin’s Wasilla area) and Areas 27-36 which are pro-Stevens in the tabulated votes.
Maybe someone is gaming the vote.